This is getting fun… I should stay out of it but I’ll pick on a few points without talking sides
Call ups….. when RJ says sit Moore and call up Turcotte it doesn’t mean Turcotte plays Moores role, someone else can slide down and Turcotte goes into his appropriate role in the lineup. It’s not always a direct swap, which you know. If we are talking JAD coming in it would be a a direct change and for my money I make that change by the TDL because JAD should be part of the longer term future.
The frustrations are definitely understandable even if I don’t agree with all of them. Brown though, it’s hard to defend his deployment and the argument to have him be the one making the room in the top 6 for the likes of Turcotte to get a cup of coffee is a strong one. He’s been better the last few games which is good and I’d have never scratched him he’s definitely playing too many minutes. He should be playing 15 minutes max to get the best out of him, age very much the defining factor. Those minutes can easily go to Grundstrom and Kaliyev (without call ups), both of whom have earned them. If you go through my posting history I’m a big Brown homer, but I can be objective on this.
There is no definitely no defence for the AA signing when the roster is already top heavy and I said that the minute it happened. The point that RJ makes about having a spot or two on the roster to rotate guys in and out is a fair one even if you don’t agree. It’s not a ridiculous viewpoint to ask that Turcotte gets 10 games, goes back down, Byfield gets a few, Turcotte comes back up etc. Personally I want to see that happening by the TDL, I’m ok with them getting a bit more AHL time until then. However, before the end of the year I want to see Byfield and JAD on the permanent NHL roster. I also want to see Turcotte get at least 15 games in, with Fagemo, Madden and Thomas getting at least a couple of games to prepare them for the off season.
Clague doesn’t bother me he never earned it IMO and Durzi is demonstrating how to actually win a job. Maatta is ok at a #7 and that contract is never getting buried in the minors and nor would it in most teams. With Vilardi you have to hope he figures it out but his body language is what I’m mostly worried about and he’s another I’ve always backed. We c an all debate how Vilardi has been handled but ultimately his back issues are the most significant factor. I’m not sure where we go from here with him.
I say all this as someone that is always positive and looks for the silver lining. I actually like Blake and think he’s doing more right than wrong and the expectation that he can’t make any mistakes is ludicrous. He’s in his first GM job and people still focus on the mistake of the Kovi signing even though I doubt he had a green light to do a proper rebuild at that time, (based on how the franchise has always operated). As a rookie GM he was always going to makes mistakes but he usually recognises them and deals with it. So, much of the criticism of Blake is more about how his first tenure as a player ended than anything else. I was over that a long time ago.
So I’m not judging if Blake is a good GM or not at this point because it’s still early in the cycle to judge how he’s executed his plan. However there are valid questions and concerns because the approach to player development is not clear to us but that doesn’t mean it’s not clear to the players. The team is definitely doing better than last year and if Kopitar were to get going again it’d make a huge difference as will having DD on the ice every night. So looking at the big picture something is going right but there needs to be some more youth integration before the season is up, because it’s about the long term future.