Rank your teams player ratings for NHL 15

  • PLEASE check any bookmark on all devices. IF you see a link pointing to mandatory.com DELETE it Please use this URL https://forums.hfboards.com/

fedfed

@FedFedRMNB
Oct 28, 2010
4,143
0
Moscow City
Erat (81) - Backstrom (88) - Ovechkin (94)
Johansson (84) - Grabovski (84) - Brouwer (83)
Chimera (80) - Laich (80) - Ward (83)
Fehr (80) - Beagle (77) - Wilson (78)
Volpatti (75), Latta (78)
Kuznetsov (83 for now)

Alzner (85) - Carlson (86)
Orlov (81) - Green (84)
And then we have like 6 guys for the remaining spots
Erskine (76) - Carrick (77)
Schmidt (78) - Wey (77)
Hillen (78) - Strachan (75)

Holtby (84)
Neuvirth (80)
Grubauer (79)
 

Invalid Username

Registered User
Jul 13, 2012
144
0
Illinois
No offense, but unless you're actually thinking about which individual attributes you'd change, it's kind of irrelevant just posting an overall. The overall isn't as big of a deal now that they've finally focused more on individual stats.
Yeah that makes sense, but who actually wants to go through all the stats and attempt that? The way people have been doing it makes it pretty simple to see who has improved, regressed, or stayed the same since the season began.

I don't have that much time on my hands. :laugh:
 

Erik Alfredsson

Beast Mode Cowboy!
Jan 14, 2012
13,369
5,579
Hall 90 - RNH 85 - Eberle 86
Perron 85 - Gagner 82 - Yakupov 83
Hendricks 78 - Gordon 81 - Hemsky 83
Joensuu 76 - Arcobello 76 - Gazdic 70

N Schultz 78 - J Schultz 83
Marincin 81 - Petry 83
Ference 80 - Fraser 76
Belov 78

Scrivens 84
Bryzgalov 82

I don't think so.
 

Mr Lebowski

Go Flames
Feb 18, 2014
3,536
0
Toronto
LEAFS (some of you are overrating them too much)

JVR (86/87-Bozak (84)-Kessel (89/90)
Lupul (85)-Kadri (84)-Clarkson (82/83)
Raymond (80)-Bolland (83)-Kulemin (82/83)
Bodie (73-75)-McClement (80)-Ashton (73-75)
Orr (68)-Holland (78)

Gunnarson (83)-Phanuef (88-89)
Franson (84)-Gleason (83)
Rielly (82)-Gardiner (78)
Ranger (78)

Bernier (85-87)
Reimer (80-81) 3.20 GAA, .901 SVP

I see a lot of Leaf games, I live in T.O, I don't like the Leafs, I don't dislike the Leafs. I'm neutral


FLAMES My favourite team

Glencross (85)-Stajan (83/84)-Cammalleri (86-87)
Hudler (85)-Backlund (84)-Stempniak (81)
Jones (80)-Monahan (81)-Galiardi (80)
McGrattan (99)-Colborne (80)-Bouma (76)
Westgarth (72)

Giordano (88)-Russel (86)
Brodie (84)-Wideman (83)
Smid (84)-Butler (82)
SOB (76/77)

Ramo (83)
Berra (78)
 

Mr Lebowski

Go Flames
Feb 18, 2014
3,536
0
Toronto
Hall 90 - RNH 85 - Eberle 86
Perron 85 - Gagner 82 - Yakupov 83
Hendricks 78 - Gordon 81 - Hemsky 83
Joensuu 76 - Arcobello 76 - Gazdic 70

N Schultz 78 - J Schultz 83
Marincin 81 - Petry 83
Ference 80 - Fraser 76
Belov 78

Scrivens 84
Bryzgalov 82

Hall-88
Gagner-84
Yakupov-82
Scrivens-82
 
May 27, 2012
17,070
856
Earth
LEAFS (some of you are overrating them too much)


FLAMES My favourite team

Glencross (85)-Stajan (83/84)-Cammalleri (86-87)
Hudler (85)-Backlund (84)-Stempniak (81)
Jones (80)-Monahan (81)-Galiardi (80)
McGrattan (99)-Colborne (80)-Bouma (76)
Westgarth (72)

Giordano (88)-Russel (86)
Brodie (84)-Wideman (83)
Smid (84)-Butler (82)
SOB (76/77)

Ramo (83)
Berra (78)

At least my when I did the Flames( my favourite team as well) I wasn't extremely him biased as you. You are overrating some players. If you want to compare our teams mine is on the first page.
 

IonizedCookie

Registered User
Dec 29, 2012
136
1
Niagara Falls, ON
LEAFS (some of you are overrating them too much)

JVR (86/87-Bozak (84)-Kessel (89/90)
Lupul (85)-Kadri (84)-Clarkson (82/83)
Raymond (80)-Bolland (83)-Kulemin (82/83)
Bodie (73-75)-McClement (80)-Ashton (73-75)
Orr (68)-Holland (78)

Gunnarson (83)-Phanuef (88-89)
Franson (84)-Gleason (83)
Rielly (82)-Gardiner (78)
Ranger (78)

Bernier (85-87)
Reimer (80-81) 3.20 GAA, .901 SVP

I see a lot of Leaf games, I live in T.O, I don't like the Leafs, I don't dislike the Leafs. I'm neutral


FLAMES My favourite team

Glencross (85)-Stajan (83/84)-Cammalleri (86-87)
Hudler (85)-Backlund (84)-Stempniak (81)
Jones (80)-Monahan (81)-Galiardi (80)
McGrattan (99)-Colborne (80)-Bouma (76)
Westgarth (72)

Giordano (88)-Russel (86)
Brodie (84)-Wideman (83)
Smid (84)-Butler (82)
SOB (76/77)

Ramo (83)
Berra (78)

Pretty sure my Leafs roster was almost exactly like yours.. look at your flames roster though... Glencross 85... Stajan 83/84... Backlund 84... Hudler 85... Russel 86... Giordano 88... Butler 82... Ramo 83... McGrattan 99...? < proved my point your roster is just bias.
 
May 27, 2012
17,070
856
Earth
Pretty sure my Leafs roster was almost exactly like yours.. look at your flames roster though... Glencross 85... Stajan 83/84... Backlund 84... Hudler 85... Russel 86... Giordano 88... Butler 82... Ramo 83... McGrattan 99...? < proved my point your roster is just bias.

Hudler I can see being an 85.
 

Royal Canuck

Taco Enthusiast
Feb 10, 2011
12,686
549
Victoria, BC
:nucks

D.Sedin (86) - H.Sedin (86) - Burrows (82)
Higgins (83) - Kesler (86) - Kassian (82)
Booth (80) - Santorelli (81) - Hansen (81)
Sestito (74) - Richardson (77) - Lain (70)
Dalpe (72)
Horvat (72)
Schroeder (76)

Edler (84) - Bieksa (83)
Garrison (83) - Hamhuis (85)
Tanev (82) - Diaz (79)
Weber (78) - Stanton (78)

Luongo (86)
Lack (80)

Pretty fair IMO, but EA Vancouver will overrate them like they have for the past three years.
 

iFishyHD

Registered User
Dec 27, 2010
6,064
204
Pittsburgh
:nucks

D.Sedin (86) - H.Sedin (86) - Burrows (82)
Higgins (83) - Kesler (86) - Kassian (82)
Booth (80) - Santorelli (81) - Hansen (81)
Sestito (74) - Richardson (77) - Lain (70)
Dalpe (72)
Horvat (72)
Schroeder (76)

Edler (84) - Bieksa (83)
Garrison (83) - Hamhuis (85)
Tanev (82) - Diaz (79)
Weber (78) - Stanton (78)

Luongo (86)
Lack (80)

Pretty fair IMO, but EA Vancouver will overrate them like they have for the past three years.

Hamuis would at least be an 87, he made TC.
 

iFishyHD

Registered User
Dec 27, 2010
6,064
204
Pittsburgh
Hamhuis(85 in his ratings) sat, as did Subban(87/88). Vlasic(84) played. How do we determine overalls by olympic performances rather than the prior year and 4 years if you wish?

Ratings will go up. Nobody expected Vlasic or Hamuis to make TC. Subban really got EA'd in his rating. Hamuis is already and 87, how do you expect a player to drop after making TC?
 

BC96

Registered User
Jun 2, 2014
2
0
Manhattan Beach, CA
LA Kings:

Offense:
Gaborik (88-90) - Kopitar (92-93) - Brown (86)
Pearson (80-82) - Carter (89) - Taffoli (84)
King (78) Stoll (83) Williams (85-86)
Clifford (77) Richards (86) Lewis (79)

Defense:
Muzzin (86) - Doughty (93)
Mitchell (80-81) - Voynov (82-83)
Martinez (81-82) - Greene (81)

Goaltenders:
Quick (91-92)
Jones (77)

Not dressing or injured:
Regehr (83) Nolan (76)

**Keep in mind that I am basing my ratings off both regular season, but also how they have been playing in the post-season, I factor in both. I'll explain my higher ratings and why I gave them. Gaborik had a bad regular season in Columbus due to injuries and such, and was thought to be washed out and a big gamble for the Kings. With 16 points in 19 games and an insane playoffs he has proven that he may be able to play to his NY standards once again, he deserves at least an 88, at most a 90. Kopitar, what can I say about him. He was one of the most consistent point scorers during the season next to being an amazing defensive center nominated for the Selke for the first time. I would put him at a 90 but these playoffs have proven him to be one of the most dominant centers in the league who is fully capable playing alongside those the likes of Jonathan Toews and Ryan Getzlaf, and could easily compete at the same level of players like Stamkos, Malkin and even Crosby. Pearson gets upgraded for his playoff performance, Taffoli has proven to be a great young player and gets an upgrade. Jeff Carter is a 50 point+ player this season and amazing in the playoffs, possible nominee for Conn Smythe, he gets the 89. King gets a slight upgrade from 77 to 78. Stoll is too good on the faceoff to stay at an 82 and gets points here and there which deserve him the upgrade to 83. Williams was good this season, but insane these playoffs, deserving of at least an 85. Clifford's okay, gets slight downgrade. Richards, although had not the greatest season, is still a great defensive player and comes through when the team needs him, he gets downgraded to 86 from 88. Trevor Lewis has been moved down lines and is not great, gets 1 point downgrade. Muzzin has proved to be our second best defensemen and gets the 86. Probably the most controversial, is 93 for Doughty. Keep in mind that tonight during the 1st intermission, Mike Milbury called Doughty the "best defensemen in the NHL". I think he will most likely win the Conn Smythe if we win the cup. Also did you see his goal tonight? Best of the playoffs, simply amazing. I give him the 93 and expect great things from him. He is easily as good as, if not better than Weber, Chara, Keith, etc. Mitchell is okay, 80-81, Voynov is getting good, but doesn't deserve higher than 83 for now, Martinez has stepped up, especially with that goal in game 7 v Chicago, he gets 81-82, and Matt Greene has slowed down, gets a slight downgrade from 82 to 81. It would be criminal not to give Quick at least his old rating back, possibly upgrading him, but only if you also upgrade Lundqvist, I admit that Quick is either equal or a tiny bit behind Lundqvist. King Henrik is still King and Quick is not better, possibly even, but not better. They are the top 2 goaltenders in the league for sure and I don't think you can give one a higher rating because they are so close. Martin Jones came through during the season when Quick was injured, he gets a 77. Regehr doesn't deserve his old 85 rating, and has had injury problems so 83. Nolan sucks. I gave a lot of players high ratings but if you compare them to last season they aren't very far fetched and I gave multiple players downgrades. The only substantial changes are Doughty and Kopitar, but I fully support that they deserve the ratings I gave them.**
 
Last edited:

oconnor9sean

Registered User
Mar 3, 2013
6,231
2,097
DFW
The Kings are hot in the playoffs, but Brown, Carter, Toffoli and Richards are too high in your rankings. I'd say they should be (respectively): 84, 88, 82, 84. Lets not for get about how bad a regular season that Brown and Richards had.

As for the Stars:

Benn(90)-Seguin(89)-Nichushkin(82)
Roussel(81)-Eakin(82)-Garbutt(80)
Cole(81)-Fiddler(81)-Peverley(82)
Sceviour(80)-Horcoff(79)-Chiasson(80)

Daley(84)-Goligoski(85)
Dillon(83)-Benn(80)
Nemeth(79)-Gonchar(77)

Lehtonen(87)
Thomas(15)
 
Last edited:

Sharppi

4 more years of Dub.
Jul 15, 2011
6,419
2
Finland
Lets try, throwing around just somekinda lineups and things.
:wild

Parise(89)-Granlund(81)-Pominville(85)
Nino(80)-Koivu(85)-Coyle(81)
Cooke(80)-Haula(78)-Fontaine(78)
Zucker(77)-Brodziak(82)-McCormick(79)
Veilleux(77),Bulmer(77)
[Vanek? (85)]

Suter(92)-Spurgeon(84)
Brodin(82)-Folin(78)
Scandella(82)-Ballard(79)
Stoner(79)

Bäckström(82)
Harding(84)
Kuemper(80)

Mike Yeo (53)
 

NewLife

Registered User
Apr 29, 2011
4,543
357
Oslo
Kreider 83 - Stepan 85 - Nash 87
Hagelin 83 - Richards 84 - St Louis 88
Poliout 82 - Brassard 84 - Zuccarello 85
D Moore 81 - Boyle 81 - Doesett 78

McDonagh 90 - Girardi 85
Staal 86 - Strålman 84
J Moore 81 - Klein 82

Lundqvist 91
Talbot 81
 

Deku

I'm off the planet
Nov 5, 2011
19,828
4,474
Ottawa
The Sens will probably look a lot different going into next season, but here is how I would rate our current players:

MacArthur (84) - Turris (86, 4*) - Ryan (87)
Michalek (82) - Spezza (87) - Hemsky (83)
Hoffman (78, 3.5*) - Zibanejad (82, 4*) - Stone (78, 4*)
Greening (78) - Smith (79) - Neil (77)
Da Costa (79, 3.5*)
Condra (78)
Pageau (75, 3.5*)
Lazar (72, 4*)

Methot (83) - Karlsson (90, 4.5*)
Phillips (80) - Ceci (78, 4.5*)
Cowen (78, 4.5*) - Gryba (82)
Wiercioch (77, 4*)
Boroweicki (76, 3*)

Anderson (84)
Lehner (79, 4.5* or 4*)
 

vilyzz

Registered User
Apr 13, 2014
70
4
The Kings are hot in the playoffs, but Brown, Carter, Toffoli and Richards are too high in your rankings. I'd say they should be (respectively): 84, 88, 82, 84. Lets not for get about how bad a regular season that Brown and Richards had.

As for the Stars:

Benn(90)-Seguin(89)-Nichushkin(82)
Roussel(81)-Eakin(82)-Garbutt(80)
Cole(81)-Fiddler(81)-Peverley(82)
Sceviour(80)-Horcoff(79)-Chiasson(80)

Daley(84)-Goligoski(85)
Dillon(83)-Benn(80)
Nemeth(79)-Gonchar(77)

Lehtonen(87)
Thomas(15)

Thomas is abslutely 15.
 

GinoLucia2217

Great Plains
Dec 1, 2013
1,277
3
Probably Minnesota
:wild

What I think it should be

Parise(90)-Granlund(84)-Pominville(87)
Niederreiter(84)-Koivu(87)-Coyle(82)
Zucker(80)-Haula(82)-Fontaine(79)
Cooke(80)-McCormick(78)-Bulmer(78)

Suter(92)-Spurgeon(83)
Brodin(82)-Scandella(81)
Folin(79)-Blum(80)

Harding(86) sadly should have durability basically low as it can go
Kuemper(83)​

Moulson is not in the lineup because I would bet that he won't be on the team when season stars but I would give him an 84

What EA will probably do

Parise(89)-Granlund(81)-Pominville(86)
Niederreiter(82)-Koivu(87)-Coyle(81)
Zucker(79)-Haula(80)-Fontaine(80)
Cooke(81)-McCormick(76)-Bulmer(76)

Suter(91)-Spurgeon(83)
Brodin(82)-Scandella(80)
Folin(78)-Blum(80)

Harding(84)
Kuemper(81)

Lets he real the wild players are this good if they add coaching into the game then that is what will make the wild a mediocre team. Otherwise if it is strictly players an performance based geared towards accurately depicting a be a gm or season mode season then I would agree more with sharppi
 

iamthewalrus

Registered User
Aug 1, 2010
883
11
Connecticut
Kreider 83 - Stepan 85 - Nash 86
Hagelin 80 - Richards 83 - St Louis 87
Poliout 79 - Brassard 80 - Zuccarello 83
D Moore 76 - Boyle 78 - Dorsett 76

McDonagh 89 - Girardi 84
Staal 83 - Strålman 80
J Moore 79 - Klein 80

Lundqvist 93
Talbot 80

Staal should be higher, but he won't be.

Wouldn't be surprised if Nash is lower.

Zucc, Kreider, ad Brassgod should be higher, won't be.

Hank could be anywhere from 90-95

There's a chance McDonagh hits 90. however, 90 is pretty rare in the NHL series and will probably be reserved for doughty, weber, suter, ...
 

iFishyHD

Registered User
Dec 27, 2010
6,064
204
Pittsburgh
Kreider 83 - Stepan 85 - Nash 86
Hagelin 80 - Richards 83 - St Louis 87
Poliout 79 - Brassard 80 - Zuccarello 83
D Moore 76 - Boyle 78 - Dorsett 76

McDonagh 89 - Girardi 84
Staal 83 - Strålman 80
J Moore 79 - Klein 80

Lundqvist 93
Talbot 80

Staal should be higher, but he won't be.

Wouldn't be surprised if Nash is lower.

Zucc, Kreider, ad Brassgod should be higher, won't be.

Hank could be anywhere from 90-95

There's a chance McDonagh hits 90. however, 90 is pretty rare in the NHL series and will probably be reserved for doughty, weber, suter, ...

Fairly realistic, but if you guys win the cup it will be wayyyy higher.
 

Cyborg Yzerberg

Registered User
Nov 8, 2007
11,153
2,372
Philadelphia
Detroit Red Wings:

Zetterberg(91)-Datsyuk(91)-Nyquist(84)
Tatar(82)-Sheahan(81)-Jurco(80)
Franzen(83)-Weiss(81)-Alfredsson(82)
Abdelkader(80)-Helm(82)-Glendening(78)
Miller(77) Ferraro(75) Callahan(75)

Kronwall(87)-Smith(82)
Dekeyser(83)-Ericsson(82)
Kindl(78)-Ouellet(77)
Lashoff(76)

Howard(84)
Monster(78)
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad