HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #87: 2024 Season Finale

[The Great Weal]

Yes, that is a better reason for why Carolina would not be interested than saying they have Slavin and Orlov.

Well I mean if it would be for a 2 year thing, one of those years wouldn't really count given that Slavin and Orlov will be playing ahead. That just leaves the last year. If it was a 2 year thing of having him be in the top 4 it could maybe make more sense where they want to go on another run before Slavin leaves, but either way there's really no valid reason for Carolina to do this.

 

[Deus ex machina]

I think it is fair offer.

Are you guys on bath salts? (just kidding)

Seriously, Kaliyev's value doesn't come close Struble's. Montreal would be nuts to do this, and i don't think they will.
I really don't see Kaliyev fitting in the MTL culture anyway.

Struble seems to be undervalued a lot on this board. I don't know why. I guess we didn't see the same games.
FWIW, David Ettedgui said on BPM yesterday that Struble was in high demand across the league right now, and that makes sense.


The Habs are looking for a top 6 F and they'd love to trade Barron for one, but it's just not realistic.
I think they'll just take what they can get for him. Same thing with Kaliyev.

Speaking of Barron, Arpon Basu said on one of his podcasts that he spoke to scouts from other teams while attending a Rocket game and apparently, they weren't impressed much with him. I wasn't either, from what i saw.

 

[417]

Well I mean if it would be for a 2 year thing, one of those years wouldn't really count given that Slavin and Orlov will be playing ahead. That just leaves the last year. If it was a 2 year thing of having him be in the top 4 it could maybe make more sense where they want to go on another run before Slavin leaves, but either way there's really no valid reason for Carolina to do this.

What about the fact Matheson > Orlov and and that Slavin/Orlov might be gone after next year and they could re-sign Matheson and transition for that Russian kid I hear good things about?

Orlov played mostly on their 3rd pair this year at just over 17 minutes a game.

Mathieson is just a better player and I didn't even mention th cap flexibility he would give them the next 2 years because of his great contract.

There's a lot of reasons why they would/should be interested.

 

[Deus ex machina]

I feels like its worst this year, just because the media (and some fans) are pushing for the Habs to make a big splash this off-season.

What I don't get is why the majority of the proposals are for soft offense only forwards. Are anyone watching the playoffs and what HuGo has been saying???

It's because they're the only players made available by their teams. The good ones are almost never available. That's why they have to draft them.

 

[ML16]

Hughes is going to ask the price for anyone available out there, this help defining the market price for his own players.

But a few weeks before the 2022 draft, media-insiders were saying that Hughes was calling everyone to find another 1st round pick in the top 10 (ended up #13 and was used in the Dach trade).

In the last week, I heard/read a few of the same media-insiders saying that Hughes is trying to trade up (from Winnipeg 1st)/get another selection in the top 15.

Another top 15 pick could be interesting indeed, but in order to move up in that range, the Habs would surely need to use #26 OA (WPG’s 1st) + #57 OA (COL’s 2nd) + a 2025 2nd (OR maybe a young D) ; a steep price, even in the quality > quantity perspective the Habs should adopt at this stage.

I don’t know prospects well enough, but I guess a few potential « fallers » could make such moving up gamble worthwhile? Sennecke? Bransegg-Nygaard? Connelly?

This being said, I think the likelier outcome is that #26 OA and/or #57 OA will be packaged along with a young LHD (Struble or Harris) for a young top-9 forward.

 

[Benstheman]

I would love to move up from Winn’s 1st and get out of the draft with Lindstrom and MBN/Yakemchuk.

 

[Richiebottles]

A name no one is talking about and there has been rumours before....

Jordan Kyrou.

I bet you that is the target this off season.

 

[sampollock]

A name no one is talking about and there has been rumours before....

Jordan Kyrou.

I bet you that is the target this off season.

There's a new name that hasn't been batted around yet

 

[417]

There's a new name that hasn't been batted around yet

He makes more than Suzuki though, it could throw the entire Habs salary structure completely out of whack.

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

A name no one is talking about and there has been rumours before....

Jordan Kyrou.

I bet you that is the target this off season.

St. Louis wants to be competitive.

He's a skilled, but smaller player, but he is locked on long-term.

Doesn't really fit all that well if they're wanting that experienced player that fits nicely into the top 6.

Pretty much everyone doesn't fit the best, but if the Habs do acquire someone, it's probably someone we're not talking about.

 

[BozoTheClown]

A name no one is talking about and there has been rumours before....

Jordan Kyrou.

I bet you that is the target this off season.

I would rather have Toropchenko. He is cheaper and more of what we need.

 

[Habs7631]

He's a skilled, but smaller player, but he is locked on long-term.

Is Kyrou small ? Caught a few Blues games this year and he looked average size to me.

Edit : Online sources says he’s 6’1, 195 lbs.

This sub wants everyone in the team to be like Slaf or something ???

 

[vokiel]

A name no one is talking about and there has been rumours before....

Jordan Kyrou.

I bet you that is the target this off season.

We've talked about him, no interests. Moving on...

 

[Scintillating10]

I would offer Matheson + jets 1st/Mesar + Trudeau for Necas

And roll with this next season

Slaf - Suzuki - Caufield
Necas - Dach - Newhook

Guhle - Savard
Hutson - Xhekaj
Struble - Harris

Could even have a Hutson - Reinbacher pairing if it looks great in camp

Way too much. At 25 and more than 350 NHL games Necas is pretty well what you going to get. Not much upside there. About 25 goals, 50 points with defensive issues.

Going to have to pay Necas a lot of money. Jets pick and a throw in far as I'm bidding for Necas's services..

 

[A Loyal Dog]

He makes more than Suzuki though, it could throw the entire Habs salary structure completely out of whack.

Only 250k more.

 

[A Loyal Dog]

A name no one is talking about and there has been rumours before....

Jordan Kyrou.

I bet you that is the target this off season.

I like it. But there are 2 things:

1. Would St. Louis be willing to trade him?
2. What would it cost us? I would not trade our 5th overall pick for him. But I know he's going to cost A LOT.

 

[Habs Icing]

Oh no, breaking the salary structure of a bad team.

It’s just following a market that is established by a bunch of factors. If we are determined in keeping Nick Suzuki our best player, we are not going to accomplish anything.

I'm not against breaking the Habs' salary structure, but not for Necas. If you break it for Necas, you're digging a hole in the ocean(a pointless move). Necas is not the player Suzuki is no matter how much you try to extrapolate Necas' numbers. With Necas on the team, Suzuki is still the best player and deserves the top dollar regardless of inflation. If you get a better player than Nick then you give that player the top dollar.

It seems Arthur Kaliyev asked for a trade..

1 for 1 : Barron vs Kaliyev ?

For me its a yes and if I was a LAK fan, I probably say yes too.

I see many posters are in a hurry to unload Barron. That's a mistake in my view. I would give him at least half the season to show any improvement before contemplating any trade.

 

[Habs Icing]

I don’t have a link here but Martin McGuire on BPM said that Kent Hughes isn’t busy getting a contract for Slaf but rather he’s constantly on his phone these days talking to people looking for an acquisition

Martin works for the NSA?

 

[Habs Icing]

I say keep your eye on Laine to the habs...gut feel

Maybe it's just indigestion.

 

[Habs Icing]

Matheson for Necas makes A LOT of sense for both teams IMO.

I'm not for or against that trade. It seems we're trading Matheson's offense for Necas's. A wash. Also, with that move, we eliminate half the veterans on defense. Is that a smart move?

 

[Benstheman]

I'm not for or against that trade. It seems we're trading Matheson's offense for Necas's. A wash. Also, with that move, we eliminate half the veterans on defense. Is that a smart move?

I think Hutson can replace Matheson's offense from the back end. Maybe not 5 vs 5 but on the PP, no problem. Also, that brings Guhle back to his natural side, which i think is the most important thing going forward. But yeah, that veteran presence on D will be thin. Maybe they target an RHD UFA comes july 1st??

 

[Habs Icing]

I think Hutson can replace Matheson's offense from the back end. Maybe not 5 vs 5 but on the PP, no problem. Also, that brings Guhle back to his natural side, which i think is the most important thing going forward. But yeah, that veteran presence on D will be thin. Maybe they target an RHD UFA comes july 1st??

Actually, you don't bring Guhle to the left side if you replace Matheson with Hutson.

 

[themilosh]

Actually, you don't bring Guhle to the left side if you replace Matheson with Hutson.

thats why you trade hutson for necas (signed at 7mx7) and draft parekh/Levshunov

 

[Milhouse40]

I think Hutson can replace Matheson's offense from the back end. Maybe not 5 vs 5 but on the PP, no problem. Also, that brings Guhle back to his natural side, which i think is the most important thing going forward. But yeah, that veteran presence on D will be thin. Maybe they target an RHD UFA comes july 1st??

Hutson can replace, but we're looking to add on offense from the backend, not replace it.

Matheson finished the year Top 10 in the league for point production for D and he's being paid a ridiculously low amount on top of it.

Matheson for Necas? What Carolina is adding?
If we trade Matheson is for full freaking value and a Top 10 D in the league is worth a lot more than a 50pts winger

 

[417]

Only 250k more.

Was just messing around lol