Why are people acting like it’s insane for Vegas to want a top tier first line centre? They’re a good team that has a gaping hole at that position. If the price isn’t too high, it’s a no brainer. They’re in a win-now position so waiting for centres to (possibly) develop isn’t logical.
Seravalli: Vegas and Buffalo working on framework of Eichel trade
- Thread starter MMC
- Start date
- Status
The Moose is Loose
Registered User
Cool. I’m sure the fans would be thrilled to get Eichel and have another conference final banner to hang at T-Mobile.
Avs44
Registered User
- May 16, 2011
- 21,884
- 10,661
Theodore is a 26 year old top pairing defenseman with an incredibly friendly 4 years at 5.2 million left on his deal...you think Eichel, after all of this, is actually going to return that sort of asset + a top centre prospect + a forward like Tuch/Smith, + two 1sts, + another prospect...?
As an Avalanche fan I absolutely hope you're right. I would love to see Vegas do that. But I gotta say, I think the expectation of that return is out to lunch. And again, I genuinely hope you're right and that if Vegas does get Eichel they do have to gut themselves to that extent -- I'd love to come back and laugh at my post.
Dadonov and Smith will end up with similar production by the end of the season. 20+ goals and 50 points. Dadonov was picked up relatively cheap and has another year. Smith is a UFA in the summer so it makes sense to have him in the conversation, even if he adds more than Dadonov on the ice.
Vegas don't need to be top of the division to be contenders for the cup, they just need to be in the playoffs and have everyone fit.
Vegas don't need to be top of the division to be contenders for the cup, they just need to be in the playoffs and have everyone fit.
then the get rid of Jan mark too?
if eichel has been. On ir then shouldn’t his cap decrease?
So no. Lets stay on topic and not throw up a bunch of hypotheticals to avoid answering the question.
This has to be one of the worst proposals I have ever seen on these boards. You people need to come to terms with the FACT that Eichel may not ever return and even if the surgery is a success he will still be out for a significant part of the season. No one is going to pay that much for a giant "?" of a player who may not even return to his previous form.
Dipsy Doodle
Rent A Barn
- May 28, 2006
- 76,984
- 21,714
Like every other team, they'd prefer the Cup.
But you're conveniently ignoring that the Lightning are literally the only team that's been more successful than the Knights the last 2 years.
There are 30 other teams that'd love to be the type of "losers" the Knights have been over that period.
They need a true 1C, that has been one of the obvious missing pieces in the last 2 years.
Anaheim had a good core of young players to work around. They started being playoff threats with their 03 Finals run and outside a small handful of off years they never went into a rebuild until a couple years ago.
When Vegas fizzles out they're likely going to need a hard rebuild. Pacioretty has maybe two or three more good years. Stone maybe four. The Karlsson line is never going to be better than they are now. Tuch doesn't seem like he'll be much more than a 40 maybe 50 point guy. Pietrangelo already looks to be somewhat outside his prime. Martinez has maybe two good years left.
You trade Theodore and Krebs and it won't be long until Eichel is centering a Calgary-esque playoff bubble team with no threat to win a cup. I understand as well as anyone how "win-now" Vegas is. But their aggressive trade and sign strategy will bite them in a hurry and especially if Eichel doesn't recover 100%
Skinnyjimmy08
WorldTraveler
- Mar 30, 2012
- 22,905
- 12,734
It'll be an ugly mix of players(dadanov, janmark etc) equalling a cap total that matches Eichels... then VGK will also have to add top prospects(Krebs and another) and conditional picks
Essentially it'll be a very attractive prospect/pick package for eichel with a few roster guys for Cap reasons
Essentially it'll be a very attractive prospect/pick package for eichel with a few roster guys for Cap reasons
Last edited:
Can someone explain why Tuch isn't included in in the expected Vegas package? I sorted through a bunch of the thread, but I didn't see a similar question.
With all Vegas' injuries, shouldn't it be a forgone conclusion that a guy already on LTIR should go back to Buffalo? Also don't they need to send out salary?
Something like Tuch, Krebs, 1st as a base and then add Brossoit and Anderson to the deal to help make the dollars work?
Obviously Eichel couldn't play until the playoffs to make the deal cap compliant. If he does come back they could always make a second deal to clear some cap.
With all Vegas' injuries, shouldn't it be a forgone conclusion that a guy already on LTIR should go back to Buffalo? Also don't they need to send out salary?
Something like Tuch, Krebs, 1st as a base and then add Brossoit and Anderson to the deal to help make the dollars work?
Obviously Eichel couldn't play until the playoffs to make the deal cap compliant. If he does come back they could always make a second deal to clear some cap.
There are 30 (now 31) teams who have accomplished the same thing Vegas has in the past 3 years. If you’re happy with good seasons ending with disappointing results then more power to you. Just being a solid contender gets old when the ending becomes predictable.
Ledge And Dairy
Registered User
Thats what you gathered? Not that the trades are completely unrealistic, hell if were talking about Theodore's value then say its worth more than injured Eichel
TheFinalWord
Registered User
- Apr 25, 2005
- 2,245
- 882
How bitter are you? You keep posting the same thing trying to dismiss Vegas. As a Leaf fan, I'm going to go out on a limb and say Vegas has had more success than the Leafs over the past....well over their entire existence. They may shoot themselves in the foot with this trade, but they're going for it. Good for them and their fans.
Djp
Registered User
if all it was going to be was cap dumps to match salary a coup,e 1sts and 2nds and a few B prospects then Eichel woukd have been traded at the draft.
Skinnyjimmy08
WorldTraveler
- Mar 30, 2012
- 22,905
- 12,734
Since the draft, his value has dropped significantly. At that point if a team offered that, Sabres would have said NO... but now, it's a different story. Each day that passes, makes it more likely Eichel misses the whole season and makes this whole situation worse, which makes his value continue to drop.
Eichel is supposed to be in his prime right now... he's missing a massive season right in the middle of his prime due to a very serious injury. It's terrifying to bring in a massive contract when it's a complete unknown how he will be afterwards
- Status
