It kind of goes beyond just Keefe though.... the Leafs signed Matt Martin and then Babcock sent him to the pressbox. Loved that signing at the time. Wayne Simmonds was a good signing....even though he was on the decline - wasn't he pretty effective as a net front presence on the PP, but then he was taken off that.
It's nice to have a player like Reaves - yes he has struggled when it comes to allowing opponents to score, but maybe that is more of the way he is used/deployed.?
Isn't this kind of a circular argument though - the team needs at least one tough player...look at Tampa last year - Maroon, Bogosian, Jeannot - they lose Maroon and sign Auston Watson this year......Florida - Bennett, Gudas, Lomberg, maybe Cousins, Tkachuck. So what is the solution...... I wouldn't be opposed to using Reaves sparingly I guess. What about Clifford? I think he was pretty effective when he was in the lineup and it seems like he was ostracized for taking the major in the playoff game against Tampa. Isn't he just on an AHL deal? What other options are out there......Nic Deslaurier?
Take out Reaves and what does this current team have.......not much. I really don't like having almost zero toughness on this team. Wouldn't it be nice to have a Reaves we could dress against teams like Florida or Tampa? Yes I know toughness is a team quality/mentality, but still nice to have that type of player in the lineup even if only ocassionaly.