Rank your teams player ratings for NHL 15

  • PLEASE check any bookmark on all devices. IF you see a link pointing to mandatory.com DELETE it Please use this URL https://forums.hfboards.com/

The Nuge

Some say…
Jan 26, 2011
27,959
9,160
British Columbia
:edmonton

Hall (89) - Nugent Hopkins (86) - Eberle (87)
Perron (85) - Gagner (83) - Yakupov (82)
Hendricks (77) - Gordon (81) - Joensuu (76)
Gazdic (75) - Arcobello (79) - Pitlick (77)

Marincin (81) - Petry (84)
Nikitin (82) - Schultz (81)
Ference (80) - Klefbom - (80)

Scrivens (83)
Fasth (81)
 

BC96

Registered User
Jun 2, 2014
2
0
Manhattan Beach, CA
Cup winners:

Williams(86)-Kopitar(92)-Gaborik(87)
Carter(88)-Richards(85)-Brown(84)
Toffoli(82)-Stoll(82)-King(82)
Clifford(79)-Pearson(79)-Lewis(79)

Doughty(92)-Mitchell(84)
Regehr(83)-Voynov(83)
Martinez(81)-Muzzin(82)

Quick(90)
Jones(83)

I posted my ratings and I agree with you except I think Richards is lower, about an 83-84, Gabo and Williams are higher, Gabo at 89 and Williams at 87, and Toffoli also gets an 84. Also Quick should be at least a 92.
 

plaaplaa72

Registered User
Jul 29, 2011
739
11
Helsinki
I posted my ratings and I agree with you except I think Richards is lower, about an 83-84, Gabo and Williams are higher, Gabo at 89 and Williams at 87, and Toffoli also gets an 84. Also Quick should be at least a 92.

That's pure homerism, no way Williams is an 87, Toffoli an 84 or Quick 92.

Just because they won the Stanley Cup doesn't mean they will or should bump up that much.

Williams will be most likely 84-86, Toffoli 80-82 and Quick 90-91.
 

Hansen

tyler motte simp
Oct 12, 2011
23,991
10,000
Nanaimo, B.C.
:nucks

D. Sedin (84) - H. Sedin (86) - Burrows (83)
Jensen (80) - Bonino (83) - Kassian (82)
Higgins (82) - Matthias (82) - Hansen (81)
Vey (77) - Richardson (79) - Dorsett (76)
x: Sestito (75), Lain (73), Santorelli (I expect him to be re-signed as Benning cant find any other top 6'ers - 82)

Hamhuis (86) - Bieksa (84)
Edler (84) - Tanev (83)
Sbisa (80) - Corrado (78)
x: Stanton (78), Weber (76)

Miller (86)
Lack (82)
 

Pierce Hawthorne

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Apr 29, 2012
46,007
44,261
Caverns of Draconis
:avs after free agent signings:


ROR(85) - Duchene(89) - Iginla(85)
Landy(87) - Mack(85) - Tanguay(83)
McGinn(82) - Mitchell(79) - Briere(80)
Talbot(81) - Winchester(77) - McCleod(76)

Stuart(83) - EJ(86)
Hejda(82) - Barrie(84)
Redmond(77) - Holden(80)


Varlamov(86)
Berra(77)
 

JDinkalage Morgoone

U of South Flurrida
Oct 7, 2008
15,010
3
308 Negra Arroyo Ln.
Im not gonna try lines because idk what they'll be.

Giroux - 92
Voracek - 86
Schenn - 83
Simmonds - 85
Read - 83
Couturier - 83
Lecavalier - 81
Umberger - 82
Raffl - 80
Rinaldo - 78
Akeson - 79

Coburn - 84
Grossmann - 82
MacDonald - 84
Schenn - 82
Streit - 85
Timonen - 83

Mason - 86
Emery - 81
 

99SvenBaertschi

Registered User
Jul 2, 2014
35
0
Sasktoon, SK, Canada
Boston Bruins

Marchand (86-87), Bergeron (89), Eriksson (86-85)
Lucic (87), Krejci (87-88), Iginla (84-86)
Smith (73-83), Kelly (80-79), Paille (79-77)
Thornton (76-78), Campbell (78-76), Caron (76-79)

Chara (92-91), Seidenberg (87-88)
Boychuk (85-82), Hamilton (79-83)
Morrow (74-76), Mcquaid (82-80)

Rask (87-88)
Hutchinson (73-74)


Final Lines

Lucic (87), Bergeron (89), Eriksson (85)
Marchand (87), Krejci (88), Iginla (86)
Smith (83), Kelly (79), Caron (79)
Thornton (78), Campbell (76), Paille (77)

Chara (91), Seidenberg (88)
Boychuck (82), Hamilton (83)
Morrow (76), Mcquaid (80)


Some Reasons

+1 ~ Marchand Another 50 point season by Marchy and his second 25 goal season, not to mention that beast 16.8 shot percent, Marchy was great this year.
= ~ Bergeron had an okay season with 62 points, but where's the 2010 Olympic Man?
-1 ~ Okay, I think Boston really screwed themselves with the Seguin-Eriksson deal. Eriksson only had 37 points and 10 goals this year, whereas Seguin scored 47 and 84 points. The same could be said for his 2012-13 season.
= ~ Enh, Lucic wasn't a huge difference maker other than his 59 points this year. Not enough to get 88 at least.
+1 ~ Krejci has come out! Another nearly 70 point season from the mystery man in Boston! Krejci is on fire, with 378 points on his resume.
+2 ~ Iginla had a really good season for an old guy (61 points) and helped Boston in the playoffs with 7 points as well. I thought he was always underrated.
+10 ~ Hang with me here. Smith had 9 points in 40 games for the Stars. I understand this was his rookie year then. Well heck, 51 points in 82 games is a half decent rookie year! Calder finalist for sure, maybe deserves even an 84.
-1 ~ The 92 face-off man isn't cutting it for my B's.
-2 ~ Once again, Paille manages to anger me. 18 points in 72 games? He doesn't even deserve the 77.
+2 ~ Even though he only had 8 points, Thornton is a fourth line enforcer who just happenes to know how to shoot.Not that he should be 80 overall or anything half decent.
-2 ~ What can a 21 point man do? He's expected to score more, so I make him a dissapointment.
+2 ~ Congratulations. 3 points. I guess I give you as many overall extra as a medal.
-1 ~ I feel bad doing this to the "Big Guy". I honestly never thought he was a 92. And when EA put him 94, I laughed my head off. Where's Erik Karlsson's 94? Or 95. Cause apparently Chara's as good as Crosby.
+1 ~ A good 10 points in 34 games and 1 playoff point in 18 games is hokey for me. I do want to see him step up and recover from injuries faster though.
-3 ~ Boychuk an 85? Not even with his 23 points and +31 plus minus.
+4 ~ Hamilton had a really good rookie year with 25 points as a D-man. Really proud of him.
+2 ~ I don't know. Never heard of him. Didn't score this year did he? Whatever.
-2 ~ Bad year statisclly for Mcquaid with only 6 points. He was playing with that Morrow guy on third d pair though.
+1 ~ Raskinator with his 2.04 GAA and .930% along with a Vezina, 36 wins, and 1641 shots against with only 115 goals against, Rask is quite the beast.
+1 ~ Again, never heard of him. Felt like it.
 

542365

2018-19 Cup Champs!
Mar 22, 2012
22,428
8,837
After free agency:

Steen(86)-Stastny(86)-Backes(86)
Schwartz(82)-Lehtera(78)-Tarasenko(84)
Berglund(82)-Sobotka(81)-Oshie(85)
Jaskin(79)-Lappiere(79)-Reaves(78)

JBo(87)-Petro(90)
Gunnar(84)-Shattenkirk(86)
Jackman(83)-Cole(81)
Leopold(81)

Elliott(83)
Allen(81)
 

capitalsrock

Registered User
Sep 7, 2012
2,506
45
Kuznetsov(81)-Backstrom(88)-Ovechkin(90)
Fehr(80)-Johansson(83)-Brouwer(82)
Chimera(80)-Laich(81)-Ward(83)
Brown(78)-Beagle(77)-Wilson(79)

Alzner(85)-Carlson(87)
Orpik(80)-Niskanen(85)
Orlov(79)-Green(81)

Holtby(83)
Peters(78)
 

VinikToWinIt

Number 1 Bull****
Jun 15, 2014
6,983
6,159
South Florida
Palat (85) Stamkos (92) Johnson (84)
Connolly (79) Filppula (85) Callahan (86)
Killorn (81) Drouin (??) Kucherov (80)
Panik (79) Boyle (80) Brown (76)

Hedman (88) Stralman (84)
Carle (83) Garrison (83)
Brewer (81) Gudas (80)
Sustr (78)

Bishop (86)
Nabokov (80)
 

Detwa

Registered User
Apr 16, 2012
10
0
Redwings:

F
Datsyuk - 93
Zetterberg - 90
Nyquist - 84
Alfredsson - 84
Franzen - 83
Helm - 83
Tatar - 83
Abdelkader - 80
Sheahan - 79
Weiss - 79
Jurco - 77
Miller - 77
Andersson - 75
Glendening - 74
Callahan - 73
Ferraro - 72
Cleary - 71

D:

Kronwall - 87
Ericcson - 81
Dekeyser - 81
Smith - 81
Quincey - 79
Kindl - 78
Oullet - 74
Sproul - 73
Marchenko - 73
Lashoff - 72

G
Howard - 85
Mrazek - 80
Gustavsson - 80
 

Underdogg04

Registered User
Dec 30, 2013
4
0
Montreal Canadiens:


Pacioretty (87) - Desharnais (83) - Gallagher (84)

Galchenyuk (84) - Plekanec (86) - Parenteau (83)

Bourque (79) - Eller (82) - Bournival (79)

Prust (79) - Malhotra (78) - Weise (80)


Gilbert (82) - Subban (90)

Markov (85) - Emelin (82)

Beaulieu (79) - Weaver (80)



Price (92)

Budaj (81)


_____________

Sekac (?)

Moen (76)

Tinordi (78)

Tokarski (80)


Although I am hoping to see Galchenyuk take on the #1 center role and see Desharnais get moved for a pick or packaged for a roster player.
 

Kents polished head

Formerly Tough Au Lit
Feb 4, 2013
9,677
4,667
Montreal Canadiens:


Pacioretty (87) - Desharnais (83) - Gallagher (84)

Galchenyuk (84) - Plekanec (86) - Parenteau (83)

Bourque (79) - Eller (82) - Bournival (79)

Prust (79) - Malhotra (78) - Weise (80)


Gilbert (82) - Subban (90)

Markov (85) - Emelin (82)

Beaulieu (79) - Weaver (80)



Price (92)

Budaj (81)


_____________

Sekac (?)

Moen (76)

Tinordi (78)

Tokarski (80)


Although I am hoping to see Galchenyuk take on the #1 center role and see Desharnais get moved for a pick or packaged for a roster player.

What exactly did Galchenyuk/Gallagher do to be rated better than a guy averaging 61 points/82 games in his last 4 seasons?
 

Underdogg04

Registered User
Dec 30, 2013
4
0
What exactly did Galchenyuk/Gallagher do to be rated better than a guy averaging 61 points/82 games in his last 4 seasons?

If my ratings were based off of average points in the last 4 seasons, both Emelin and Weaver would be rated 5 or less.
 

Gohabsgo67

Registered User
Jul 25, 2013
121
0
Quebec
For Canadian teams:

Calgary:

Hudler(85)-Backlund(83)-Glencross(84)
Raymond(83)-Monahan(83)-Stajan(82)
Jones(80)-Colborne(81)-Baertschi(78)
Bollig(79)-Bouma(78)-McGrattan(75)

Giordano(87)-Brodie(83)
Wideman(84)-Russell(82)
Smid(82)-Engelland(80)

Hiller(85)
Ramo(83)

Edmonton:

Hall(89)-Nugent-Hopkins(85)-Eberle(86)
Pouliot(82)-Perron(85)-Yakupov(81)
Hendricks(79)-Gordon(80)-Joenssu(77)
Gazdic(74)-Arcobello(78)-Lander(76)

Ference(83)-Nikitin(81)
Schultz(83)-Petry(82)
Marincin(80)-Fayne(80)

Scrivens(85)
Fasth(83)

Montreal:

Pacioretty(88)-Desharnais(84)-Parenteau(84)
Galchenyuk(83)-Plekanec(85)-Gallagher(83)
Bourque(82)-Eller(82)-Bournival(79)
Prust(80)-Malhotra(79)-Weise(79)

Subban(91)-Emelin(83)
Markov(86)-Gilbert(83)
Weaver(80)-Tinordi(78)

Price(92)
Budaj(81)

Ottawa:

Ryan(86)-Turris(86)-MacArthur(85)
Michalek(83)-Zibanejad(82)-Chiasson(82)
Greening(80)-Smith(80)-Hoffman(78)
Neil(79)-Condra(79)-Pageau(78)

Karlsson(91)-Methot(84)
Phillips(81)-Cowen(81)
Wiercioch(81)-Gryba(79)

Anderson(84)
Lehner(84)

Toronto:

Kessel(90)-Bozak(85)-Van Riemsdyk(87)
Lupul(85)-Kadri(85)-Santorelli(82)
Komarov(78)-Holland(79)-Clarkson(80)
McLaren(77)-Frattin(78)-Orr(76)

Phaneuf(85)-Gardiner(82)
Franson(84)-Rielly(82)
Polak(82)-Robidas(82)

Bernier(86)
Reimer(84)

Vancouver:

D.Sedin(87)-H.Sedin(87)-Vrbata(85)
Higgins(83)-Bonino(84)-Burrows(83)
Hansen(82)-Matthias(81)-Kassian(82)
Dorsett(78)-Richardson(81)-Vey(78)

Hamuis(85)-Bieksa(84)
Edler(83)-Tanev(81)
Stanton(79)-Sbisa(79)

Miller(88)
Lack(82)

Winnipeg:

Wheeler(87)-Little(85)-Ladd(86)
Byfuglien(86)-Scheifele(83)-Kane(85)
Frolik(83)-Perreault(83)-Slater(78)
Tangradi(78)-Thorburn(78)-Wright(77)

Enstrom(84)-Bogosian(83)
Trouba(83)-Stuart(79)
Clitsome(79)-Pardy(77)

Pavelec(83)
Huntchinson(77)
 

Yung Rotini

6 Summers
May 18, 2013
18,333
938
Penticton, BC
For Canadian teams:

Calgary:

Hudler(85)-Backlund(83)-Glencross(84)
Raymond(83)-Monahan(83)-Stajan(82)
Jones(80)-Colborne(81)-Baertschi(78)
Bollig(79)-Bouma(78)-McGrattan(75)

Giordano(87)-Brodie(84)
Wideman(82)-Russell(82)
Smid(82)-Engelland(80)

Hiller(85)
Ramo(83)

Edmonton:

Hall(89)-Nugent-Hopkins(85)-Eberle(86)
Pouliot(82)-Perron(85)-Yakupov(81)
Hendricks(79)-Gordon(80)-Joenssu(77)
Gazdic(74)-Arcobello(78)-Lander(76)

Ference(83)-Nikitin(81)
Schultz(83)-Petry(82)
Marincin(80)-Fayne(80)

Scrivens(83)
Fasth(83)

Montreal:

Pacioretty(88)-Desharnais(84)-Parenteau(84)
Galchenyuk(83)-Plekanec(85)-Gallagher(83)
Bourque(82)-Eller(82)-Bournival(79)
Prust(80)-Malhotra(79)-Weise(79)

Subban(91)-Emelin(83)
Markov(86)-Gilbert(83)
Weaver(80)-Tinordi(78)

Price(92)
Budaj(81)

Ottawa:

Ryan(86)-Turris(85)-MacArthur(85)
Michalek(83)-Zibanejad(82)-Chiasson(82)
Greening(80)-Smith(80)-Hoffman(78)
Neil(79)-Condra(79)-Pageau(78)

Karlsson(91)-Methot(84)
Phillips(81)-Cowen(81)
Wiercioch(81)-Gryba(79)

Anderson(84)
Lehner(84)

Toronto:

Kessel(90)-Bozak(85)-Van Riemsdyk(86)
Lupul(85)-Kadri(84)-Santorelli(82)
Komarov(80)-Holland(79)-Clarkson(80)
McLaren(77)-Frattin(78)-Orr(76)

Phaneuf(85)-Gardiner(82)
Franson(84)-Rielly(82)
Polak(82)-Robidas(82)

Bernier(85)
Reimer(82)

Vancouver:

D.Sedin(87)-H.Sedin(87)-Vrbata(85)
Higgins(83)-Bonino(84)-Burrows(83)
Hansen(82)-Matthias(81)-Kassian(82)
Dorsett(78)-Richardson(81)-Vey(78)

Hamuis(85)-Bieksa(84)
Edler(83)-Tanev(81)
Stanton(79)-Sbisa(79)

Miller(88)
Lack(82)

Winnipeg:

Wheeler(87)-Little(85)-Ladd(86)
Byfuglien(86)-Scheifele(83)-Kane(85)
Frolik(83)-Perreault(83)-Slater(78)
Tangradi(78)-Thorburn(78)-Wright(77)

Enstrom(84)-Bogosian(83)
Trouba(83)-Stuart(79)
Clitsome(79)-Pardy(77)

Pavelec(80)
Huntchinson(77)

Only things I would change, otherwise, pretty good ratings.
 

richyy03

"We're all mad here"
Aug 19, 2012
649
0
Ottawa, ON
:devils (Possible lineup)

Cammalleri (85) - Zajac (85) - Jagr (84)
Henrique (84) - Elias (83) - Havlat (81-82)
Clowe (82) - Ruutu (82) - Ryder (82)
Zubrus (79-80) - Gionta (76) - Bernier (75-76)

Brunner (80-81)/ Josefson (74-75)

Greene (84-85) - Larsson (81-82)
Merrill (78-80) - Zidlicky (81-82)
Salvador (77-79) - Gelinas (76-78)

Schneider (86)
Kinkaid (75)
 

Number 57

Registered User
Dec 21, 2004
11,690
2,384
Montreal
Montreal Canadiens

Pacioretty - 84
Plekanec - 82
Parenteau - 81
Desharnais - 80
Gallagher - 80
Eller - 79
Galchenyuk - 79
Bourque - 78
Sekac - 77
Weise - 76
Bournival - 75
Prust - 74
Moen - 74
Malhotra - 74

Subban - 89
Markov - 82
Emelin - 78
Gilbert - 77
Weaver - 76
Beaulieu - 75
Tinordi - 74
Pateryn - 73

Price - 91
Budaj - 80
Tokarski - 79
 

The Rage Kage

Registered User
Apr 21, 2014
6,257
5,118
:flyers

For the expected line up

Schenn(84)-Giroux(92)-Voracek(87)
Akeson(79)-Couturier(84)-Read(83)
Umberger(81)-Laughton(77)-Simmonds(85)
Bellemare(76/77)-Levavalier(80)-Rinaldo(-9001)

Macdonald(83)-Coburn(85)
Timonen(82)-Schenn(82)
Streit(82)-Grossman(80)

Mason(85)
Emery(77)
 

Pulkcannon

Registered User
Jun 29, 2014
94
0
Grand Rapids, MI
Detroit Red Wings

Zetterberg 92 Datsyuk 92 Nyquist 84
Franzen 85 Helm 84 Alfredsson 83
Tatar 82 Sheahan 81 Jurco 80
Abdelkader 82 Weiss 81 Glendening 77

Miller 78 Andersson 78 Callahan 75
Pulkinnen 76 Ferraro 75

Kronwall 87 Smith 82
Dekeyser 83 Ericsson 83
Kindl 79 Qunicey 80

Ouellet 75 Lashoff 75
Sproul 74 Marchenko 74

Howard 86
Gustavsson 78
Mrazek 77
McCollum 73
 

Nuge93

Stuck in a "Rebuild"
Jun 27, 2013
851
1
Oilers

Hall 89 - RNH 86 - Eberle 85
Perron 85 - Draisaitl 79 - Yakupov 81
Pouliot 82 - Gordon 79 - Purcell 81
Joensuu 75 - Hendricks 77 - Gazdic 75
Lander 75
Arcobello 75

Nikitin 84 - Petry 83
Schultz 82 - Ference 81
Marcinin 80 - Fayne 82
Klefbom 78


Scrivens 84
Fasth 81
 

jiggy35

Registered User
Jun 26, 2012
638
370
Leafs:
JVR 87 - Bozak 84 - Kessel 90
Lupul 85 - Kadri 85 - Santorelli 82
Komorov 80 - Kontiola 77 - Clarkson 81
Ashton 77 - Holland 80 - Frattin 78

Gardiner 84 - Phaneuf 87
Rielly 83 - Robidas 83
Franson 82 - Polak 82

Bernier 85
Reimer 82
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad