Toggle sidebar

Proposal: Ana-wpg

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
troubabooster said:
And I'm fine with that. HF prospect ranker had those guys ranked 7.5C which seems fair, exactly same as Petan which I might begrudgingly consider a fair trade in a one for one
Click to expand...

im sure you would dude. but defensemen are worth more than wingers. montour outscored petan as a defensemen and larsson has more potential than montour. noone else would do that 1 for 1 but jets fans. and for a reason
 
lindholmie said:
im sure you would dude. but defensemen are worth more than wingers. montour outscored petan as a defensemen and larsson has more potential than montour. noone else would do that 1 for 1 but jets fans. and for a reason
Click to expand...

Yes we get it, all Duck defensemen are amazing, they likely have 6 top pairing guys in their system, right?
 
Exit Dose said:
I have no problem with Morrissey being put on the same tier as Theodore. Both are equally promising. Morrissey is more of a two-way threat, so extrapolating on offensive stats isn't really getting to the heart of the issue. Both looked like they had high ceilings at all levels. It's not like Lindholm was some statistical beast in the AHL, but if you watched him it was understandable that he had a high ceiling. I'd argue that the same is true of Morrissey.
Click to expand...

Good post. Morrissey had 2 goals and 10 points in 28 AHL games in his draft+1 season (mostly playoff games). Lindholm had 1 goal and 11 points in 44 AHL games in his draft+1 season. Lindholm was always a better prospect than Morrissey. Scoring rates in the AHL aren't a great way to assess young defensive prospects. Morrissey has high end skating, skills and vision. He has a chance to be a top end NHL defenseman, as does Theodore.
 
Whileee said:
Good post. Morrissey had 2 goals and 10 points in 28 AHL games in his draft+1 season (mostly playoff games). Lindholm had 1 goal and 11 points in 44 AHL games in his draft+1 season. Lindholm was always a better prospect than Morrissey. Scoring rates in the AHL aren't a great way to assess young defensive prospects. Morrissey has high end skating, skills and vision. He has a chance to be a top end NHL defenseman, as does Theodore.
Click to expand...


except the fact lindholm is elite defensively and one of the best shutdown defenders in the world and morrissey is an offensive defensemen.....
 
JetsHomer said:
Yes we get it, all Duck defensemen are amazing, they likely have 6 top pairing guys in their system, right?
Click to expand...

They probably do. Depending on the need and team they are on.... and if we are talking about today or 4 years from now.

I can see 4 Ducks dmen hitting top pairing potential with 7 or more of them hitting top 4.

Depends where they play though.
 
BSU said:
except the fact lindholm is elite defensively and one of the best shutdown defenders in the world and morrissey is an offensive defensemen.....
Click to expand...

Lindholm was not one of the best shutdown defenders in the world during the time frame they mentioned.
 
supersonic jet said:
I'll have what he's having:yo:
Click to expand...

Vatanen Fowler lindholm manson and despres are all already top 4 dmen... that means 2 of Theodore, Montour and larrson have to be top 4 to have 7, it's not unrealistic.


Top pair guys I'd say lindholm and Theodore are the only legit option, larsson still to raw to make that claim
 
BSU said:
except the fact lindholm is elite defensively and one of the best shutdown defenders in the world and morrissey is an offensive defensemen.....
Click to expand...

And that by this time in Morrissey's career, Lindholm had already forced his way into 2 full NHL seasons amassing a +54 rating and 64 points. Meanwhile Morrissey has only earned his way into playing 1 singular NHL game.

Can't possibly be any difference between the two prospects nor their upside...
 
xxreact9 said:
And that by this time in Morrissey's career, Lindholm had already forced his way into 2 full NHL seasons amassing a +54 rating and 64 points. Meanwhile Morrissey has only earned his way into playing 1 singular NHL game.

Can't possibly be any difference between the two prospects nor their upside...
Click to expand...

This is not why Lindholm's name came up.
 
Sojourn said:
Lindholm didn't request a trade.
Click to expand...

"the irony of a Ducks fan chirping about Trouba when Lindholm isn't signed either"

Wouldn't personally fire shots at anyone if my team gets called out by the player himself for lowballing.

By the way, you can count on me putting that post in my signature, if karma strikes back. :)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Maukkis said:
"the irony of a Ducks fan chirping about Trouba when Lindholm isn't signed either"

Wouldn't personally fire shots at anyone if my team gets called out by the player himself for lowballing.

By the way, you can count on me putting that post in my signature, if karma strikes back. :)
Click to expand...

Go for it. :dunno:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom