Randy Randerson
Registered User
I dunno... he has made mistakes... but play by play he might have been our best Dman if that makes sense. Very rare he gives the puck away and he is awesome at breaking it out of our zone. He thinks the game stupidly well already.
I.E. If you went play by play all year so far and ranked each play of each Dman... then took the median, he would probably be the best... but in mean he would not be!
It is not like he is making the same mistakes again, or struggling in one aspect of the game... it seems more like 'boundary testing' a lot... plus he has been objectively extremely 'unlucky' defensively. (.857 sv% at 5v5!)
He is definitely already an NHL calibre defenseman... heck, he is better than half the guys on our back end already!
I mean, so far this season:
52.73% Corsi
+0.88 Corsi rel
While facing top lines mostly!
And he has 0.5 PPG with 4/5 points at 5v5.
Once he realises what he can and cannot do in the NHL he is going to be very good... he already has 99% of the findamentals down to a tee.
That seems like the scouting book on him - carries the puck at an elite level but doesn't force plays
The thing about making mistakes is only what I picked up in this thread, I haven't seen anything other than highlights. I just think if the AHL is an option then its a good place to get top pick's feet wet when they're coming from a junior league, I would always opt for a stopover there if its an option even if it's a short one
The Corsi numbers tell a very different story than the plus/minus for Provorov, and goaltending seems to be the missing component that explains it - same with the leaf's record, with numbers that bad every little mistake gets exploited and its hard to score at a rate to cover it up