I’ve been busy and noticed the Johnsson’s dead horse got ridden at the end of the last thread. I saw that the ridiculous argument that Johnson didn’t get his numbers inflated by playing with the Leaf’s top players in 2018-19 got peddled again.
Matthews assisted on of 5 of AJ’s 16 5v5 goals and 8 of Johnsson’s 20 5v5 assists were on Matthews’ 5v5 goals. That’s because he played 422 minutes (out 866 5v5 minutes) with Matthews. Johnsson didn’t play much with Matthews until December but he played on his line for half the year with Kaparen or Nylander.
Johnsson did play a while on a line with Connor Brown and Par Lundholm in Oct/Nov when healthy before getting his minutes bumped up when he moved to the top six. He played a bit with Tavares and Marner too, and was pretty productive, when Hyman was out for 11 games. AJ only got bumped down to bottom six again later in the year when Marleau was playing with Kaparen/Matthews and he briefly got dumped on Gauthier’s line, that’s why his minutes go down temporarily in February.
The forwards Johnsson played the most 5v5 with in order: Matthews (422 minutes), Kaparen (251), Nylander (239), C. Brown (199), Lindholm (192), Tavares (121), Marner (109), Kadri (75) and Gauthier (67).
So this comment of Steve’s about Johnsson is correct except AJ’s year doesn’t have much to do with Nylander’s holdout per se. Nylander played with Marleau and Kadri after he first returned and then he mostly played with Matthews and Johnsson after Kadri got injured.
In Johnsson's one (1) decent season, William Nylander was a contract holdout. Johnson received significant time alongside both Matthews and Tavares, and played mostly on the 2PP. To his credit, he seemed to show a decent nose for the net and a pretty good finish, which along with his surrounding high-talent contributed to his being one of 6 20-goal scorers on the 2018-19 Maple Leafs (20 goals, 23 assists, 43 points).
I’m refuting this with this much excruciating detail because this same debate happened during the trade and it annoyed me then that people were denying Johnsson played the majority of that season with top line players. (I remember someone dismissing the amount of time he played with Matthews since it was “only” half of his season, and that’s probably why I’m still annoyed.)