Speculation: Draft and UDFA Thread 2018-19: Part IX (No Kakko/Hughes Talk)

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
Status
Not open for further replies.
My vet dream with the Winnipeg pick, plus a small trade-up if possible, is Newhook at 1st place and then Seider at 2nd place. Newhook wouldn’t be impossible if you look at rankings, but I can’t imagine that he goes as late as 15 even. Seider? I also think it’s unlikely, but maybe not impossible. There are some guys a few teams can be really high on.
 
i want no part of seider at 20 if there are still a few highly regarded forwards on the board.

still scratching my head why all the shade thrown at lovoie. kid just had a monster playoffs. hes big, skates beautifully and has sublime hands. rocket shot too. the narrative on this kid is a joke.

anyway, pass on seider for me. forwards with the top 2 picks please.

a falling kaliyev would be fine with me. im not that concerned about his label.

ive been on the newhook bandwagon early and lovoie could work as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: egelband
i want no part of seider at 20 if there are still a few highly regarded forwards on the board.

still scratching my head why all the shade thrown at lovoie. kid just had a monster playoffs. hes big, skates beautifully and has sublime hands. rocket shot too. the narrative on this kid is a joke.

anyway, pass on seider for me. forwards with the top 2 picks please.

a falling kaliyev would be fine with me. im not that concerned about his label.

ive been on the newhook bandwagon early and lovoie could work as well.

Lavoie had a monster playoffs after a VERY meh regular season, as one of the biggest and oldest draft eligible players this season. With his talent, he should've dominated. He didn't
 
i want no part of seider at 20 if there are still a few highly regarded forwards on the board.

still scratching my head why all the shade thrown at lovoie. kid just had a monster playoffs. hes big, skates beautifully and has sublime hands. rocket shot too. the narrative on this kid is a joke.

anyway, pass on seider for me. forwards with the top 2 picks please.

a falling kaliyev would be fine with me. im not that concerned about his label.

ive been on the newhook bandwagon early and lovoie could work as well.

I’m holding out hope #20 isn’t our 2nd pick.
 
i want no part of seider at 20 if there are still a few highly regarded forwards on the board.

still scratching my head why all the shade thrown at lovoie. kid just had a monster playoffs. hes big, skates beautifully and has sublime hands. rocket shot too. the narrative on this kid is a joke.

anyway, pass on seider for me. forwards with the top 2 picks please.

a falling kaliyev would be fine with me. im not that concerned about his label.

ive been on the newhook bandwagon early and lovoie could work as well.

Lavoie's been impressive to watch. The stats were underwhelming, but it's hard to deny the tools.

IMO he's what Brett Connolly is today. Which is a very good support player that can get you 20.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joey Bones
I think that's three years? I've never really gotten the idea of the value of high draft picks diminishing as you get more of them, though. Each one is a small chance at getting a transformative talent. Get as many plinko chips as you can.


Zuccarello going to Dallas would make it four is what i was getting at. I agree in stockpiling picks but not at the expense of traded a top-6 winger IF the intent is to make the playoff the next season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Thirty One
Zuccarello going to Dallas would make it four is what i was getting at. I agree in stockpiling picks but not at the expense of traded a top-6 winger IF the intent is to make the playoff the next season.

I certainly hope the team doesn't put making the playoffs next year above the real goal of building a contender who can ultimately win it all. If they happen to make the playoffs next year so be it...but it shouldn't be at any price. We're headed in the right direction. Remain patient and build for the long term. We aren't that far away from having something special.
 
Turning it up in the playoffs is pretty big though. I wouldn't mind him at 20 either.

The pro tools are there. Some think that he doesn't slide past MTL.

But big body, rhs. Can skate and shoot. Lots to like. I don't have a problem with him getting 30 goals in the Q. But he's been very hit or miss.

Still though, I know a couple of guys that think very highly of his ability. Was simply dominant in the playoffs.
 
I certainly hope the team doesn't put making the playoffs next year above the real goal of building a contender who can ultimately win it all. If they happen to make the playoffs next year so be it...but it shouldn't be at any price. We're headed in the right direction. Remain patient and build for the long term. We aren't that far away from having something special.

I don't think one franchise pick (along with the rest of the pretty okay prospect pool) is enough either. Not really the biggest fan of tanking but since it's become widely used commodity in the NHL, it's also what the Rangers really should consider at least for the coming year. One or two seasons is much nothing at all compared to decade(s) of mediocrity.
 
Do people really think that Kreider is going to fetch a 1st in this year's draft + another 1st in 2020? I don't. You'll get a 1st for sure but depending on how high you might not get anything else. He's a better player than Hayes but not that much better.

I'd be shocked to see them land two 1's straight up.

I'd be very satisfied is they dealt something along the lines of Kreider and #20 for an early/mid teens pick and that teams 1 in 2020. I'd even be willing to retain on Kreider. If you dealt with a bubble team like AZ then you never know what can happen with that 2020 pick.
 
I don't think one franchise pick (along with the rest of the pretty okay prospect pool) is enough either. Not really the biggest fan of tanking but since it's become widely used commodity in the NHL, it's also what the Rangers really should consider at least for the coming year. One or two seasons is much nothing at all compared to decade(s) of mediocrity.
I wouldn't outright tank but I'd try to trade Kreider for a good 2019 or 2020 pick and then let the young players try their best to win. They're probably not going to be good enough to win us a ton of games but if they are, then that's a good problem to have. I'd be a lot more confident in this rebuild succeeding if we can get at least 1 more top 10 pick that hopefully turns into a star.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LORDE
The pro tools are there. Some think that he doesn't slide past MTL.

But big body, rhs. Can skate and shoot. Lots to like. I don't have a problem with him getting 30 goals in the Q. But he's been very hit or miss.

Still though, I know a couple of guys that think very highly of his ability. Was simply dominant in the playoffs.

I can also se Minny reaching on him as well, a lot of their fanbase are desperate for a right hand shot, not sure if it translates to management, just going off this board.
 
If the intention is to just tank the best way to do that is not just getting rid of Chris Kreider but moving on from Mika Zibanejad too. You really want the team to collapse you do things like that. At the same time I don't think a hard charging motivator like David Quinn should be your coach. Might as well have kept AV around.

The Rangers have no intention of tanking and they certainly didn't try to tank last year. They played hard right up through the last game. They will do that again next year. Whether that means making the playoffs I don't know but I expect they will be better. One should expect that guys like Chytil, Howden, Andersson, DeAngelo, Lemeiux, Buchnevich, Pionk and Georgiev will all improve and Kakko (Hughes) to be a big addition too along with Kravtsov, Fox and Shesterkin and maybe even Rykov. It's going to be a very young team but also pretty talented.
 
If the intention is to just tank the best way to do that is not just getting rid of Chris Kreider but moving on from Mika Zibanejad too. You really want the team to collapse you do things like that. At the same time I don't think a hard charging motivator like David Quinn should be your coach. Might as well have kept AV around.

The Rangers have no intention of tanking and they certainly didn't try to tank last year. They played hard right up through the last game. They will do that again next year. Whether that means making the playoffs I don't know but I expect they will be better. One should expect that guys like Chytil, Howden, Andersson, DeAngelo, Lemeiux, Buchnevich, Pionk and Georgiev will all improve and Kakko (Hughes) to be a big addition too along with Kravtsov, Fox and Shesterkin and maybe even Rykov. It's going to be a very young team but also pretty talented.
I wouldn’t say they’re tanking like Buffalo did for McDavid, but I think they were tanking like Toronto did for Marner/Matthews
 
I wouldn’t say they’re tanking like Buffalo did for McDavid, but I think they were tanking like Toronto did for Marner/Matthews

If we look at last season, we had a lot fewer vets than Toronto had when they got Matthews. Toronto actually had a lot of vets. But that is a bit of the dilemma, because kids with attitude will always keep skating but its the vets that really throw in the towel when a season is done, which it can be pretty early.
 
They are not tanking, they have several vets, they are just not very good. The most expensive of them have two years left with some sort of no trade clause if not a full no movement clauses.

They have been selling off those who are pending UFAs, some with a year left on their term even. That is not tanking, that is using the natural supply and demand cycle within the CBA.

The CBA rules the day, there are mechanisms within it which give the teams who finish lower in the standings a better chance to draft earlier. Thus a better chance at improving their team over the long term.

None of us made up the system, the Rangers are just playing it just as they did when they were on the other side of it, they were allowed to sell their picks, allowed to hand out whatever contracts they wanted which fit into the cap. They were allowed to put themselves into the position they are in, now they are just using the opposite side mechanics to dig themselves out of it and hopefully do more than only that while they have the opputunity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LORDE
I've heard talk that scouts say that Seider will go closer to 10 than 20
That is a possibility. He's got that feeling of being the "riser" this year. There could well be a run on defense as you get to around the 10th pick with names like Broberg or maybe York coming off the boards. Which would bear well for the Rangers to get that forward that is falling for some reason.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad