Dynasty Isles were notorious chokers before the first Cup. They were the Leafs of the 1970s. Great seasons followed by weak playoffs. Rangers twisted the knife in 1979. That’s why they hate us even after the Cups. 1979 was as bad as 1994 in terms of morale. In 1979-80, Isles were dead and going nowhere late in the season. Arbor was out of answers. Torrey had a deal with Sather to get a young Messier from Edmonton but it fell through, so he traded his most popular players - Lewis and Harris — to the Kings for Goring. Isles cried like babies at the goodbyes. But it was a message from Torrey. That group was tight and he was willing to break it up. Rest is history. Players stepped up.
Mike Keenan went to the finals three times and lost before coming here. In between were horrible upsets in 1986 and 1991. He bullied Smith telling him he knew the kind of players it would take to win. Hawks in 1991 won Pres. Trophy and were embarrassed in R1 by weak North Stars. Larmer, Noonan, Hudson, and Gilbert were on that team. Sound familiar? Next season, Hawks go to the Cup.
Same happened in Detroit when they brought in Scotty Bowman after too many early exits. Red Wings were a joke in the playoffs with peak Yzerman and Fedorov. Notorious chokers. Were first No. 1 seed to lose to a No. 8 (to expansion Sharks and the “Dirtbag Line”) and Bowman was coach. Went to Cup next season, CF after that, then B2B Cups. Players stepped up.
Quebec suffered a bad upset in 1995 then won the Cup in 1996 as Colorado. After that Cup they got upset bad two seasons later by a 7 seed and blew a 3-1 lead. Drury wasnt part of it but probably heard all the stories from Sakic about why Crawford was fired and Hartley (a real asshole BTW) replaced him. Those Avs could not score on Cujo for three straight games. Drury’s first four years with Hartley was CF, CF, SCF, CF. Players stepped up.
Bruins suffered playoff humiliation in 2009 and 2010. Gorton built a chunk of those teams and pushed management to give Tim Thomas a chance. Julien was coach for all of it and Boston wanted his head after they blew the 3-0 lead in R2. But they kept him and won the Cup in 2011. Players stepped up.
Devils were chokers after 1995. Big time. Lou was at his wits end. He fired Robbie Ftorek (another asshole) with a few weeks left in the 2000 season and begged Larry Robinson to take over. Devils changed on a dime in-season and won the Cup. Same with Pens and Bylsma after that douche Therrien was fired in 2008-09. Same with Blues and Berube after “Clueless Yeo” was canned in 2018-19. Players stepped up.
Tampa was a mess after 2013. Went to CF in 2011 then regressed and missed playoffs. They fired Guy Boucher and his scar in-season and brought in Cooper. Instant turnaround because he’s hockey’s Phil Jackson, but took a lot of crushing losses to get to Cups. Players stepped up.
Moral of the story: Coaching helps but one man can only do so much. Playoff humiliation and disappointment always precedes a title. Players’ ego gets crushed and they’re humbled, which shifts their focus and habits, especially in the offseason. Eyes on the prize.
IMHO, it doesn’t matter who’s hired. This is a young-ish team and core is locked up. They will learn from this and get to a Cup eventually. I predict within 2-3 years, mostly because of Igor. Few roster changes are necessary, maybe a blockbuster if possible.