Speculation: Roster Building Thread - Part XXII

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
Most talented? We have a ways to go to even compete for a playoff position this year. How have we really closed the gap on the teams that dominated us last season plus we also have to contend with Montreal, Tampa, Florida, Carolina and Toronto who we didn't even play last year and who all made the playoffs. I do agree with the solidify/stabilize center position which until that is done I do not believe this team will take the next step.

you do realize that under the normal format they would have gotten in and Montreal wouldn’t have right? I bet the Rangers wish they got to play those north teams too, they sucked.
 
Most talented? We have a ways to go to even compete for a playoff position this year. How have we really closed the gap on the teams that dominated us last season plus we also have to contend with Montreal, Tampa, Florida, Carolina and Toronto who we didn't even play last year and who all made the playoffs. I do agree with the solidify/stabilize center position which until that is done I do not believe this team will take the next step.
talent was not the issue. We have all the talent we need. Coaching and roster makeup were 2 of the biggest issues. Covid didn't help but all teams dealt with it to some extent
 
  • Like
Reactions: bl02 and haveandare
you do realize that under the normal format they would have gotten in and Montreal wouldn’t have right? I bet the Rangers wish they got to play those north teams too, they sucked.
Thats not actually true, if you go back and look the rangers just fall outside.
Nyi
Pitt
Wsh
Car
Tor
Bos
Fla
Tb

All had higher point totals than us.
We were the 15th highest point total, but the east only gets 8 seeds.
 
Panarin, Zibanejad, Lafreniere, Kakko, Kravtsov, Chytil, Kreider, Strome

Kucherov, Point, Stamkos, Palat, Killorn, Cirelli

who has more talent? talent was never the issue. We have too much talent
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobSantos
I think you can expect the Rangers young talent to improve which will give them a boost in the standings
The way people talk, the Rangers roster players last season can't possibly be better this year despite the whole mantra of last year being "this is a super young team with a lot of players that have a lot of development to go"

IMO coaching and how the team comes together overall is going to decide whether they are a playoff team or not. They have the talent, it needs to be utilized correctly
 
I think you can expect the Rangers young talent to improve which will give them a boost in the standings
The way people talk, the Rangers roster players last season can't possibly be better this year despite the whole mantra of last year being "this is a super young team with a lot of players that have a lot of development to go"

IMO coaching and how the team comes together overall is going to decide whether they are a playoff team or not. They have the talent, it needs to be utilized correctly

Yeah and I could easily make a case that every team that made the playoffs last year will be worse next year with the exception of Florida.
 
On the center discussion. I stumbled across Tyler Seguin's stats line that I found to be so illustrative of what "works" in the NHL right now, and especially in the POs. When they went to the finals, his statline were:
Playoffs2621113
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

I am far from Seguin's biggest fan, but I mean he is a talented player, he can certainly put the puck in the back of the net and he plays in a great environment with many talented forwards. Still he only got two goals -- on a team that was successful and went to the finals.

My point is just, its not these guys that will drive a team to a cup. Ziba, definitely not Eichel. Teams just does such a good job at taking away their ice when you get deep in the POs. Who has success in the POs? There is always some noise with special teams having a big impact and what not, but from my POV its quite obvious that its the slippery centers who are awsome at carrying the puck up ice and taking it to the net and the wingers that are extremely good at finding open ice and that just can attack against a collected D. Kucherov, Pat Kane -- and most certainly Panarin.

Honestly, I am a big fan of Ziba. But I wouldn't handcuff the team for 8 years with a monster contract on him. Doing it with Eichel is organizational suicide. Get the strong match-up centers. Centers that will push back the opponents. Has the speed to skate them into the ground.
 
On the center discussion. I stumbled across Tyler Seguin's stats line that I found to be so illustrative of what "works" in the NHL right now, and especially in the POs. When they went to the finals, his statline were:
Playoffs2621113
[TBODY] [/TBODY]
I am far from Seguin's biggest fan, but I mean he is a talented player, he can certainly put the puck in the back of the net and he plays in a great environment with many talented forwards. Still he only got two goals -- on a team that was successful and went to the finals.

My point is just, its not these guys that will drive a team to a cup. Ziba, definitely not Eichel. Teams just does such a good job at taking away their ice when you get deep in the POs. Who has success in the POs? There is always some noise with special teams having a big impact and what not, but from my POV its quite obvious that its the slippery centers who are awsome at carrying the puck up ice and taking it to the net and the wingers that are extremely good at finding open ice and that just can attack against a collected D. Kucherov, Pat Kane -- and most certainly Panarin.

Honestly, I am a big fan of Ziba. But I wouldn't handcuff the team for 8 years with a monster contract on him. Doing it with Eichel is organizational suicide. Get the strong match-up centers. Centers that will push back the opponents. Has the speed to skate them into the ground.

Zibanejad won't handcuff the Rangers. Kreider's contract handcuffs the Rangers. The Rangers have Panarin and Lafrenière on the left side. Unless one of them can make the adjustment to the right side, the Rangers have a $6.5M third line left winger.

Kreider's contract is structured in a way for the Rangers to move him as soon as next summer. Kreider will have received $24.5M of the $45.5M by next July 2022. He has a $5M signing bonus due for 22-23. His salary is just $1M in 22-23. The Rangers pay the $5M signing bonus. The acquiring team pays the $21M. $1M salary followed by 4 years of $5M per. $3M is in signing bonus money. That's $4.2M per over 5 years. The Blues gave Saad $4.5M per for 5 years.

Kreider has a full NMC until 23-24. He has a say if he goes and where he goes.

The Rangers need Zibanejad. He has on pace for a 35 goal season if it was a full 82 game season. The Rangers can't discard that player and replace him with a better player. Where are they finding that better player? Mika knows NY and he has been a very good player here.
 
On the center discussion. I stumbled across Tyler Seguin's stats line that I found to be so illustrative of what "works" in the NHL right now, and especially in the POs. When they went to the finals, his statline were:
Playoffs2621113
[TBODY] [/TBODY]
I am far from Seguin's biggest fan, but I mean he is a talented player, he can certainly put the puck in the back of the net and he plays in a great environment with many talented forwards. Still he only got two goals -- on a team that was successful and went to the finals.

My point is just, its not these guys that will drive a team to a cup. Ziba, definitely not Eichel. Teams just does such a good job at taking away their ice when you get deep in the POs. Who has success in the POs? There is always some noise with special teams having a big impact and what not, but from my POV its quite obvious that its the slippery centers who are awsome at carrying the puck up ice and taking it to the net and the wingers that are extremely good at finding open ice and that just can attack against a collected D. Kucherov, Pat Kane -- and most certainly Panarin.

Honestly, I am a big fan of Ziba. But I wouldn't handcuff the team for 8 years with a monster contract on him. Doing it with Eichel is organizational suicide. Get the strong match-up centers. Centers that will push back the opponents. Has the speed to skate them into the ground.

Seguin also had like hip, groin and, knee surgery after that cup run, which is why his production was so low. I was living in Dallas, it was beyond well documented that he could barely play, cortisone shots every game, etc. He was winning faceoffs and being a leader and Dallas didn’t have anyone better to call up. Seguin’s become a pretty complete player and is not a one dimensional offensive threat anymore.

Sure, guys like Kucherov and Kane get it done in the playoffs, but part of it is just that they’re special players who have that extra gear. Deep in the playoffs, it’s honestly the random step up games from different depth guys that team’s always seem to get. A hat trick from an unknown like Kiviranta. A mini breakout from Gurianov. Depth role players that contribute in the playoffs are huge.


A46852B0-6099-44EF-922A-E1AFC7830DA0.jpeg


I was wrong, he only had surgery on the hip though. Torn labrum.
 
Last edited:
On the center discussion. I stumbled across Tyler Seguin's stats line that I found to be so illustrative of what "works" in the NHL right now, and especially in the POs. When they went to the finals, his statline were:
Playoffs2621113
[TBODY] [/TBODY]
I am far from Seguin's biggest fan, but I mean he is a talented player, he can certainly put the puck in the back of the net and he plays in a great environment with many talented forwards. Still he only got two goals -- on a team that was successful and went to the finals.

My point is just, its not these guys that will drive a team to a cup. Ziba, definitely not Eichel. Teams just does such a good job at taking away their ice when you get deep in the POs. Who has success in the POs? There is always some noise with special teams having a big impact and what not, but from my POV its quite obvious that its the slippery centers who are awsome at carrying the puck up ice and taking it to the net and the wingers that are extremely good at finding open ice and that just can attack against a collected D. Kucherov, Pat Kane -- and most certainly Panarin.

Honestly, I am a big fan of Ziba. But I wouldn't handcuff the team for 8 years with a monster contract on him. Doing it with Eichel is organizational suicide. Get the strong match-up centers. Centers that will push back the opponents. Has the speed to skate them into the ground.
Seguin had like 47 significant injuries that run from his knees to his wrists
 
I think Zibanejad could be one of those pace pushers and guys who does well in the playoffs but he (and the rest of the team) has to realize you can't go far solely relying on transition attacks and have little or no forecheck and cycle game.
He has great anticipation, great speed, is big, can push other teams back, has all the tools to do it, but he and everyone else has to be able to forecheck, punish other teams, and attack the net
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cag29
If we recall to last time, Mika and his brother in law are fairly tough negotiators. It went down to the wire on the day of the arbitration hearing. I think they will adopt the same approach of going to the 11th hour. Mid September for an extension at the earliest. Eichel stays put, too injured, too risky. Drury needs Mika extended. They can't go with both 1C and 2C set to expire especially with no appetite for Strome long term. I think Drury and Gallant believes there are options for Cs from within.
Big Kravtsov is the most pivotal piece of our rebuild
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tob
Seguin also had like hip, groin and, knee surgery after that cup run, which is why his production was so low. I was living in Dallas, it was beyond well documented that he could barely play, cortisone shots every game, etc. He was winning faceoffs and being a leader and Dallas didn’t have anyone better to call up. Seguin’s become a pretty complete player and is not a one dimensional offensive threat anymore.

Sure, guys like Kucherov and Kane get it done in the playoffs, but part of it is just that they’re special players who have that extra gear. Deep in the playoffs, it’s honestly the random step up games from different depth guys that team’s always seem to get. A hat trick from an unknown like Kiviranta. A mini breakout from Gurianov. Depth role players that contribute in the playoffs are huge.


View attachment 461666

I was wrong, he only had surgery on the hip though. Torn labrum.

Seguin had like 47 significant injuries that run from his knees to his wrists

I think the point was, you can make it without 1C production. Or, atleast, that's how I took it.

If good to great players are playing good to great, does it matter if they are left, center or right? If 2 players on the line are great top line players with the other a nice compliment piece, does it matter the order/arrangement?

So, if a center can skate, play a strong 2way game, forecheck/be relentless and not be a black hole on offense, it will be a nice compliment for our wingers.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: NYR Viper
I'll use this line to keep me optimistic for a bit. Thanks!

Kreider signed a pre-pandemic contract with the front loaded signing bonuses. Most of the money will be paid in the first two seasons and the signing bonus due for the 22-23 season. I like Kreider very much but the Rangers are paying Panarin a fortune and they need Lafreniere to play top six minutes. The Rangers should not move him from his natural side. They need for Lafreniere to become a legit first line player.
 
The team will be fine. Geez, if these star wingers can’t function without a star center guess what?, they aren’t as great as we think. Then you have to trade the wings for a center. Imo, the team is loaded and will be fine.
 
On the center discussion. I stumbled across Tyler Seguin's stats line that I found to be so illustrative of what "works" in the NHL right now, and especially in the POs. When they went to the finals, his statline were:
Playoffs2621113
[TBODY] [/TBODY]
I am far from Seguin's biggest fan, but I mean he is a talented player, he can certainly put the puck in the back of the net and he plays in a great environment with many talented forwards. Still he only got two goals -- on a team that was successful and went to the finals.

My point is just, its not these guys that will drive a team to a cup. Ziba, definitely not Eichel. Teams just does such a good job at taking away their ice when you get deep in the POs. Who has success in the POs? There is always some noise with special teams having a big impact and what not, but from my POV its quite obvious that its the slippery centers who are awsome at carrying the puck up ice and taking it to the net and the wingers that are extremely good at finding open ice and that just can attack against a collected D. Kucherov, Pat Kane -- and most certainly Panarin.

Honestly, I am a big fan of Ziba. But I wouldn't handcuff the team for 8 years with a monster contract on him. Doing it with Eichel is organizational suicide. Get the strong match-up centers. Centers that will push back the opponents. Has the speed to skate them into the ground.

Seguin shot 2.9% and he was playing with a torn labrum in his hip that required surgery causing him to miss all but three games this season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ola
Has anyone else looked at Nemeth's contract in terms of how the dollars are paid? Seems odd.

$2.5m cap hit
Year 1 - $1.5m
Year 2 - $2.5m
Year 3 - $3.5m

So it's backloaded and for a team like the Rangers, that seems like bad business, no?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad