Rank your teams player ratings for NHL 15

[Yung Rotini]

Ya I posted that in FEB.

It's probably

Gaudreau (79) - Monahan (82) - Colborne (81)
Glencross (83) - Backlund (83) - Hudler (85)
Baertschi (80) - Stajan (81) - D.Jones (81)
Galiardi (79) - Bouma (75) - McGrattan (1000000000000000000)

Brodie (85) - Giordano (87)
Smid (83) - Wideman (83)
Russell (82) - Butler (0)

Ramo (82)
Ortio (77)

Russell was not an 86 in February either.

 

[Rolo]

Saad 84 - Toews 92 - Hossa 88
Sharp 88 - Shaw 83 - Kane 89
Bickell 81 - Kruger 80 - Versteeg 81
Bollig 73 - Handzus 79 - Smith 77

Keith 91 - Seabrook 88
Hjalmarsson 86 - Oduya 82
Leddy 82 - Rozsival 80

Crawford 86
Raanta 79

 

[Mr Lebowski]

Russell was not an 86 in February either.

I know

 

[Royal Canuck]

Hall (88) - Nuge (83) - Eberle (84)
Perron (84) - Gagner (82) - Yakupov (79)
Hendricks (77) - Gordon (78) -
Joensuu (72) - Arcobello (77) - Gazdic (70)

Marincin (79) - Petry (82)
Klefbom (78) - Schultz (80)
Ference (80) -

Scrivens (82)
Fasth (81)

This what I think it should be with the current players they have.

I think you got the forwards down, but you're a little too harsh on the defence and not harsh enough on the goalies.

 

[Oilers Apologist]

Hall (87) - Nugent Hopkins (85) - Eberle (85)
Perron (85) - Gagner (82) - Yakupov (82)
Hendricks (77) - Gordon (80) - Joensuu (76)
Gazdic (73) - Lander (76) - Arcobello (77)

Horak (75) - Pitlick (75) - Yakimov (68)
Moroz (65) - Khaira (64) - Ewanyk (64)

Marincin (83) - Petry (83)
Klefbom (79) - Schultz (81)
Ference (83) - Fraser (77)

Simpson (65) - Gernat (71)
Musil (67) - Oesterle (65)

Scrivens (82)
Fasth (82)

Brossoit (68)

 

[PatriceBergeronFan]

obviously this will change based on who we resign the off-season but based on this playoffs roster...

Lucic (85) Krejci (86) Iginla (85)
Marchand ( 84) Bergeron (89) Smith (83)
Kelly (81) Soderberg (83) Ericksson ( 83)
Paille (80) Campbell (77) Thornton (74)
Spooner (77)

Chara ( 89) Seidenberg (86)
Hamilton ( 85) Boychuk (85)
Krug ( 82) Miller (78)
McQuaid ( 78)

Rask (90)
Johnson (83)

Mostly agree. I think Marchy is still 85-86, Chara 91+, Seids 87, McQuaid probably keeps his 81. Lucic might get 86. I'd give Kelly 77 but he'll be in the 80s.

 

[Mijatovic]

I for one would appreciate the game a little more if they stretched the average 4th liner to low 70's. This would give more seperation between the best and the good enough.

Don't really want every player to feel like minimal difference between others. I swear other than Datsyuk or Zetterberg(and Helm for his ridiculous speed), most players on Detroit felt like they played the same.

 

[izzy]

Steen(85)- Backes(87)-Oshie(87)
Schwartz(84)- Roy(83)-Tarasenko(86)
Sobotka(82)- Berglund(82)- Morrow (81)
Cracknell (78)- Lapierre(80)- Reaves(78)
Paajarvi(80) Porter(77) Ott (81)

J-Bo(86)- Pietrangelo(89)
Jackman(84)-Shattenkirk(88)
Leopold (80)- Polak(81)
Cole(80)

Elliott(83)
Allen (80)

These aren't mine, guesses for what EA rates them.

 

[Pierce Hawthorne]

Was actually thinking of this the other day for the

tough to tell with a lot of them, as a lot of them are having really strong if not career years.

Assuming no player hits a cold streak or a hot streak between now and seasons end, this is what I see for the Avs next season.


Oreilly(86) - Duchene(89) - McGinn(81)
Landeskog(86) - Stastny(85) - Tanguay(83)
Talbot(81) - Mackinnon(85) - Paranteau(82)
Bordeleau(75) - Mitchell(79) - McCleod(75)
Cliche(75)


Hejda(82) - EJ(85)
Benoit(78) - Barrie(84)
Holden(80) - Guenin(76)
Wilson(75) - Elliott(77)

Varlamov(87)
Berra(77)

Prospects:

Hishon(75, 4* Red)
Siemens(73, 3.5* Yellow)
Bigras(68, 4* Yellow)

Updated ratings IMO for the Avs. Landeskog and ROR both bump up to an 87 and 86 respectively after ~65 point seasons for each. Both guys will be solid all around players, Landy wil lget the slight edge because of his physicality. Duchene becomes a legitimate star in game after a PPG season, and a good(albeit brief) playoff showing. Paranteau drops after a lackluster season. Barrie gets a nice increase in both rating and potential after a big breakout season. Mack jumps in both overall and potential as well(Maybe 5* Yellow potential?).

Varlamov gets the biggest increase after a Vezina nomination, and an extremely impressive season.

 

[DatsyukToZetterberg]

Nyquist (84) - Datsyuk (93) - Franzen (85)
Weiss (82) - Zetterberg (90) - Alfredsson (84)
Tatar (82) - Sheahan (78) - Jurco (78)
Abdelkader (81) - Helm (83) - Miller (80)
Glendening (76) -

Kronwall (88) - Smith (82)
DeKeyser (84) - Ericsson (84)
Ouellet (78) - Quincey (82)
Lashoff (76) - Kindl (80)

Howard (86)
Gusatvsson (80)
Mrazek (76)

In terms of potential:

Sheahan - 3.5 Green
Jurco - 4 Yellow
Nyquist - 4.5 Yellow
Ouellet - 4 Yellow
Mrazek - 4.5 Yellow
Mantha (72) - 4.5 yellow
DeKeyser - 4 yellow
Smith - 4 yellow
Marchenko - 3.5 Green

 

[Bdravens]

Ovechkin 93-Backstrom 90 4.5Y-Johansson 82 4Y
Kuznetsov 81 4.5Y-Grabovski 83-Brouwer 84
Chimera 81-Fehr 80-Ward 83
Laich 81-Beagle 75-Wilson 78 3.5G

Alzner 85 4Y-Carlson 87 4G or 4.5y
Orlov 80 4Y-Green 83
Hillen 78-Erskine 76

Holtby 83 4G
Grubauer 76 4R


Hopefully not at all how the lines look but given the current roster that's what I expect.

 

[FlyTimmo]

Hartnell (84) - Giroux (92) - Voracek (87)
Lecavalier (82) - B. Schenn (84) - Simmonds (86)
Raffl (81) - Couturier (84) - Read (83)
Akeson (79) - Hall (78) - Rinaldo (77)

Coburn (85) - Timonen (84) -if he doesn't retire
Streit (84) - L. Schenn (83)
MacDonald (84) - Grossmann (81)

Mason (85)
Emery (79) - if resigned

Prospects who maybe make team:

Laughton (78) 4*
Gostisbehere (78) 4*
Alt (77) 3.5*
McGinn (78) 3.5*
Hagg (77) 4*
Morin (76) 4.5*

 

[King Karlsson]

Ottawa (redo)

MacArthur (84) - Turris (86) - Ryan (87)
Michalek (83) - Spezza (88) - Hemsky (84)
Hoffman (78, 3.5 green) - Zibanejad (82, 4 green) - Stone (79, 4 yellow)
Greening (76) - Smith (80) - Neil (73)
Da Costa (77, 4 red)
Condra (78)
Pageau (73, 3.5 green)
Lazar (71, 4.5 yellow)

Methot (83) - Karlsson (91)
Phillips (80) - Ceci (80, 4 yellow)
Cowen (78, 4.5 red) - Gryba (82)
Wiercioch (81, 4 yellow)
Boroweicki (77, 3 green)

Anderson (84)
Lehner (82, 4.5 green)

 

[Elvs]

2 (assuming no Selanne, Koivu, Hiller or Robidas).

Maroon (79) - Getzlaf (91) - Perry (89)
Cogliano (81) - Bonino (83) - Palmieri (78)
Beleskey (77) - Perreault (81) - Silfverberg (78)
Winnik (79) - Rakell (73) - Smith-Pelly (77)

Fowler (85) - Lovejoy (79)
Beauchemin (81) - Lindholm (80)
Allen (77) - Vatanen (77)

Andersen (82)
Gibson (78)

I wish they'd go back to the days when 90% of a team didn't consist of 80+ players. A player with 80 should be a low tier 2nd liner/good 3rd liner, or a decent #4 defenseman imo.

 

[BonMorrison]

Going by what I think EA will do, I would personally have different ratings.

Matt Cullen (81) - Mike Fisher (84) - Patric Hornqvist (83)
Filip Forsberg (77, 4.5*Y) - Colin Wilson (83, 4.0*R) - Craig Smith (84, 4.0*Y)
Nick Spaling (80) - Calle Jarnkrok (78, 4.0*Y) - Viktor Stalberg (82)
Rich Clune (71) - Paul Gaustad (80) - Eric Nystrom (79)
Patrick Eaves (77)

Roman Josi (85, 4.5*Y) - Shea Weber (93)
Mattias Ekholm (79, 3.5*G) - Ryan Ellis (81, 4.0*Y)
Michael Del Zotto (83) - Seth Jones (80, 4.5*Y)
Victor Bartley (77)

Pekka Rinne (89)
Carter Hutton (76)

 

[Deku]

(What I think EA will do)

Jenner (80, 3.5*) - Johansen (85, 4.5*) - Horton (84)
Calvert (80, 3.5*) - Dubinsky (85) - Atkinson (81, 3.5*)
Foligno (83) - Anisimov (82, 4*) - Comeau (79)
MacKenzie (77) - Letestu (79) - Boll (74)
Umberger (82)
Tropp (77)
Frattin (76, 3.5*)

Johnson (86) - Tyutin (82)
Murray (80, 4.5*) - Wisniewski (82)
Nikitin (81) - Savard (79, 4*)
Schultz (78)
Prout (77)

Bobrovsky (84, 4*)
McElhinney (76)

 

[hockeyr5]

:

Ruutu (81) - Zajac (85) - Jagr (85)
Elias (85) - Henrique (84) - Clowe (82)
Zubrus (78) - Josefon (78) - Brunner (80)
Carter (78) - Gionta (75) - Bernier (77)
Ryder (80)


Greene (83) - Fayne (80)
Salvador (77) - Zidlicky (81)
Volchenkov (80) - Merrill (79)
Larsson (79) - Gelinas (76)


Schneider (87)
Brodeur (81)

 

[GoAwayDanCleary]

What I would do...

Abdelkader (80) - Datsyuk (93) - Alfredsson (83)
Nyquist (84, 4.5★Y) - Zetterberg (90) - Franzen (84)
Tatar (82, 4★Y) - Sheahan (79, 3.5★G) - Jurco (78, 4★Y)
Miller (78) - Helm (82) - Glendening (76)

Kronwall (87) - Ericsson (83)
DeKeyser (83, 4★G) - Smith (82, 4.5★R)
Lashoff (76) - Kindl (78)
Almquist (77, 3.5★R)

Howard (85)
Mrazek (79, 4.5★Y)

 

[izzy]

Gotta wonder what Williams will be rated now

 

[Hisch13r]

I think you got the forwards down, but you're a little too harsh on the defence and not harsh enough on the goalies.

Scrivens and Fasth are good goalies

 

[Hisch13r]

:

Ruutu (81) - Zajac (85) - Jagr (85)
Elias (85) - Henrique (84) - Clowe (82)
Zubrus (78) - Josefon (78) - Brunner (80)
Carter (78) - Gionta (75) - Bernier (77)
Ryder (80)


Greene (83) - Fayne (80)
Salvador (77) - Zidlicky (81)
Volchenkov (80) - Merrill (79)
Larsson (79) - Gelinas (76)


Schneider (87)
Brodeur (81)

Elias, Jagr, Greene, Schneider should all be a little higher, besides that everything looks good.

 

[Captain Nutjob]

The Pens will probably make some moves, but as of now, here's how I rank them.



Kunitz (85) - Crosby (96) - Dupuis (80)
Neal (88) - Malkin (93) - Jokinen (85)
Stempniak (81) - Sutter (84) - Bennett (82)
Glass (78) - Adams (75) - Vitale (76)

Extras: Megna (76) - Pyatt (74)

Letang (88) - Maatta (84)
Niskanen (86) - Martin (85)
Orpik (82) - Despres (80)

Extras: Bourtuzzo (78) - Scuderi (79)

Fleury (87-88)
Zatkoff (80)​

 

[Deku]

Gotta wonder what Williams will be rated now

I'm guessing 86/87.

 

[Malakian#13]

Gaborik (87) - Kopitar (90) - Brown (85)
Pearson (80) - Carter (88) - Toffoli (83)
Clifford (76) - Richards (84) - Williams (84)
King (78) - Stoll (81) - Lewis (79)
Nolan (75)

Muzzin (82) - Doughty (92)
Mitchell (82) - Voynov (83)
Martinez (82) - Greene (78)
Regher (82) - Schultz (77)

Quick (90)
Jones (79)

No responses.. guess that means I nailed it!

 

[jonyro84]

Jones should be 81-82 . Brown 83-84 but other than that looks good