The headline for this thread is a bit sensationalist for my liking but ill bite.
Use Dustin Brown's recent contract as a comparable for Callahan. I think 5.5 for some number of years is a fair number for Cally and NYR as Cally is good player but a notch below Dustin Brown in terms of skill IMO.
Girardi is an anchor to our blueline and a great player, but he is a very prototypical stay at home defenseman. He does not have great outlet vision and his shot is very inaccurate. Somewhere in the 5-5.5 mill range seems appropriate.
Hand Hank a blank check and hope he doesn't bend us over a barrel. He earns every dollar of what he gets and then some.
Just for a comparable, to show how much of a pay increase these 3 would get if we were to resign all 3 to my proposed deals.
Callahan: 4.3 --> 5.5 = $1.2 mil
Girardi: 3.3 --> 5.3 = $2 mil
Lundqvist: 6.875 --> 8.5 = $1.625 mil
Total $14.475 mill --> 19.3 mill = $4.825 raise
Considering the cap is expected to go up to around 70 million, and we are more than likely going to buyout Richards next summer, i think this is pretty reasonable.