Ja Morant of the NBA's Memphis Grizzlies was just suspended for 25 games for shooting a Tik Tok in his car where he flashed a gun for half a second. No charges. Perfectly legal in Tennesse.
Fwiw he's a superstar/top 10 player/best player on an elite team
Different situation, though. Nobody is saying that a player cannot be suspended for an off-ice/field/court issue without a criminal charge.
But the example you used (and the Irving one as well) was not a suspension based on an allegation which the player denied. It was based on something they did in plain sight, for all to see. There was no ambiguity as to whether they did it or not.
This is quite different. These players are being accused of something that they deny.
A better example would be the allegation that Ja Morant assaulted a teen at a pick-up game. Morant denied that he assaulted him. The NBA didn't suspend him for that incident despite the allegation, which has since become more credible.
A more recent example is Anthony Lamb, who was just accused of a rape in 2019. The allegation is being investigated but is unproven. The NBA hasn't suspended Lamb. The accuser didn't sue Lamb directly, but named him in a civil suit against the University of Vermont for mishandling the reporting of the assault. It's fairly similar to how the HC incident came to light.
The Warriors released this statement:
“Anthony is not a defendant in this recent lawsuit and, to our knowledge, he has never been charged with any wrongdoing in any legal case,” a rep for the Warriors told
the Athletic in a statement. “Prior to signing Anthony in September, we did our due diligence with the NBA and his prior teams, as we do with all players. If any new information comes to light, we will certainly evaluate it and act accordingly.”