I don't think it was that strange considering how everything played out the first day of free agency. For much of the day, NJ seemed like the favorite to land him. It would've made a ton of sense too, considering he wanted to be closer to home, Philly was capped out and NJ had a very talented young team and plenty of cap space. The announcement that he was going to Columbus came out of nowhere and caught most NJ (and NHL fans) completely off guard. After he signed with the Blue Jackets, it seemed to come out that he really didn't have much intention of ever signing with NJ in the first place and was just stringing them along - not sure if that's accurate, but that's how things sounded. Thus, the animosity for Gaudreau from Devils fans. Seemed like NJ would've given him close to the same contract, but he spurned them to live further from home and play for a worse team. If he just showed zero interest in the Devils and they didn't seemingly go right down to the wire in getting him, I doubt we'd have seen the same reaction.