Proposal: Trade Proposal Thread: Part 77

[HuGo Burner Acc]

Here's an interesting proposal, would you make a trade for Arizona's 3OA for Habs 2023 first Rd pick (lottery protected)

 

[Licou]

Jaedong's team was Evil Geniuses too!

Yup in ScII I mostly remember him from his BW days.

I am glad I am not the only SC nerd!

 

[FF de Mars]

Yup in ScII I mostly remember him from his BW days.

I am glad I am not the only SC nerd!

My favourite player has been Serral since then. I still watch it, it's as intense as hockey!

 

[Licou]

My favourite player has been Serral since then. I still watch it, it's as intense as hockey!

My favorite SC2 player are/were sOs and Maru.

Is still vividly remember that Blizzcon finale between sOs and Life... what a spectacular series!

I haven't watched a match in a while, I should get back at it.

I really enjoyed the Kespa proleague. I was sad when it folded.

 

[Kaladin]

Arizona has the Canes first pick courtesy of us.

Completely forgot about that! Thanks.

 

[Nico Cauzuki]

Weber and rights to Struble probably get Canes first pick back. Habs deep on LD can move Struble. Use the pick to draft Luneau or Chesley.

Flames pick and our 33rd to Canucks for 15th? Kasper could be good pick at 15.

Gives Habs Wright, Kasper and Luneau first round.

Struble isnt worth nothing and Weber's contract aint worth much neither,will probably end up paying something small or get a 3rd/4th back

 

[tazsub3]

Struble isnt worth nothing and Weber's contract aint worth much neither,will probably end up paying something small or get a 3rd/4th back

so you saying 26 million cash saving for a broke team aint worth anything?
then let us agree to disagree.

 

[SwiftyHab]

I would do it

You’re undervaluing Guhle. he’s got top 2 potential.

 

[Licou]

You’re undervaluing Guhle. he’s got top 2 potential.

I like him as a prospect, but I *think* Cooley or Nemec have a much higher upside.

 

[SwiftyHab]

Here's an interesting proposal, would you make a trade for Arizona's 3OA for Habs 2023 first Rd pick (lottery protected)

So we’d get their 3rd this year, and best they could do is 2nd but more likely higher next year?

sure. Where do we sign?

 

[HuGo Burner Acc]

So we’d get their 3rd this year, and best they could do is 2nd but more likely higher next year?

sure. Where do we sign?

The thing is, the projected top 10 next season looks like they could all go in this year's top 5, a few (besides Bedard, Fantalli, Michkov) even probably going top 3 in 2022. So the tradeoff is sooner product or wait for maybe a higher end player (if you think Habs will be bad next year)

 

[Nico Cauzuki]

so you saying 26 million cash saving for a broke team aint worth anything?
then let us agree to disagree.

Your gonna be disappointed this summer when you see the return isnt a 1st round pick

 

[HuGort]

Struble isnt worth nothing and Weber's contract aint worth much neither,will probably end up paying something small or get a 3rd/4th back

Why isn't Struble worth anything?

 

[Kimota]

Here's an interesting proposal, would you make a trade for Arizona's 3OA for Habs 2023 first Rd pick (lottery protected)

I would do it only if we I'm sure to get Slaf on the 3rd pick. And that Hughes make us competitive next year. Cause say we lose the lottery but we get 2nd pick then we lose Michkov.

 

[tazsub3]

Your gonna be disappointed this summer when you see the return isnt a 1st round pick

well i never said it will be a first,. However you said we have to give to get rid, and that is what i disagree with.

 

[Beendair Donedat]

I like him as a prospect, but I *think* Cooley or Nemec have a much higher upside.

Guhle is the best defenseman in the CHL, and the captain of the Team Canada World Juniors team. He plays monster minutes and in all situations for his WHL club (the Oil Kings) where he’s been simply dominant this playoffs. This is a cornerstone stud defenseman that we have here - a leader, has size, a mean streak, hits like a truck, skates well, has an excellent pass and shot, puts up points, and can play anywhere - and excel! There’s a reason he’s often compared to Shea Weber. It’s been a really long time since we’ve had such a completely well rounded prospect.

 

[Kimota]

Guys ask yourself that question:

Would you trade our pick for a top 9 player + a late pick + 2 ok prospect ?

What would be the point of that. We'll pick Wright hoping he has more upsides than late picks and ok prospects and third liners.

 

[JuJu Mobb]

(Not gonna happen scenario)

Trade big cap hit players, grab Fiala.

 

[Licou]

Guhle is the best defenseman in the CHL, and the captain of the Team Canada World Juniors team. He plays monster minutes and in all situations for his WHL club (the Oil Kings) where he’s been simply dominant this playoffs. This is a cornerstone stud defenseman that we have here - a leader, has size, a mean streak, hits like a truck, skates well, has an excellent pass and shot, puts up points, and can play anywhere - and excel! There’s a reason he’s often compared to Shea Weber. It’s been a really long time since we’ve had such a completely well rounded prospect.

Thanks for sharing.

I really like his kit not going to lie. But I would trade such a player for a "Markov" any day of the week. But that might just be my PTSD talking.

Is Guhle showing he can run a PP in the CHL?

 

[bcv]

Thanks for sharing.

I really like his kit not going to lie. But I would trade such a player for a "Markov" any day of the week. But that might just be my PTSD talking.

Is Guhle showing he can run a PP in the CHL?

No

 

[Takeru]

Would you trade Guhle and CGY 1st for NJ 2nd?

Dont see how devils do it when they can instead turn around and draft jiricek/nemec and instantly have a better D prospect than ghule. I doubt a late first bridges the quality gap from their pov.

The whole idea behind NJ pick being in play is for them getting more competitive.
I dont see how that deal accomplishes that for them.

 

[HuGo Burner Acc]

I would do it only if we I'm sure to get Slaf on the 3rd pick. And that Hughes make us competitive next year. Cause say we lose the lottery but we get 2nd pick then we lose Michkov.

The lottery is the first 2 picks. They draw for both.

 

[David Suzuki]

Would you trade Guhle and CGY 1st for NJ 2nd?

In a second lol

 

[Nico Cauzuki]

Why isn't Struble worth anything?

because every team has atleast 3/4 strubles,does he even make our top 10 prospects

 

[Habs Halifax]

I just left the coyotes board, people there think that the habs should pay for the coyotes to take webers contract, I countered with a different viewpoint with explanation.

Ignorant fans. Little's contract has more actual money to pay out in a shorter span vs Weber while Weber takes up more cap room to reach the floor.

It's just not debatable. Weber's contract it worth more to the Coyotes than Little's contract is.

because every team has atleast 3/4 strubles,does he even make our top 10 prospects

False. Not every team has 3 or 4 Strubles and just cause he don't make our top 10 prospects, it don't make his value less. It just means our pool is deep. Not many teams can measure up to the Habs draft power over the last few drafts.

Struble is a grade B or B+ type (at best today). Maybe each team has 1 but your reaching with the 3 or 4 narrative. He's not a grade B- or C prospect which is how I see your evaluation on him.