JetsHomer
Registered User
- Nov 29, 2011
- 10,941
- 3,146
I wouldn't trade Sergachev for Trouba. Who knows what trouba is seeking.
I wouldn't trade Connor for Galchenyuk. Who knows how much money Galchenyuk wants!
I wouldn't trade Sergachev for Trouba. Who knows what trouba is seeking.
Value wise this trade is off. Sergachev will be better than Trouba in the long run, I see Trouba as a poor man's Dion Phaneuf, he plateau'd very soon - I don't see him getting much better than this but that doesn't mean he won't be a very good top pairing defenseman (not a #1), but Sergachev has much more potential.
This is pretty close to what i think Trouba, Will eventually sign for.
Value wise this trade is off. Sergachev will be better than Trouba in the long run, I see Trouba as a poor man's Dion Phaneuf, he plateau'd very soon - I don't see him getting much better than this but that doesn't mean he won't be a very good top pairing defenseman (not a #1), but Sergachev has much more potential.
Trouba to Detroit for Svechnikov + Cholowski + cap dump
Trouba to Detroit for Svechnikov + Cholowski + cap dump
Nope, nope aaaaaand.... nope. You don't have the assets to get him.
Unless that cap dump is at least $5 million, It's not going to work cap wise for us.
Yup any deal involving Detroit for Trouba, Would've to include the 3rd team that would have the LHD that Cheveldayoff would want. And we just don't have it.
Trouba to winnipeg for nothing.
Call me crazy, but I even prefer to bet on Sergachev than taking Trouba straight up.
I dont see the need to waste a 1st there
Ur normal then
Out of interest, how many full games of Sergachev have you seen him play?
As a fan of both the Leafs and Jets, if the Jets feel they really have to trade Trouba (I'd rather they trade Myers), I think an offer based around Gardiner and a conditional 2017 1st round pick would be beneficial to both sides.
Condition on that pick being if the Leafs end up drafting in the top 5, Winnipeg gets their 2018 1st instead (10-15 overall range by my estimations).
Don't bother offering scraps. Offer a defenseman, comparable to Trouba age wise (max 23) and talent wise (borderline top pairing guy with upside to be even better).
If he indeed can play both sides, I would offer Beaulieu, 2017 1st and a cap dump.