Toggle sidebar

Proposal: Which fan base would do this trade Matthew Knies For Jesper Wallstedt

Which fan base would do this trade and if so why?

  • Neutral fan would do the trade

    Votes: 32 5.5%

  • Neutral fan would not do the trade

    Votes: 245 41.8%

  • Toronto fan would do the trade

    Votes: 69 11.8%

  • Toronto fan would not do the trade

    Votes: 125 21.3%

  • Minnesota fan would do the trade

    Votes: 16 2.7%

  • Minnesota fan would not do the trade

    Votes: 99 16.9%
  • Total voters
    586
HockeyVirus said:
Nah this doesn't make any sense. That would be like saying any player in the OHL Leaf fans are experts on. I very much doubt any significant portion of fans were repeated viewers of college hockey.
Click to expand...
Horrible analogy. There are 20 different OHL teams. A leaf fan who happens to be a big fan of a particular OHL team will have good insight about a player on that team. Someone who casually follows the league as a whole will not. The Gophers are a huge presence in the state of Minnesota and the hockey following crowd likely has a lot of familiarity with a massive overlap between Minnesota Golden Gopher fans and Minnesota Wild fans.

You're comparing a following of an entire league to a following of a specific team that has a huge fanbase if you know anything about the state and its fanbase. Your assumptions are just off, it appears you pulled it out of nothing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marlowe Syn, luiginb and TaLoN
As a rule of thumb I think it's harder for a team to get max. value from a highly valued goalie prospect.
 
Digitalbooya said:
Minnesota views him as untouchable. Not trying to trade him.
Click to expand...

As a rule of thumb would imply it’s not about Wallstedt. For example I don’t think Nashville would get equivalent value for Askarov if they ever tried to trade him.
 
I would venture a guess that most Wild fans have seen more Knies games than Wallstedt games.
 
Maybe if Gus hadn't shat the bed last season. 2.10 GAA and .931 save % in 39 games in 22-23 as a 25 year old. 23-24 was a whole different story, .899 save % and 3.06 GAA in 45 games where he was counted on as #1, i.e. unreliable.

Love having Fleury hang around for his value as a hockey player and human being, but he likely hangs em up, and which Gus you gonna get?

Wallstedt is indispensable at this point.
 
Bizz said:
Wallstedt is Minnesota's goalie for the future, without him they pretty much have no options. Knies doesn't do anything for Minnesota in the near term either.

You're better off using Knies to get Askarov from Nashville.
Click to expand...
At least Askarov might be more available than Wallstedt because of Saros's new deal.

Seems that Leaf fans are saying that they think they are fine in goal, and need a player like Knies, anyway. The whole premise of this thread is flawed, IMO. MN needs Wallstedt in the medium, if not short term, and have plenty enough young middle six talent either on the team or coming up in the next year or two in Boldy, Rossi, Yurov, Ohgren, maybe Khusnutdinov, Heidt. TOR has a couple, potentially, in Cowan and Minten, but can't let Knies go, not only from a talent perspective, but also because of his salary status.
 
Honestly, Minnesota has a Knies in Hartman (if he stays healthy). Hartman's best season should be what Knies tries to achieve every season. On the flip side Wallstedt could become the next Vasilevsky and I'd be hard pressed to trade Vas for Hartman.
 
thestonedkoala said:
Honestly, Minnesota has a Knies in Hartman (if he stays healthy). Hartman's best season should be what Knies tries to achieve every season. On the flip side Wallstedt could become the next Vasilevsky and I'd be hard pressed to trade Vas for Hartman.
Click to expand...
I think Knies will end up MUCH better than Hartman
 
40% of Toronto fans would do this
1% of Minnesota fans would do this

The results don’t lie. Awful deal
 
TaLoN said:
I expect him to be a very good 2nd line power forward.
Hartman is a 3rd line utility forward who can be a pest.
Click to expand...
Okay, I think your opinion of Hartman is pretty low. He has averaged 56 points per 82 games the last 3 seasons with mostly even strength production. That’s not 3rd line production.
 
Digitalbooya said:
Okay, I think your opinion of Hartman is pretty low. He has averaged 56 points per 82 games the last 3 seasons with mostly even strength production. That’s not 3rd line production.
Click to expand...
Only because he played with Kaprizov, as a center due to necessity since we didn't have any center depth.
Prior to that he was a 3rd line winger when we had better centers.

On a real playoff team, he's not a top 6 player.
 
TaLoN said:
Only because he played with Kaprizov, as a center due to necessity since we didn't have any center depth.
Prior to that he was a 3rd line winger when we had better centers.

On a real playoff team, he's not a top 6 player.
Click to expand...
I do not agree with this at all. Is Rossi a 3rd line player in your books?
 
TaLoN said:
Only because he played with Kaprizov, as a center due to necessity since we didn't have any center depth.
Prior to that he was a 3rd line winger when we had better centers.

On a real playoff team, he's not a top 6 player.
Click to expand...
I mean he didn't really play with Kaprizov last season and was injured or coming off injuries and still put up 21 goals in 74 games. I'd say that is more middle 6 than anything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DigitalBoldy
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom