Jimmi McJenkins
Sometimes miracles
Some prospect as in Colborne or.... Gardiner?
Blacker or Biggs, you know, the "big time" guys.Rumor: Trade Rumors and Proposals Thread XXV: Season over. Still waiting to begin...
- Thread starter s7ark
- Start date
- Status
Blacker or Biggs, you know, the "big time" guys.
I know we've been talking about possible trades, if you want some laughs, Leafs fans figure that Phaneuf, #21 and some prospect would net PRV and #7
That isnt the worst trade ever. I wouldnt do it, but it's not laughable.
Jimmi McJenkins
Sometimes miracles
PRV and the 7th Overall pick for Dion Phaneuf, the 21st overall pick and Biggs/Blacker? That's laughable.
Anaheim could be the darkhorse to steal MacT's thunder this summer. What would it take for Letang?
Etem, Rakell and Gibson?
the you move Ryan for youth from Ottawa (Zibinajad?Turris? and a dman) or NYR or PHI ...watch out for the Ducks!
I don't think that is laughable either.
Phaneuf is terribly overrated and I don't want him on the Oil, but the value of that proposal isn't terribly far off. I wouldn't do it, but saying this is laughable is like Leaf fans saying our valuation of Gardiner is laughable.
Oilception
Registered User
You probably find napolean dynamite funny too... You cant account for some peoples taste in humor!
Dion, despite being a DB, is a top pairing dman....we currently dont have a top pairing dman.
They dont come cheap.
If it wad a trade and sign, I'd seriously consider it.
Beerfish
Registered User
- Apr 14, 2007
- 19,513
- 5,665
I can only hope someone steals that thunder. Letang would be a nice addition but the contract sounds brutal to me. Huge price to get the guy and a massive contract. Count me out of the letang derby.
MetaOil1993
Registered User
Jimmi McJenkins
Sometimes miracles
Whats more laughable is the 7th, Klefbom and Paajarvi for Phaneuf
One poster suggested that anything short of Eberle and Klefbom and they pass. That Kool-aid must be really good.
nhlisajoke
Registered User
Whats more laughable is the 7th, Klefbom and Paajarvi for Phaneuf
the only trade i make for Phaneuf is Horcoff straight up
hey guys, what do u think and Devante -Smith-Pelly.......does anyone else think he can be had for cheap? I saw him at the red white game for canada two years ago and he was just exploding guys
Jimmi McJenkins
Sometimes miracles
Accordint to Dreger, Peverley is a available, seems like a guy that would fit nicely into the bottom-6 and provide more center depth, what do you think it takes to acquire him?
Draiskull
Registered User
- Oct 26, 2005
- 23,388
- 2,246
I would certainly inquire about him if I was the GM... I think he goes in part of a package for a big fish.
Edit: re Peverly being available... hardly a new news.. Dreger is pretty much stating the obvious.
Whats more laughable is the 7th, Klefbom and Paajarvi for Phaneuf
Oh ya... That's bad!
MetaOil1993
Registered User
Some fans make the whole fan base look bad. I know there's quite a few good posters from them but it seems like most of them are just little kids and it turns into a bashing show. I wish we can just ban Leafs/Oilers proposals on the main board. That stuff is just embarrassing to read.Honestly it would take a 3rd IMO. They need to shed salary so his value shouldn't be high especially coming off an awful season.
Too bad Tambo gave away our 3rd for Fistric without getting one back for Whitney/Hemsky at the deadline
Not sure but would love to have him.
Jejune
Registered User
I think this is the thinking we need to get away from. The only way we're going to win a trade is by taking a chance. If we only go for guys that performed well lately and don't have any issues, we're going to by above market value. If we get underperforming guys that we are confident in we can watch them turn it around and laugh in the other team's faces. It will be wonderful.
I did think that Peverley showed some jump in the playoffs and could be an extremely useful player here. I wouldn't want to pay too much, but I think he would help out our bottom 6 immensely.
It seems like 3rd lines around the league really just need one motivated, energetic player on them to get them going. If you get one player that has enough motivation and jump, it will usually get the other two to play harder and faster, and cause fits for the other teams. Glencross is a good example of this. Brodziak and Stortini were doing sweet FA until he showed up, and then all of a sudden they're a dynamite 3rd line. I think Peverley could be that guy.
MikeModano9
Registered User
In a dream world.. Our bottom 6 this year.
MPS-Bolland-Clutterbuck
xxxx-Peverley-xxxx
I guess as it looks Smyth and Brown will be in the bottom 6. Just not in my dream world. Hahah
MPS-Bolland-Clutterbuck
xxxx-Peverley-xxxx
I guess as it looks Smyth and Brown will be in the bottom 6. Just not in my dream world. Hahah
MetaOil1993
Registered User
Also RNH has shoulder problems while Gardiner is durable as a rock.I wonder if Peverley would waive his NTC to come here though?
Redwood Original
El Presidente
- May 3, 2007
- 1,494
- 1
Peverley isn't a fourth line center, neither is Bolland. Perhaps Peverley could play the 2c role if Gagner shifts to the wing.
joestevens29
Registered User
- Apr 30, 2009
- 54,051
- 17,176
dustrock
Too Legit To Quit
- Sep 22, 2008
- 8,494
- 1,421
Fair comment - I did say I was interested, but I'd like to see who else is available.
- Status
