Tim Stutzle vs Auston Matthews Contracts Included

[MavisGoldberg]

You realize the difference between Stutzle and Matthews contract is pretty much the exact amount Tarasenko signed for, right? I’m not even a sens fan but that’s just silly

I’d rather have Stutzle + Tarasenko for sure

Ok, but is he really that good in 2023? And Pinto is not signed...

 

[CDJ]

Ok, but is he really that good in 2023? And Pinto is not signed...

Yeah he’s pretty good! In a down year he had 50 points in 60something games. He was more than a ppg the year prior! I would def rather have Stutzle + Tarasenko than just Matthews

And again just because their GM is an idiot and didn’t leave money for Pinto doesn’t change what we are talking about here in re: to the difference in their contracts. Having an extra $5 mill lets you go out and get a really good player or get other extensions done , there should be no debating that.

 

[MavisGoldberg]

Yeah he’s pretty good! In a down year he had 50 points in 60something games. He was more than a ppg the year prior! I would def rather have Stutzle + Tarasenko than just Matthews

And again just because their GM is an idiot and didn’t leave money for Pinto doesn’t change what we are talking about here in re: to the difference in their contracts. Having an extra $5 mill lets you go out and get a really good player, there should be no debating that.

Ok and Leafs signed Max Domi, who had 56 points last year and his cap hit is 3 million, I think that proves my point.

 

[CDJ]

Ok and Leafs signed Max Domi, who had 56 points last year and his cap hit is 3 million, I think that proves my point.

It really doesn’t

 

[MavisGoldberg]

It really doesn’t

Domi is a beetter signing. Leafs do get good value on contracts. Tarasenko is not a great signing at all.

 

[Golden_Jet]

Domi is a beetter signing. Leafs do get good value on contracts. Tarasenko is not a great signing at all.

Well if you don’t like Tarasenko, then substitute in the Chychurn contract, little less than 5 million.

 

[ViewsFromThe6ix]

Stutzle very easily. Even ignoring contracts, I'm not sure if Matthews is better than Stutzle

HF Boards at its finest.

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

This poll was always wrong but now It's hilarious

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

HF Boards at its finest.

This poll was always wrong but now It's hilarious

Yeah two games into the season. HF boards at it's finest.

 

[ViewsFromThe6ix]

Yeah two games into the season. HF boards at it's finest.

We have a 5+ year sample of Matthews being one of the 5 best players in the league. One down year and somehow Stutzle is equal

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

Yeah two games into the season. HF boards at it's finest.

Have you seen Matthews this season?

 

[All Mod Cons]

We have a 5+ year sample of Matthews being one of the 5 best players in the league. One down year and somehow Stutzle is equal

Matthews slots in right behind Laine.

 

[WillTheThrill]

Laine better
Boeser better
Barzal better
Petterson better
Stutzle better

HF continues to deny Matthews greatness

 

[All Mod Cons]

Contracts included, I'd have to go for Matthews.

 

[34]

What a joke of a thread. Best goal scorer in the world is losing a pole with a bunch of Leafs haters voting, to a Stützle who has never won a scoring title in his life. He could not hold Matthews jock strap.

 

[MCR74]

What a joke of a thread. Best goal scorer in the world is losing a pole with a bunch of Leafs haters voting, to a Stützle who has never won a scoring title in his life. He could not hold Matthews jock strap.

But he's saving the team $5M! They can buy a shit ton of jock straps with that money.

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

Yeah two games into the season. HF boards at it's finest.

To be fair, your take was ridiculous when you made it. You said you weren't sure if the guy who scored 60 goals and won a Hart Trophy may be better than Tim Stutzle

 

[MCR74]

To be fair, your take was ridiculous when you made it. You said you weren't sure if the guy who scored 60 goals and won a Hart Trophy may be better than Tim Stutzle

Brilliant.

 

[Miro4Norris]

What a joke of a thread. Best goal scorer in the world is losing a pole with a bunch of Leafs haters voting, to a Stützle who has never won a scoring title in his life. He could not hold Matthews jock strap.

Chill leafs fanbois it's 2 games against mid/bad teams. Stutzle outscored AM last year, is much younger, earns 5m less and has longer term.

 

[TheBeastCoast]

Chill leafs fanbois it's 2 games against mid/bad teams. Stutzle outscored AM last year, is much younger, earns 5m less and has longer term.

Yeah it's not like the guy scored 60 the year before or anything. It's just these two games against bad teams. You nailed it.

 

[MCR74]

Yeah it's not like the guy scored 60 the year before or anything. It's just these two games against bad teams. You nailed it.

We keep hearing about this magical $5M. Dorion's the GM, so it wouldn't make a lick of difference.

 

[34]

Chill leafs fanbois it's 2 games against mid/bad teams. Stutzle outscored AM last year, is much younger, earns 5m less and has longer term.

Matthews has won multiple Rockets. not to mention the Ted Lindsay and Hart as well.


you can not be serious.

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

To be fair, your take was ridiculous when you made it. You said you weren't sure if the guy who scored 60 goals and won a Hart Trophy may be better than Tim Stutzle

The same Stutzle that outscored him last year as a 20 year old?

 

[34]

The same Stutzle that outscored him last year as a 20 year old?

lmao, you are not fooling anyone.

 

[ViewsFromThe6ix]

The same Stutzle that outscored him last year as a 20 year old?

How do you still not see the issue with comparing ONE career season from Stutzle to a season where Matthews was playing through injury and just came off a hart, lindsay and back to back rocket?

Matthews' floor season was Stutzle's peak.