Around the NHL – Part XL - Mod post page 249

Status
Not open for further replies.

CasusBelli

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Jul 6, 2017
14,029
13,113
Could be really scary if/when he fills out.
I just wonder how you can play defense without lats, shoulders, biceps or triceps. It’s almost like The Matrix: “you think that’s air you’re breathing?” … “you think those are your muscles you’re using?”
 

CasusBelli

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Jul 6, 2017
14,029
13,113
I mean, just last year, people were comparing Fox’s IQ to Gretzky, and also comparing him to Orr.

Makar is absolutely incredible.
He is by leaps and bounds the best offensive defenseman in the league … but you could make the case that Orr was the greatest player of all time (longevity aside). The comparison seems premature.
 

Tob

Registered User
Sep 16, 2017
16,540
36,806
Even with the power of domestic altercation, prostitution, gambling, abortion contracts, and the finest legal representation money can buy, it only got the Oilers 8 wins with McDavid and Draisaitl.
 

Kane One

Registered User
Feb 6, 2010
43,830
11,715
Brooklyn, New NY
He is by leaps and bounds the best offensive defenseman in the league … but you could make the case that Orr was the greatest player of all time (longevity aside). The comparison seems premature.
Lol what? You absolutely cannot, and I think he’s one of those legends like Babe Ruth that people say is the best (in Orr’s case, best at his position) just because people are used to saying it and hearing it for 50 years.
 

Boris Zubov

No relation to Sergei, Joe
May 6, 2016
18,903
26,182
Back on the east coast
I'll take Fox every single time. Physical skills will erode. Fox's 4D chess galaxy brain will keep him going late into his career
This is homer bias here, hate to say it. Nobody in their right mind should choose Fox over Makar. Fox is better right now in his own end, but Makar's skating is the difference to me. He can learn to play defense better as his career progresses. Fox is who he is as a skater & that won't likely improve enough to bridge the gap between the two players.

We're lucky to have Fox, but Makar is the better player, IMO.
 

CasusBelli

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Jul 6, 2017
14,029
13,113
So he is an underdeveloped mesomorph, that what you're saying?
I’m saying you don’t usually see big shooters who don’t have huge upper bodies as well. Weber, Chara, Ovechkin, Burns, Laine, Malkin. All huge shooters and all big guys. Thinner big shooters like MSL, Bure and Karlsson have been much rarer. Not sure if Mika and Stammer are big guys — tall and lanky?

Lol what? You absolutely cannot, and I think he’s one of those legends like Babe Ruth that people say is the best (in Orr’s case, best at his position) just because people are used to saying it and hearing it for 50 years.
Why not?
 
  • Like
Reactions: will1066
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad