HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #88: 2024 Off-Season Thread

[vokiel]

Glad you are not the GM....
lol

Cause Barron would be out already?

 

[Miller Time]

I would give up Barron + 2025 1st without blinking an eye

Seems excessive.

Even most Preds fans don't expect that kind of return.

 

[calder candidate]

We just made a significant move... Now between the current player+ propects+ picks we seem to have almost all the piece lineup to build a contender,
now is not the time to be overly aggressive we need to let player sort them self out see which one are good enough to build on and who can fill different roles. This is the exact step where it is easy to try to speed up the process and trip up, we need to be even more patient.
Once we know we have people that are good enough in the most important roles, than we can address the one that are missing or fill the secondary role.

There ton of Example Toronto, Edmonton, Detroit, Ottawa, Calgary of team that screw them self, some did or might over come their false starts but there were significant issue that set back their rebuild.

 

[calder candidate]

Calgary unprotected '26 pick be sweet

Yes and that pick might be Mckenna... but Florida will screw us again... We when from having a 2nd lottery pick in 2023 to ending up with 31st... and now again the CGY pick would certainly have been great but will get Florida...

 

[salbutera]

We just made a significant move... Now between the current player+ propects+ picks we seem to have almost all the piece lineup to build a contender,
now is not the time to be overly aggressive we need to let player sort them self out see which one are good enough to build on and who can fill different roles. This is the exact step where it is easy to try to speed up the process and trip up, we need to be even more patient.
Once we know we have people that are good enough in the most important roles, than we can address the one that are missing or fill the secondary role.

There ton of Example Toronto, Edmonton, Detroit, Ottawa, Calgary of team that screw them self, some did or might over come their false starts but there were significant issue that set back their rebuild.

F*ck that, nows the time to be Uber agressive in targeted moves which fit age + need - namely McGroarty + Askarov.

- McGroarty for Mailloux

- Askarov for Barron + 1st rounder top-15 protected if that’s what it takes

 

[Kudo Shinichi]

If we end up acquiring Askarov, the plan could be:

24-25
Monty (starter)
Askarov (backup)

Ahl: Dobes
NCAA: Fowler


25-26
Monty
Askarov

Ahl: Dobes and Fowler


26-27
Askarov
Dobes

AHL: Fowler

(Monty traded with 1 year left on his contract)


27-28
Askarov
Dobes

Ahl: Fowler


28-29
Askarov
Fowler

(Dobes traded)

 

[RationalExpectations]

F*ck that, nows the time to be Uber agressive in targeted moves which fit age + need - namely McGroarty + Askarov.

- McGroarty for Mailloux

- Askarov for Barron + 1st rounder top-15 protected if that’s what it takes

View attachment 902509

Askarov has not shown anything yet.

I have been defending Barron, and am not the greatest Mailloux fan at this stage but let s see what MTL has in store becore tradinf the farm.

 

[themilosh]

Yes and that pick might be Mckenna... but Florida will screw us again... We when from having a 2nd lottery pick in 2023 to ending up with 31st... and now again the CGY pick would certainly have been great but will get Florida...

And Floridas is going to be 11th oa.. teams are going to start busting soon.. the atlantic is due for a shakeup.

 

[HabbyGuy]

I actually thought he would have a big year because he had a really good camp and finished the previous year pretty strong too. It all went downhill when the season started.

I agree, I thought the season prior to last was Anderson's best hockey of his career. Last year was so damn frustrating and annoying to watch him flounder and float after the first month and things didn't go his way. I didn't even care that he wasn't scoring, it was his lack of any kind of engagement that was so infuriating.

Anderson still has value to his team with his size speed and physicality even without producing. The fact he couldn't be bothered to even do that, as a veteran on this young team, is what pissed most of us off.

 

[ReHabs]

Anderson still has value to his team with his size speed and physicality even without producing. The fact he couldn't be bothered to do that as a veteran on this young team is what pissed most of us off.

Why is this often repeated when it's been proven to not be true? Anderson is a BAD forechecker because he's CONSTANTLY behind the play. He doesn't use his body nearly as much as some of you imply. He doesn't carry the puck well at all either. His physicality is a non-factor.

 

[HabbyGuy]

Why is this often repeated when it's been proven to not be true? Anderson is a BAD forechecker because he's CONSTANTLY behind the play. He doesn't use his body nearly as much as some of you imply. He doesn't carry the puck well at all either. His physicality is a non-factor.

How can something demonstrably false be proven? Lets just agree to disagree, an engaged Josh Anderson is a handful for any team to deal with. Just ask Jon Cooper who said they had no answer for him in their sweep loss to Columbus or ask the Leafs every time he plays them.

 

[ReHabs]

How can something false be proven? Lets just agree to disagree, an engaged Josh Anderson is a handful for any team to deal with. Just ask Jon Cooper who said they had no answer for him in their sweep loss to Columbus or ask the Leafs every time he plays them.

Oh boy, I hope to one day see "an engaged Josh Anderson".

 

[HabbyGuy]

Oh boy, I hope to one day see "an engaged Josh Anderson".

You clearly haven't, I dunno what you've been watching when he's on.

 

[HuGort]

F*ck that, nows the time to be Uber agressive in targeted moves which fit age + need - namely McGroarty + Askarov.

- McGroarty for Mailloux

- Askarov for Barron + 1st rounder top-15 protected if that’s what it takes

View attachment 902509

You trading a lot of right D aren't you? One of hardest assets to get

 

[salbutera]

You trading a lot of right D aren't you? One of hardest assets to get

Gotta give to get - IMO an NHL ready top-6 power F and potential starting G are the last 2-core elements needed for rebuild completion - w Demigod + Redenbacher a season away

From that point fwd it’s all about organic growth + key veteran additions + asset / cap management to keep feeding the prospect pool while building up trade ammo

 

[ReHabs]

You clearly haven't, I dunno what you've been watching when he's on.

Anderson sulked for 60 games straight last year. When is he on?

He last produced at the tail end of the 2022-2023 season, for about 10 dead-rubber no-pressure games.

 

[HabbyGuy]

Anderson sulked for 60 games straight last year. When is he on?

Yes I said as much, in my original post. He was infuriatingly useless last year after the first month or so. No argument there.

 

[Whalers Fan]

Askarov has not shown anything yet.

I have been defending Barron, and am not the greatest Mailloux fan at this stage but let s see what MTL has in store becore tradinf the farm.

Agreed. Askarov's own team doesn't think he's ready for the NHL, as they signed Scott Wedgewood to a two year contract to backup the recently extended Saros. Some folks here are acting like Askarov is a slam dunk future star, while there are questions about whether he will actually be future starter material.

Trading away RD prospects for an unproven goalie prospect makes no sense to me.

 

[BLONG7]

Askarov has not shown anything yet.

I have been defending Barron, and am not the greatest Mailloux fan at this stage but let s see what MTL has in store becore tradinf the farm.

Agreed................if Askarov is that good....................why did they not package Saros instead of signing him longer term??
Trust the process boys, we are going in the right direction

 

[BLONG7]

I agree, I thought the season prior to last was Anderson's best hockey of his career. Last year was so damn frustrating and annoying to watch him flounder and float after the first month and things didn't go his way. I didn't even care that he wasn't scoring, it was his lack of any kind of engagement that was so infuriating.

Anderson still has value to his team with his size speed and physicality even without producing. The fact he couldn't be bothered to even do that, as a veteran on this young team, is what pissed most of us off.

Andy was bad last year, and then he was pouting and made it worse......I am hopeful he comes back with passion and proves everyone wrong, but I for one will not hold my breath.
If he does it, it will be from the 3rd line.......he can have a role on the team, let's hope he accepts it.

This is coming from a fan of his who has been left always wanting more from him......the ball is firmly in his court. Thinking Dvorak and Roy will be his linemates......let's see how it goes.

 

[Rob Sense]

In terms of Goalie prospects in the league, the Athletic has Askarov #2 and Fowler #3. Why give away top assets for someone who has not pushed for a spot on his team and has asked for a trade? Too risky...our guy will be Fowler.

 

[Habs Halifax]

In terms of Goalie prospects in the league, the Athletic has Askarov #2 and Fowler #3. Why give away top assets for someone who has not pushed for a spot on his team and has asked for a trade? Too risky...our guy will be Fowler.

I would listen to Askarov trade talks but no way we should be opening up our futures to acquire him when we are in solid shape with Monty/Primeau/Fowler.

Wouldn't it be a shame if we trade for Askarov and he is not even better than Primeau? Primeau is older and more NHL ready. He really worked hard last year in between games to improve and he deserves more credit or respect.

If we are using youth to acquire youth, go get McGroarty.

 

[WeThreeKings]

In terms of Goalie prospects in the league, the Athletic has Askarov #2 and Fowler #3. Why give away top assets for someone who has not pushed for a spot on his team and has asked for a trade? Too risky...our guy will be Fowler.

You just be around it.. Hughes is smart, he's not gonna sell the farm for Askarov.. but if there's an opportunity to turn someone like Barron and excess of picks into Askarov, you might as well do it. Barron will be supplanted quickly by Mailloux and Reinbacher.

 

[Whalers Fan]

You just be around it.. Hughes is smart, he's not gonna sell the farm for Askarov.. but if there's an opportunity to turn someone like Barron and excess of picks into Askarov, you might as well do it. Barron will be supplanted quickly by Mailloux and Reinbacher .

The team still needs a 3rd Rd - - unless they want to keep playing Guhle on his wrong side.

 

[BLONG7]

The team still needs a 3rd Rd - - unless they want to keep playing Guhle on his wrong side.

We have to get Guhlie back on his left side......asap.