Proposal: VAN - MIN (Fiala+for Miller)

[Nucklehead Supreme]

So why not leave the thread? If you’re not going to engage in discussion and just focused on calling people lunatics, why are you even here?

Because you seem to be stuck in this thought that you are right, and basing that on Wild fans having a bias, as a Canucks fan, I'm telling you, you are in fact the one that is wrong.

Felt it was the necessary thing to do, you know since you seem just soo stuck.

 

[Minnewildsota]

You can use the same argument if I replaced Miller with McDavid. Guess we don’t trade Fiala for McDavid either

You see how that argument doesn’t make any sense?

Why are you so angry? You’re basically yelling at everyone because we’re not interested in trading Fiala for Miller.

 

[Dr Jan Itor]

Why are you so angry? You’re basically yelling at everyone because we’re not interested in trading Fiala for Miller.

And now comparing Miller to McDavid...

 

[IceBoxHockey]

You can use the same argument if I replaced Miller with McDavid. Guess we don’t trade Fiala for McDavid either

You see how that argument doesn’t make any sense?

His point still stands. Your solution for us is to trade off our depth to sign Miller. So you use McDavid as an example to prove your point but really it enforces his. How are the Oilers doing with McDavid and no depth?

 

[JohnHodgson]

Why are you so angry? You’re basically yelling at everyone because we’re not interested in trading Fiala for Miller.

How so?

A lot of the arguments don’t make any sense from your fanbase.

Thanks for your input though.

 

[JohnHodgson]

His point still stands. Your solution for us is to trade off our depth to sign Miller. So you use McDavid as an example to prove your point but really it enforces his. How are the Oilers doing with McDavid and no depth?

My point still stands.

Trading a Marcus Foligno does not deplete your team of depth.

 

[IceBoxHockey]

My point still stands.

Trading a Marcus Foligno does not deplete your team of depth.

We would have to trade off more than just Foligno though.

 

[JohnHodgson]

His point still stands. Your solution for us is to trade off our depth to sign Miller. So you use McDavid as an example to prove your point but really it enforces his. How are the Oilers doing with McDavid and no depth?

Oilers don’t have defenseman and goaltending, something Minnesota has.

Not really a comparison that holds any weight.

 

[JohnHodgson]

We would have to trade off more than a Foligno though.

How so?

You think Miller would make more than Fiala and Foligno combined?

 

[Joseph Nathan]

My point still stands.

Trading a Marcus Foligno does not deplete your team of depth.

We don't really care what you think. We aren't trading foligno, neither is our gm.

 

[Joseph Nathan]

Oilers don’t have defenseman and goaltending, something Minnesota has.

Not really a comparison that holds any weight.

Oilers have D, and G? So you are revealing yourself to just bsing alot.

 

[IceBoxHockey]

How so?

You think Miller would make more than Fiala and Foligno combined?

What about cap space to sign other players? We have 14 million in dead cap coming. I’m not in favor of adding anymore 8/9 million dollar contracts until after that dead cap is gone.

 

[Minnewildsota]

Just because it didn’t make sense to you, doesn’t mean it didn’t make sense. We’ve explained ad nauseum why this doesn’t make sense for the Wild. If I were you, I would trust the fans that pay attention to the team.

 

[IceBoxHockey]

Oilers don’t have defenseman and goaltending, something Minnesota has.

Not really a comparison that holds any weight.

That’s my point. To fit miller’s contract we’d have to sacrifice depth.

 

[rangersfansince08]

You can use the same argument if I replaced Miller with McDavid. Guess we don’t trade Fiala for McDavid either

You see how that argument doesn’t make any sense?

LOL. The hell do Miller and McDavid have in common?

 

[Mnsportsfan22]

You can use the same argument if I replaced Miller with McDavid. Guess we don’t trade Fiala for McDavid either

You see how that argument doesn’t make any sense?

Pssttt.... Miller isn't McDavid....

 

[Dr Jan Itor]

Just because it didn’t make sense to you, doesn’t mean it didn’t make sense. We’ve explained ad nauseum why this doesn’t make sense for the Wild. If I were you, I would trust the fans that pay attention to the team.

He must only watch our team once a month.

 

[JohnHodgson]

Just because it didn’t make sense to you, doesn’t mean it didn’t make sense. We’ve explained ad nauseum why this doesn’t make sense for the Wild. If I were you, I would trust the fans that pay attention to the team.

that’s fair but fans aren’t an indication of anything to be honest.

For example, fans long time ago said why would we ever need cory schneider? We have mackenzie blackwood, the devils would never make this deal… a month later, they traded for schneider.

the simple premise of this deal is the Wild are addressing one of their biggest needs and improving significantly.

if you think it doesn’t make sense then sure. I dont think a competing team looking to land a first line center and address their biggest organizational need is an absurd concept… but do you.

 

[Mnsportsfan22]

that’s fair but fans aren’t an indication of anything to be honest.

For example, fans long time ago said why would we ever need cory schneider? We have mackenzie blackwood, the devils would never make this deal… a month later, they traded for schneider.

the simple premise of this deal is the Wild are addressing one of their biggest needs and improving significantly.

if you think it doesn’t make sense then sure. I dont think a competing team looking to land a first line center and address their biggest organizational need is an absurd concept… but do you.

You know what can really help this team? Rossi! Do you know why the wild won't call him up this year?

 

[JohnHodgson]

LOL. The hell do Miller and McDavid have in common?

Someone said Fiala for Milller makes no sense because they would have to trade a contract like Marcus Foligno to accommodate Miller’s contract (all hypothetical by the way).

Trading one contract does not deplete Minny’s depth.

 

[JohnHodgson]

Because you seem to be stuck in this thought that you are right, and basing that on Wild fans having a bias, as a Canucks fan, I'm telling you, you are in fact the one that is wrong.

Felt it was the necessary thing to do, you know since you seem just soo stuck.

I have an opinion.

there is no “right” or “wrong”

its a hockey forum lol

 

[Minnewildsota]

that’s fair but fans aren’t an indication of anything to be honest.

For example, fans long time ago said why would we ever need cory schneider? We have mackenzie blackwood, the devils would never make this deal… a month later, they traded for schneider.

the simple premise of this deal is the Wild are addressing one of their biggest needs and improving significantly.

if you think it doesn’t make sense then sure. I dont think a competing team looking to land a first line center and address their biggest organizational need is an absurd concept… but do you.

Then call Bill Guerin. JFC. I’ve never seen someone fight so hard to trade a player away

I’ll make this easy for you. WE DON’T WANT TO TRADE FOR MILLER REGARDLESS OF HOW GOOD HE IS OR HOW MUCH IT WOULD MAKE SENSE TO YOU

 

[IceBoxHockey]

Someone said Fiala for Milller makes no sense because they would have to trade a contract like Marcus Foligno to accommodate Miller’s contract (all hypothetical by the way).

Trading one contract does not deplete Minny’s depth.

In this world your working in does it not include contract extensions for other players? By the time Millers contract would kick in we would have to deal with signing Boldy to a new deal. That won’t be cheap. What about Zuccarello, Dumba or Kähkönen?

It’s not just one contract we are talking about. The Wild have to smart about their cap, more so than most teams, due to the dead cap space. Why is that so hard to understand?

 

[Joseph Nathan]

Someone said Fiala for Milller makes no sense because they would have to trade a contract like Marcus Foligno to accommodate Miller’s contract (all hypothetical by the way).

Trading one contract does not deplete Minny’s depth.

No one said this. You are lying. You keep trying to force us to trade foligno to accommodate JT Miller and it's been made clear to you, our GM won't trade him. Just like you have inconveniently skipped over the part where reports are saying he's no longer involved with, or interested in JT Miller

 

[Nucklehead Supreme]

I have an opinion.

there is no “right” or “wrong”

its a hockey forum lol

Your "opinion" is one thing your overreaction and tantrum is something else entirely