Rank your teams player ratings for NHL 15

  • PLEASE check any bookmark on all devices. IF you see a link pointing to mandatory.com DELETE it Please use this URL https://forums.hfboards.com/

Malakian#13

Registered User
Mar 7, 2003
3,060
0
Seattle
Visit site
Gaborik (87) - Kopitar (90) - Brown (85)
Pearson (80) - Carter (88) - Toffoli (83)
Clifford (76) - Richards (84) - Williams (84)
King (78) - Stoll (81) - Lewis (79)
Nolan (75)

Muzzin (82) - Doughty (92)
Mitchell (82) - Voynov (83)
Martinez (82) - Greene (78)
Regher (82) - Schultz (77)

Quick (90)
Jones (79)
 

dougie1107

Registered User
Jul 6, 2012
442
1
Memphis
Cullen (82) - Fisher (83) - Hornqvist (84)
Bourque (79) - Jarnkrok (77) - Smith (84)
Spaling (80) - Wilson (81) - Stalberg (80)
Clune (70) - Gaustad (78) - Nystrom (76)

Josi (85) - Weber (93)
Del Zotto (82) - Ellis (83)
Ekholm (77) - Jones (81)
Bartley (74)

Rinne (89)
Hutton (77)
 

The Rage Kage

Registered User
Apr 21, 2014
6,257
5,118
Hartnell (84) - Giroux (91/92) - Voracek (86/87)
Lecavalier (82) - Schenn (83/84 - 4 yellow) - Simmonds (85)
Read (82/83) - Couturier (84 - 4 green) - Akeson (77 - 3.5 yellow)
Rinaldo (72 - 3 yellow) - Hall (74) - Raffl (76 - 3 yellow)

Laughton (75 - 4 green)

*Timonen (84) - (Coburn (85)
Macdonald (83) - Streit (84)
Grossman (79/80) Schenn (82 - 4 yellow)

^Ghostisbehere (70-78 - 3-4 green)

Mason (84/85)
Emery (77)

Stolarz (60-70 range - 3.5 yellow)

*assuming timonen plays, even if he retires he will likely be in the game still.

^Ghost should be in the game within the first few roster updates, he's one if the flyers best prospects and has a chance at making the team to start the season.
 
Last edited:

That Habs Fan

Registered User
Nov 29, 2008
9,419
1,994
Toronto
Pacioretty(88)-Desharnais(81)-Gallagher(84)
Galchenyuk(83)-Plekanec(86)-Bourque(83)
Prust(80)-Eller(84)-Briere(81)
Moen(78)-White(77)-Weise(80)

Gorges(84)-Subban(90)
Markov(85)-Emelin(84)
Beaulieu(79)-Weaver(81)
Tinordi(78)

Price(91)
Budaj(78)
Tokarski(76)

Regular season and playoff performances taken into account
 
Last edited:

SmokesLetsGo

Registered User
Dec 10, 2013
55
0
Central NJ
Pacioretty(88)-Desharnais(81)-Gallagher(84)
Galchenyuk(83)-Plekanec(86)-Bourque(83)
Prust(80)-Eller(84)-Briere(81)
Moen(78)-White(77)-Weise(80)

Gorges(84)-Subban(90)
Markov(85)-Emelin(84)
Beaulieu(79)-Weaver(81)
Tinordi(78)

Price(91)
Budaj(78)
Tokarski(76)

Regular seasonand playoff performances taken into account

Desharnais just had a 50+ point season, should he be maybe like an 82 or 83? He is pretty good offensively and okay defensively from what I have seen.
 

That Habs Fan

Registered User
Nov 29, 2008
9,419
1,994
Toronto
I am one of his strongest detractors. He should get low 70s and no more than 3* for phsyicality and shot, and his defense isn't that great IMO (especially faceoffs).

But you may be right, anywhere from 80-83 would be fine.
 

Yung Rotini

6 Summers
May 18, 2013
18,333
938
Penticton, BC
LEAFS (some of you are overrating them too much)

JVR (86/87-Bozak (84)-Kessel (89/90)
Lupul (85)-Kadri (84)-Clarkson (82/83)
Raymond (80)-Bolland (83)-Kulemin (82/83)
Bodie (73-75)-McClement (80)-Ashton (73-75)
Orr (68)-Holland (78)

Gunnarson (83)-Phanuef (88-89)
Franson (84)-Gleason (83)
Rielly (82)-Gardiner (78)
Ranger (78)

Bernier (85-87)
Reimer (80-81) 3.20 GAA, .901 SVP

I see a lot of Leaf games, I live in T.O, I don't like the Leafs, I don't dislike the Leafs. I'm neutral


FLAMES My favourite team

Glencross (85)-Stajan (83/84)-Cammalleri (86-87)
Hudler (85)-Backlund (84)-Stempniak (81)
Jones (80)-Monahan (81)-Galiardi (80)
McGrattan (99)-Colborne (80)-Bouma (76)
Westgarth (72)

Giordano (88)-Russel (86)
Brodie (84)-Wideman (83)
Smid (84)-Butler (82)
SOB (76/77)

Ramo (83)
Berra (78)

Russell at 86
lol
 

Mr Lebowski

Go Flames
Feb 18, 2014
3,536
0
Toronto
Russell at 86
lol

Ya I posted that in FEB.

It's probably

Gaudreau (79) - Monahan (82) - Colborne (81)
Glencross (83) - Backlund (83) - Hudler (85)
Baertschi (80) - Stajan (81) - D.Jones (81)
Galiardi (79) - Bouma (75) - McGrattan (1000000000000000000)

Brodie (85) - Giordano (87)
Smid (83) - Wideman (83)
Russell (82) - Butler (0)

Ramo (82)
Ortio (77)
 

CMDEADLY

Registered User
Jun 6, 2014
786
124
Nashville Predators


Cullen (83) - Fisher (83) - Hornqvist (85)
Bourque (82) - Jarnkrok (80) - Smith (85)
Spaling (82) - Wilson (82) - Stalberg (79)
Clune (74) - Gaustad (78) - Nystrom (78)

Josi (85) - Weber (93)
Del Zotto (83) - Jones (82)
Ekholm (80) - Ellis (81)
Bartley (74)

Rinne (88)
Hutton (80)
 

BostonCreamPaille

Registered User
Apr 8, 2014
314
0
Lowell, Ma
:bruins

obviously this will change based on who we resign the off-season but based on this playoffs roster...

Lucic (85) Krejci (86) Iginla (85)
Marchand ( 84) Bergeron (89) Smith (83)
Kelly (81) Soderberg (83) Ericksson ( 83)
Paille (80) Campbell (77) Thornton (74)
Spooner (77)

Chara ( 89) Seidenberg (86)
Hamilton ( 85) Boychuk (85)
Krug ( 82) Miller (78)
McQuaid ( 78)

Rask (90)
Johnson (83)
 
May 27, 2012
17,070
856
Earth
Ya I posted that in FEB.

It's probably

Gaudreau (79) - Monahan (82) - Colborne (81)
Glencross (83) - Backlund (83) - Hudler (85)
Baertschi (80) - Stajan (81) - D.Jones (81)
Galiardi (79) - Bouma (75) - McGrattan (1000000000000000000)

Brodie (85) - Giordano (87)
Smid (83) - Wideman (83)
Russell (82) - Butler (0)

Ramo (82)
Ortio (77)

I am a Flames fan and giving Gaudreau a 79 right off the bat is meh. I am going with what they gave him in NHL 14, 77. For the most part I agree but the others not really.

Gaudreau (77) - Monahan (82) - Colborne (80)
Glencross (84) - Backlund (83) - Hudler (85)
Baertschi (79) - Stajan (81) - D.Jones (80)
Galiardi (79) - Bouma (75) - McGrattan (67)

Brodie (84) - Giordano (87)
Smid (83) - Wideman (82)
Russell (81) - Butler (79)

Ramo(81)
Backup
 

CP31

Registered User
Jun 19, 2012
1,787
3
Welland, ON
Pacioretty (88) Desharnais (83) Gallagher (84)
Galchenyuk (85) Plekanec (86) Bourque (81)
Bournival (78) Eller (83) Gionta (80)
Moen (78) Prust (78) Weise (79)
Briere (79)

Markov (84) Subban (90)
Gorges (82) Emelin (82)
Tinordi (79) Beaulieu (78)

Price (91)
Budaj (81)
 

Brock Anton

flames #badnwagon
Nov 8, 2009
21,520
12,326
Westerly, RI
:canes

Tlusty (80) - E. Staal (87) - Semin (86)
Skinner (87) - J. Staal (85) - Lindholm (79)
Gerbe (78) - Loktionov (78) - Dwyer (75)
Bowman (74) - Nash (75) - Dvorak (75)
Malhotra (76)

Faulk (84) - Sekera (85)
Liles (81) - Hainsey (82)
Harrison (77) - Murphy (75)
Bellemore (73)

Ward (85)
Khudobin (82)
 

David Suzuki

Registered User
Aug 25, 2010
18,022
9,421
New Brunswick
Pacioretty (87) Desharnais (82) Gallagher (83)
Galchenyuk (82) Plekanec (85) Bourque (82)
Bournival (77) Eller (80) Gionta (81)
Moen (76) Prust (81) Weise (80)
Briere (78) White (76)

Markov (85) Subban (91)
Gorges (82) Emelin (81)
Weaver (80) Beaulieu (76)
Tinordi (75)

Price (90)
Budaj (79)
Tokarski (78)
 

member 151739

Guest
Sharp (88) - Toews (92) - Hossa (89)
Saad (84) - Shaw (82) - Kane (90)
Bickell (80) - Handzus (75) - Versteeg (77)
Bollig (69) - Kruger (79) - Smith (79)

Keith (91) - Seabrook (89)
Oduya (83) - Hjalmarsson (87)
Leddy (83) - Rozsival (78)

Crawford (86)​
 

Nail

Registered User
Mar 21, 2014
332
229
Sedin (86) Sedin (86) Burrows (83)
Higgins (82) Kesler (86) Jensen (80)
Hansen (80) Matthias (81) Kassian (82)
Booth (80) Richardson (79) Sestito (75)
Dalpe (77)

Hamhuis (87) Tanev (83)
Bieksa (84) Edler (84)
Garrison (82) Stanton (80)

Lack (82)
Markstrom (80)
 

Dellstrom

Pastrnasty
May 1, 2011
25,361
4,119
Boston
:bruins

Lucic (86) - Krejci (87) - Iginla (85)
Marchand (85) - Bergeron (89) - Smith (82)
Spooner (75) - Soderberg (82) - Eriksson (84)
Paille (79) - Campbell (76) - Florek/Thornton (74)

Chara (92) - Hamilton (83)
Seidenberg (86) - Boychuk (85)
Krug (81) - McQuaid/Miller (79)

Rask (90)
Svedberg/Johnson/FA (~72-75)

I think Hamilton/Soderberg should be a little higher, but in reality, they'll probably be lower.
 

Trap Jesus

Registered User
Feb 13, 2012
28,686
13,457
:bruins

Lucic (86) - Krejci (87) - Iginla (85)
Marchand (85) - Bergeron (89) - Smith (82)
Spooner (75) - Soderberg (82) - Eriksson (84)
Paille (79) - Campbell (76) - Florek/Thornton (74)

Chara (92) - Hamilton (83)
Seidenberg (86) - Boychuk (85)
Krug (81) - McQuaid/Miller (79)

Rask (90)
Svedberg/Johnson/FA (~72-75)

I think Hamilton/Soderberg should be a little higher, but in reality, they'll probably be lower.

Assuming you're going by what you think EA will do, this looks pretty good.

I think Bergeron will get bumped up to a 90 with him probably being on the cover. They'll boost his shooting stats for sure.

I think Soderberg and Krug might be lower than we think. I think Krug will be high 70s and Soderberg more around 80 with him being so new. Kelly will probably be around 80 too.

I think Campbell would be more around 78.

Thornton will be higher than 74, Florek lower.

Miller will probably be mid-70s rather than high 70s.
 

AIexisLafreniereNYR

Registered Drug User
Jan 25, 2009
7,729
2,379
New York City
:rangers

Carl Hagelin (81) - Brad Richards (84) - Martin St. Louis (86)
Chris Kreider (83) - Derek Stepan (83) - Rick Nash (85)
Benoit Pouliot (81) - Derick Brassard (82) - Mats Zuccarello (84)
Brian Boyle (80) - Dominic Moore (80) - Derek Dorsett (79)
Daniel Carcillo (79) - J.T. Miller (78) - Oscar Lindberg (77)
Jesper Fast (78)

Ryan McDonagh (89) - Daniel Girardi (85)
Marc Staal (87) - Anton Stralman (83)
John Moore (81) - Kevin Klein (81)
Raphael Diaz (78) - Justin Falk (77)

Henrik Lundqvist (94)
Cam Talbot (81)
 

BonMorrison

Registered User
Jun 17, 2011
33,927
10,094
Toronto, ON
EA tends to not fluctuate too much from previous years. A lot of bad ones so I'll honor that.

Maple Leafs

James van Riemsdyk (86) - Tyler Bozak (84) - Phil Kessel (89)
Joffrey Lupul (85) - Nazem Kadri (85) - David Clarkson (83)
Mason Raymond (81) - Dave Bolland (83) - Nikolai Kulemin (82)
Carter Ashton (75) - Jay McClement (79) - Jerry D'Amigo (74)
Peter Holland (77), Colton Orr (71)

Dion Phaneuf (88) - Carl Gunnarsson (84)
Tim Gleason (85) - Morgan Rielly (81)
Jake Gardiner (82) - Cody Franson (83)
Paul Ranger (78)

Jonathan Bernier (83)
James Reimer (82)
 

Ducks Ahoy

Effort = overrated
Jun 9, 2013
2,706
1
Orange County
:ducks2

Smith-Pelly (80) - Getzlaf (92) - Perry(89-90)
Maroon (82) - Perreault (82) - Palmieri (80)
Cogliano (84) - Rakell (79) - Silfverberg (83)
Etem (78) - Bonino (83) - Winnik (80)

*if Koivu doesn't retire: 77

Fowler (85-86) - Lovejoy (82)
Lindholm (82) - Beauchemin (85)
Allen (80) - Vatanen (79)

Andersen (84)
Gibson (93):sarcasm:
 
Last edited:

RebuildTheRebuild

Registered User
Apr 27, 2013
765
34
:edmonton

Hall (88) - Nuge (83) - Eberle (84)
Perron (84) - Gagner (82) - Yakupov (79)
Hendricks (77) - Gordon (78) -
Joensuu (72) - Arcobello (77) - Gazdic (70)

Marincin (79) - Petry (82)
Klefbom (78) - Schultz (80)
Ference (80) -

Scrivens (82)
Fasth (81)

This what I think it should be with the current players they have.
 

sjsharks92

Shark Tank Commander
Jun 9, 2014
2,540
368
Bay Area, California
:sharks Lineup

Hertl 82 - Thornton 90 - Burns 87
Marleau 86 - Couture 89 - Pavelski 87
Torres 78 - Kennedy 81 - Wingels 81
Sheppard 77 - Desjardins 76 - Burish 76
Nieto 76

Vlasic 85 - Demers 84
Stuart 82 - Braun 82
Hannan 81 - Boyle 83
Irwin 79

Niemi 83
Stalock 80

Vlasic should be higher. I'd give him an 87-88. Kennedy is too high. I'd put him at 78-79.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad