why are posters on the main boards so down on us

Status
Not open for further replies.

Xspyrit

DJ Dorion
Jun 29, 2008
31,666
10,573
Montreal, Canada
Am I the only who thinks the line-up is better than 2012-13 and even 2013-14?

Possibly, all good then , it's usually a good sign :)

Because the team is a legit joke.

Wont spend, losing players and a very meh roster with a very average prospect pool.

Plus the Sens are a small market, making it easy to dump on em.

We're no different from the Islanders and Panthers.

Do you really believe in what you write? If the Sens are a joke, what are the Oilers, Panthers, Islanders, Blue Jackets, Flames, Sabres, Jets and Maple Leafs? Teams that almost never make the playoffs and never seem to get better despite drafting high or spending a ton of money

A very meh roster with a very average prospect pool is a super disingenuous thought. The line-up is actually a mix of both present and future, a transition. Seeing how many youngsters are already on the team and how many others are about to make it, it sounds unfair to call them "meh". Unless you really believe that all those guys have so-so potential (Karlsson, Lehner, Ceci, Cowen, Wiercioch, Wikstrand, Claesson, Turris, Zibanejad, Chiasson, Hoffman, Stone, Puempel, Lazar, Guptill, Pageau, Dzingel, Prince,...)

If you really think the Sens are no different than the Islanders and Panthers, I will conclude that you really lack any kind of analytical skill. Simply because the Sens have made the playoffs 14 of the last 17 seasons and the worst finishes are 22th in 2008-09, 26th in 2010-11 and 20th last year. How is it even comparable to the other teams I named before?

Money is another subject, but let's see what they will spend in the future. For now, it makes sense to spend below average while the team is growing up. It's the reality of the market of Ottawa, can't spend to the max every year if you want to remain profitable (particularly in non-contending years). Not sure why people have such a big trouble to understand that. Business 101

Not because Melnyk has a lot of money that he should be burning it. In fact, that might be that state of mind that pushed him to the top

This is why, because our posts are filled with negative comments 24/7. Because we have the worst fanbase in the NHL, because after one bad year its freaking doomsday.

This fanbase needs to grow up.

Yes it's a bit true, this fanbase is really emo-parano, soft as tissue. Although it's getting better recently, we have a lot of great posters "moderating" (or trying lol) the whole thing.

People feel the need to put other's down to feel good about themselves. When this happens people generally pick an easy target to gain moral support from others making themselves feel better and important and part of the group. Ottawa along with Toronto is one of the easiest targets to make fun of in Canada, sports especially for different reasons. It will always be like this in Canada as we are a nation of generally negative complainers compared to other countires in similar circumstances imo. Most countries embrace their capital city, in Canada we loathe it and knock it down at every opportunity. My 2 cents.

This. Occidental mentality sucks. Psychology 101 : kick him while he's down.

I don't understand how you guys don't see it really... The reason is that we don't see this team getting in the right direction. Your team's internal budget is killing their chance to do anything really. The thing that hurt you guys the most is that your 2 previous captains left because they didn't like the direction the team is going. Also, after all the assets you traded for Bobby Ryan and him becoming a UFA probably wanting a big deal and also the fact you have an internal budget, we wonder if the Sens will be able to keep him at a price that he will want. And my last point would be that also because of your internal budget, Ottawa always seems like they have to trade away good players while they could be competing because of it and then get other prospects and the cycle goes on and on.

I understand your point of view, from an outside perspective that must be hard to follow, but personally I really like the direction of the team : youth talent, build through the draft, like before. The Sens drafting really sucked from 2002 to 2007, it shouldn't come as a surprise why they hit a few bumps on the road since 2007-08.

On Ryan, it remains to be seen. I think he signs long-term and when he does, no more problem on that front

Alfie left because he is almost 42 y/o and has no time to wait for this team to turn into a contender (in the end, he might have went to play 1 season with his Swedish buddies for more money and a slightly better chance at the cup). Spezza left because he needed a change of scenery and was tired to be scapegoated (some of it was deserved frankly). Hurts the team very short term (and it remains to be seen), but will be for the best, going for another 7-8 years contract at 7-8 millions per would have been really risky. Might be another bullet dodged ala Heatley

Spezza-Turris-Smith or Turris-Zibanejad-Legwand

Let's see what difference it makes ON the ice.

All that being said, the Sens will still spank the Habs ***** quite easily ;)

Other than Spezza and Alfie I'm at a loss as to which seemingly great players we had to let go in the last 3 or 4 years

That's basically the question I ask myself everytime I log onto HF. I mean, we continue to cry for a player that is going to be 42 years old soon... And that comes from a guy who became a Sens fan because of Alfie.

When you read the main boards, it seems we have lost a ******** of guys. Well, in the past maybe (Chara, Havlat, Hossa...) but Heatley, why should regret losing him? Spezza might become same of the same story, I wouldn't be surprised.

I consider any year that doesn't end in the conference finals or Stanley cup finals to be a failure.

How do you survive in this world? 99.9% of humans are a dime a dozen and 99.9% of the things you do (maybe 100%) is failure.

Of players who played games last year:

Out: spezza, hemsky, Da Costa, kassian

Of players expected to play a game(s) this year but didn't last year:

In: legwand, chiasson, ...maybe Lazar or puempel get games.

To outsiders that looks like a step backwards to a team that didn't make the playoffs. I can see why they predict we do worse than last year.

Well, that's not exactly the way to look at it. Just because layers like Mark Stone and Mike Hoffman played "some games" that they shouldn't be part of this equation

This post is heavily biased, you could at least try to make it a bit more subtle, please.

I expect Murray to do better than this, especially when he's vaunted for building the Ducks. Which took him and Burke four years or so. And he's been here close to ten years.

Not going to argue much because everybody knows how much crap you can come with, but do you realize 7 years is as close as 10 years than it is to 4 years?

you may be a Montreal fan, but you speak the truth. Honestly I feel like the Sens' are the kings of developing great players and seeing them eventually sign to another team while still in their prime.. and majority of the time its because of our idiot management that it leads to (this includes the owner)

Well in reality, since your post is addressed to a Habs fan, it's quite the opposite... I lived in Montreal 23 years. Do you want a list of players that were Habs property at first but only found success after they left Montreal?

Beauchemin
Hainsey
Streit
Robidas
...

Do you want me to continue?

Believe me, after Patrick Roy left Montreal, they had their dark days and it was way uglier than this "doom days" version of the Sens (making the playoffs 2 out 3 years while rebuilding with a 2nd round as the ice cake)

Also, the list you omitted included many players that were just traded. That has nothing to do with the current argument but Erik Alfredsson covered that already
 

Sensinitis

Registered User
Aug 5, 2012
15,979
5,587
Xspyrit to the rescue!

I agree that this team is better than 12-13 and 13-14. What else other than progress do we want?
 

JD1

Registered User
Sep 12, 2005
16,335
10,017
you may be a Montreal fan, but you speak the truth. Honestly I feel like the Sens' are the kings of developing great players and seeing them eventually sign to another team while still in their prime.. and majority of the time its because of our idiot management that it leads to (this includes the owner)

Chara
Hasek
Hossa
Havlat
Fisher
Kelly
Alfredsson
Spezza--?

Chara - we had Redden and Chara. The organization made a choice, so did Chara. The organization made the wrong choice.
Hasek - was an old man when he left here
Hossa - was traded for Heatley. Regardless what you think of him (and I personally do not think much) Heatley scored 180 goals in 4 years which is BY FAR the best 4 year run in franchise history
Havlat - traded
Kelly / Fisher - part of an organization wide change in direction
Alfredsson / Spezza - both left in somewhat odd circumstances and everyone has an opinion on their departures but I think there is blame to go around for their departures and neither of them is completely innocent.

The other thing that this list doesn't consider....when we came out of the first lockout the cap was 39 and we were IIRC right at the top. At the time, many in the league thought that the team hit the hardest by the reduced cap was us. We had a lot of guys entering their prime earning years and an inability cap wise to keep them all happy. Had the will and cash flow been there to keep all those guys, the cap space wouldn't have allowed it anyway.
 

Cosmix

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Jul 24, 2011
19,209
7,201
Ottawa
Xspyrit to the rescue!

I agree that this team is better than 12-13 and 13-14. What else other than progress do we want?

I am looking forward to the new season as i see great potential in this team and i want to see their progress and the new players (Legwand, Chiasson, Lazar). I think they will be better than last year's version, and make the playoffs.

So, we are now about 31 days from the start of main training camp on 19 September. Only about 24 days from the Rookie Tournament.
 

Cosmix

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Jul 24, 2011
19,209
7,201
Ottawa
When Chara left, i think he got over $7m annually. That was about $1m more than Phillips and Volchenkov combined. At that time, i wanted to keep Chara and Redden, but using the available funds on Phillips and Volchenkov was a smart money thing to do, i think. We got two decent defensive defensmen instead of having one, plus saving $1m.
 

MtRundle

We once were warriors.
Apr 29, 2013
963
26
Toronto
Xspyrit to the rescue!

I agree that this team is better than 12-13 and 13-14. What else other than progress do we want?


I think if we are even close to being as good as 12-13 I'm ecstatic.

And to get back to the topic, main board (Mon and Tor) fans **** on us cause thats what they do, its in their blood to be plugs. When we were one of the best teams in the NHL 2003-2007 they **** on us, so what do you expect now. Plus they know we care. Frankly I don't give 2 ***** what some old windbag Laff fan or a comebackpatrique Habs fan says.

Just win baby.
 

trentmccleary

Registered User
Mar 2, 2002
22,239
1,123
Alfie-Ville
Visit site
A bottom 5 finish should be expected for a bottom of the league payroll without much in the way of above average talent.

My hopes are now that when Melnyk sells the team;
- that the new owner wants to keep the team in Ottawa.
- that the team gets some elite level draft picks in the coming few seasons (1st or 2nd overalls) for the new owner to build around.
 

Dysentery

Ottawa Senators
Sep 14, 2011
2,906
0
New Brunswick
I like this team. I like this teams makeup more than the one that went for the cup run. The only sure thing in the East maybe Boston and Pittsburgh making the playoffs, the rest is a crap shoot, anyone thinking different is wrong.
 

SlapJack

Scum bag Sens
Dec 6, 2010
2,004
1,294
If you were asked for your opinion of another team in the same position, you would likely respond the same way. Did anyone here think that Ottawa would have tied with New Jersey in the overall standings last year? After so much hype for the Sens, and the Devils missing the playoffs the year before followed by the loss of Clarkson and Kovalchuk (preceded by Parise's departure the year prior), most people would have picked NJ to be near the bottom.

It could turn out to be better that no one expects anything from the Senators. A combination of high hopes, the loss of their true leader, not enough experience on defence, and a brutal schedule to start the season, all played a huge part in derailing Ottawa last year. And it's possible that all the pundits this year could be correct in assuming that Ottawa will be in tough to succeed this season. My personal feeling is that they will be equal or slightly better this year.

The loss of Spezza is perceived from the outside as a crushing blow, whereas internally it's almost a wash. There will be fewer goals scored, but that will be offset by less against.
 

Duck Off

HF needs an App
Oct 25, 2002
21,012
5,473
Oklahoma
... Like seriously. They think we will finish last. They think Karlsson will ask for a trade and Ryan has already asked for a trade (????). I really don't get it.

Duck fan just visiting.

Ignore Philly fans. For whatever reason they have some entitlement issues when it comes to them. Ryan, himself, told me he made a mistake and did an interview when he was drinking. He says he likes the Philly area, but doesn't have a desire to play hockey there.

Regardless though, you'll hear it non stop from them until Ryan re-signs or is moved. I find it asinine that people think he would demand a trade though. If he doesn't like it in Ottawa (which he's never told me by the way), he'll just cash in next July. No reason for him to demand a trade at all.
 

bert

Registered User
Nov 11, 2002
37,576
23,895
Visit site
They also think Drew Doughty is the best defenseman in the league.

Something shiny will come along and pull them off in some other direction soon enough.

We won't be lucky enough to finish last.

He is the best D man in the league. He was the best player at the Olympics for team Canada was the best D man at the previous Olympics and is the best player on the best team in the league. When the games are on the line or its the playoffs he raises his game to a higher level than any other defenseman in the NHL. Sure his regular season could be better but when it counts he is the obvious choice.

I think it has a lot to do with the sens posters on here.

An odd unwarranted confidence ala the leafs fan base has arisen around here in the last couple years. They are tired of hearing the fans defend what is an obvious disaster. Didn't help all the overhype the team got last year either.

Until proven otherwise they are right Ottawa was one of the worst teams in the league last year and compared to the hype massively underperformed. As a group myself included last year we were a very confident bunch. Didn't really calculate exactly how the leadership core was going to be so affected by Alfies departure and what seems like an almost disconnect between the team and coaching staff.

Hopefully they turn it around this year, the MacArthur signing is huge in getting this organization back onto the right track. Its a well known fact that him and Bobby are close. Now its time for Ryan, Anderson and Methot.
 

bert

Registered User
Nov 11, 2002
37,576
23,895
Visit site
I like this team. I like this teams makeup more than the one that went for the cup run. The only sure thing in the East maybe Boston and Pittsburgh making the playoffs, the rest is a crap shoot, anyone thinking different is wrong.

I disagree I think Tampa is going to be a force, they have all the pieces and the team got ALOT better than last year in the offseason. All the youth they have is elite and will get better on top of having a healthy Stamkos for a full season they aren't regressing.
 

ChocolateLeclaire

Registered User
Jan 12, 2010
12,042
2
Ottawa, Canada
I disagree I think Tampa is going to be a force, they have all the pieces and the team got ALOT better than last year in the offseason. All the youth they have is elite and will get better on top of having a healthy Stamkos for a full season they aren't regressing.

I think Tampa struggles as Bishop approaches his normal average of play and the team has issues finding it's identity after losing their heart and soul captain.

Sound familiar?
 

aef1400

Registered User
Mar 20, 2013
113
0
Personally I see us in the 8-14 range this year. Alot of things will have to go our way to make the playoffs (EK back to being EK, good year from Andy-Lehner, good year for the younger guys like Zibby, good chemistry from the new guys). But to be honest if there was one year where I would be ok with being terrible it would be this year because of the draft.

A top 5 pick next year could seriously help turn us around. I know thats a bad mentality to have as a fan, but if you've seen the draft eligible players for the 15' draft play, its almost mouth watering.
 

Senscore

Let's keep it cold
Nov 19, 2012
21,522
17,186
He is the best D man in the league. He was the best player at the Olympics for team Canada was the best D man at the previous Olympics and is the best player on the best team in the league. When the games are on the line or its the playoffs he raises his game to a higher level than any other defenseman in the NHL. Sure his regular season could be better but when it counts he is the obvious choice.

I think it has a lot to do with the sens posters on here.

An odd unwarranted confidence ala the leafs fan base has arisen around here in the last couple years. They are tired of hearing the fans defend what is an obvious disaster. Didn't help all the overhype the team got last year either.

Until proven otherwise they are right Ottawa was one of the worst teams in the league last year and compared to the hype massively underperformed. As a group myself included last year we were a very confident bunch. Didn't really calculate exactly how the leadership core was going to be so affected by Alfies departure and what seems like an almost disconnect between the team and coaching staff.

Hopefully they turn it around this year, the MacArthur signing is huge in getting this organization back onto the right track. Its a well known fact that him and Bobby are close. Now its time for Ryan, Anderson and Methot.


Well then you're going to be upset when some other team wins the Cup and the top guy on that team becomes the best.
 

Filatov2Kovalev2Bonk

Effortless sexy.
Jul 13, 2006
12,800
1,124
Cumberland
Well then you're going to be upset when some other team wins the Cup and the top guy on that team becomes the best.

That doesn't stop Doughty from being the best. What makes him right up there is that teams that he is on just succeed. From the time he was a kid, to the Kings (they turned around dramatically when he joined them) to the Olympics and so on. He is just a winner. Even his attitude is a winner's. Hockey News Yearbook: "Do you want a Norris trophy?" "It would be nice for sure but we're focused on the post-season and the Cup, that's regular season stuff."

I haven't heard that type of talk from anyone here...Karlsson at times but that's it.

The Mac signing is a good step for sure (though I hear he has a full NMC, which is crazy considering players generally decline in their 30s) but we need more than tweeners on the team. Elite players on the Senators? Erik Karlsson and...Ryan is a stretch. Turrs is a 2C. Mac is a 2W/3W on an elite team. It's just...average. And the team rewards average.

Hope I'm wrong and they get to be elite though.
 

Senscore

Let's keep it cold
Nov 19, 2012
21,522
17,186


The main board is all about "What have you done for me lately?"

Go to any poll thread, go to any "who is the best?" thread, etc etc.


They are cats chasing laser pointers. This was never really about your personal opinion of Drew Doughty.
 

bert

Registered User
Nov 11, 2002
37,576
23,895
Visit site
I think Tampa struggles as Bishop approaches his normal average of play and the team has issues finding it's identity after losing their heart and soul captain.

Sound familiar?

They have more talent and leadership, they also had a time to adjust without St Louis. St Louis wasn't the captain for the last 12 years either.

They don't rely on Bishop like the Sens did on Anderson/Lehner/Bishop they score goals lots of them. Vasilevski is also coming and will more thank likely replace Bishop so they will be upgrading in nets too.

The addition of Stralman, Drouin and Garrison is going to make them better.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad