Toggle sidebar

HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #79

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
  • We are currently aware of "log in/security error" issues that are affecting some users. We apologize and ask for your patience as we try to get these issues fixed.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Adam Michaels said:
That's exactly what I said. The PLD to Montreal rumor is similar to the Trouba to the Rangers rumor.

Trouba was an RFA also and only wanted to go to the Rangers. Like PLD now, Jets had no obligation to send Trouba to New York. But despite it all, they ended up trading him to the Rangers for Pionk + a 1st. Trouba was not going to sign with anyone else. So that worked in Trouba's favor because teams might not have been willing to give up more to get someone who had no intention of staying there.
Click to expand...

Difference is that was a 2019 pick. I do not want to give up a 2023 pick at all for Dubois not even Florida's. It's a generational draft.
 
  • Like
Reactions: the, Adam Michaels, McPhees Moustache and 1 other person
tbcwpg said:
Respectfully I don't see how a podcast and confirmed reports of him being at the draft, which are definitely true, lead to the Jets changed the deal. Either side could still have done that.
Click to expand...
Not likely. Hughes has a lot of guys to move. He is not going to hinder those moves by reneging on a deal. But I bet HuGo wouldn't take another team changing a deal kindly. Backing out maybe but changing a deal No.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MarkovsKnee
McPhees Moustache said:
You're right - the Dach theory makes no sense.
Jets owned the 14th pick and could've added another pick of their own to acquire him as opposed to adding the complexity of having us acquire him to flip him to them
Click to expand...
Crazy theory time.

Hughes tried to make a deal to get the Jets 14th pick + Dubois, but Chevy decided to ask for more since it was in Montréal and he believed he could force Hughes's hand. But Hughes found a cheap deal to get #13 instead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ReHabs
morhilane said:
Crazy theory time.

Hughes tried to make a deal to get the Jets 14th pick + Dubois, but Chevy decided to ask for more since it was in Montréal and he believed he could force Hughes's hand. But Hughes found a cheap deal to get #13 instead.
Click to expand...
More plausible than Dach being part of the Dubois trade
 
Boss Man Hughes said:
Not likely. Hughes has a lot of guys to move. He is not going to hinder those moves by reneging on a deal. But I bet HuGo wouldn't take another team changing a deal kindly. Backing out maybe but changing a deal No.
Click to expand...

I don't see how it's out of the realm of possibility that Hughes may have tried to get the price lowered a bit. GMs are trying to maximize their value. And from 11 years of experience with Chevy backing out of a deal last minute like this would be the first time he's done it. His MO is having a price and not changing it. It's not unusual to think that Hughes said we're not moving X now why not take Y and Chevy said no we're not doing it.
 
CHfan1 said:
Add in Stamkos and Crosby, who both could have got more as well on the open market (although PLD is clearly not in their tier).

I’m just hoping if Montreal signs PLD it’s not because they outbid every team, it’s because PLD accepted a fair contract because he wants to play in Montreal.

I also believe a player taking less than what he could have got on the open market is a discount.
Click to expand...
Exceptions don't make the rule...you're pointing out a tiny percentage of players.

Could Dubois take a discount to sign in Montreal?

Maybe

Not sure it should be expected of him though.

Players want/should get paid....good for them when they raise the bar.

HabsWhiteKnightLOL said:
Habs are not giving a top 5 upcoming first pick for a guy that wants to go to Montreal and that Jets won't be able to keep.

That would incredibly dumb to do that because that draft is absolutely top notch. Dubois value is not worth that much. We are talking a second line player and not a player like Seider
Click to expand...
Who said anything about giving up a top 5 pick?
 
Natey said:
What was wrong with Rogers? Do they have online streaming? I watched a bunch on the Sportsnet App.
Click to expand...

Rogers was down that day. So anyone who had Rogers on their TV, Internet or phone had no service that day. It was a country wide system breakdown. And since Rogers owns Fido, anyone who had a phone with Fido was also down.

Thanksfully, I have Bell TV and Internet so I didn't miss out on anything regarding the 2nd day of the draft.

I do have a Fido phone so my cell was useless that day. I actually had to use the house phone to make calls. I had forgotten how to hold a house phone. My hand was cramping from that. :laugh:

MarkovsKnee said:
Top 10 protected only.
Click to expand...

Top-16 protected. :sarcasm:
 
  • Like
Reactions: MarkovsKnee
Milhouse40 said:
This is intriguing

Brisson might be forcing their hands so the Jets elect themselves to go for arbitration.

And this is the big difference if the club decide to move to arbitration because the player refuse to sign his QO which seems to be the case right now, the player ends up deciding the terms for their arbitration, either it's one year or 2 years AND the team can't place the numbers lower than the qualifying offer on the table (In this case it's 6M$) so they are not starting at a good numbers here for negotiations, teams usually lowball their offers in arbitration and it usually ends up near the middle.

If Dubois decide the arbitration is going to be for 2 years.....the team can walk away but compare to when it's the player that elect to go to arbitration, even if the team walks away of a 2 years arbitration case, they are still force to give him that contract for one year and the player is UFA at the end of the season.
Click to expand...

Well at minimum he's getting his Q.O. Not sure what the dates are for club elected arbitration. If Jets don't take him to arbitration, PLD should sign his QO and go back to Jets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Milhouse40
MarkovsKnee said:
Well at minimum he's getting his Q.O. Not sure what the dates are for club elected arbitration. If Jets don't take him to arbitration, PLD should sign his QO and go back to Jets.
Click to expand...

Club Elected Salary Arbitration eligibility (second window):

  • For the 2021-22 off-season, due to the extended season schedule (originally intended for the Olympics), the second window spans Jul 17, 2022 at 5:01pm ET to July 18, 2022 at 5:00pm ET

www.capfriendly.com

Thank You - CapFriendly - NHL Salary Caps

Thank you for the amazing 9 years
www.capfriendly.com www.capfriendly.com
 
  • Like
Reactions: Adam Michaels and Milhouse40
PLD is not coming here, not in the short term anyways.

HuGo is busy figuring out ways to shed salary, making sure the Habs finish last for years. Yesterday's trade was brutal. HuGo's off season moves have been subpar, apart from the Dadonov deal. Moving Romanov and acquiring Dach was a step backwards. I must say tearing apart BargainBin's mess is quite challenging.

The french media is at it again, conspiring and fooling us fans. PLD is a slight upgrade over Drouin. He hasn't exactly moved the needle for the Jets. The Habs are rebuilding, why the heck would Dubois want to join? It makes no sense giving up assets from the Habs' perspective.

I rather see HuGo get creative and rid himself of Price, Drouin, Byron, Armia and Gallagher.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: DailyKaizen, MolleSon, Destopcorner and 2 others
tbcwpg said:
I don't see how it's out of the realm of possibility that Hughes may have tried to get the price lowered a bit. GMs are trying to maximize their value. And from 11 years of experience with Chevy backing out of a deal last minute like this would be the first time he's done it. His MO is having a price and not changing it. It's not unusual to think that Hughes said we're not moving X now why not take Y and Chevy said no we're not doing it.
Click to expand...
Has Gorton been known to go back on deals? If not he wouldn't let Hughes do it either. It is possible Habs backed out of the deal although i don't see it with Dubois in attendance.
 
Boss Man Hughes said:
Has Gorton been known to go back on deals? If not he wouldn't let Hughes do it either. It is possible Habs backed out of the deal although i don't see it with Dubois in attendance.
Click to expand...

I think the more likely explanation is that the Habs needed something for the Dach deal that they'd include in the Dubois deal and Chevy said no, and they couldn't agree on a replacement.

I doubt either GM flat out said "I've changed my mind we're not doing that". Something changed and the deal fell through.
 
BargainBinSpecial said:
PLD is not coming here, not in the short term anyways.
HuGo is busy figuring out ways to shed salary, making sure the Habs finish last for years. Yesterday's trade was brutal. HuGo's off season moves have been subpar, apart from the Dadonov deal. Moving Romanov and acquiring Dach was a step backwards. I must say tearing apart BargainBin's mess is quite challenging.
The french media is at it again, conspiring and fooling us fans. PLD is a slight upgrade over Drouin. He hasn't exactly moved the needle for the Jets. The Habs are rebuilding, why the heck would Dubois want to join? It makes no sense giving up assets from the Habs' perspective.
I rather see HuGo get creative and rid himself of Price, Drouin, Byron, Armia and Gallagher.
Click to expand...
 
HabsWhiteKnightLOL said:
Here what would be my offer for PLD
Dvorak + 2nd 2023 + 2nd 2024 and Byron for cap.
Take or leave it or see you in 2 years Dubois.
Click to expand...
They'd probably hang up right away. I'm willing to wait 2 years also, it's not a big deal. Knowing PLD wants to leave, and wants to specifically go to Montreal really sours his trade value to other teams as he's only seen as a 1-2 year rental at most. So you're essentially paying for 2 years of RFA years for PLD. Clearly, none of the young key players are going to be included as both teams know it's not worth it. Right away, they're going to ask for a few picks, probably 2-3 mid tier(2-3 Rd) picks. Then they'll ask for a centre to replace PLD. Dvorak is the only sensible option. Then they'll probably ask for a mid winger in the vein of a Gallagher, Armia, etc. Habs would want to alleviate cap so I could actually see them giving away Anderson if Armia is also combined. A B-level prospect will probably also be included.

So I can see PLD for:

Dvorak, Anderson, Armia, 2nd, 3rd, B-Prospect
 
Adam Michaels said:
Rogers was down that day. So anyone who had Rogers on their TV, Internet or phone had no service that day. It was a country wide system breakdown. And since Rogers owns Fido, anyone who had a phone with Fido was also down.

Thanksfully, I have Bell TV and Internet so I didn't miss out on anything regarding the 2nd day of the draft.

I do have a Fido phone so my cell was useless that day. I actually had to use the house phone to make calls. I had forgotten how to hold a house phone. My hand was cramping from that. :laugh:



Top-16 protected. :sarcasm:
Click to expand...
Ah I remember that happening but I have nothing through Rogers so I didn't remember which day it happened lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: Adam Michaels
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom