I like Gudas. However, I think most people on HFBoards do not. Anyway, he is/was on the third pairing. Why is he so critical now?
The Panthers are in a major one-year cap crunch due to dead cap. The biggest issue all season is that they haven’t been able to handle any injuries. Obviously it’s part of the game and something every team goes through but some, like this year’s Panthers, are not set up to handle it well.
People will say the Panthers were very lucky in rounds 1-3 and that’s true and probably a requirement to win the cup. And while I think people associate that with bounces and saves, the luckiest that they’ve been is that it’s one of a few times they’ve been able to play with a full lineup
Someone gave some specifics above but Gudas, while on the third pairing, is the team’s 3rd most reliable defender on the blue line behind Ekblad and Forsling. Two goals that don’t happen this series if he’s in:
Game 1, goal 1. Gudas is in the locker room so Montour fills in for a rare PK shift where he completely abandons the front of the net allowing an easy centering pass and goal
Game 2, goal 3. Gudas’s replacement, who doesn’t belong on the ice a cup final game, has a complete individual defensive breakdown allowing his man to walk in from the corner un-contested and screening Bob in the process
They’re little things but you don’t have any margin for that in the playoffs
Beyond Gudas, the Luostarainen injury has really killed the 3rd line which was a very important two-way line for the Panthers in rounds 1-3 and takes the only decent player off the 4th line
Vegas’s 5th goal was also a direct result of the forward situation with FLA playing with only 10 and bundling a line change, sending only 4 out due to confusion and another easy goal
And these are just the most direct examples. There’s a lot of other more nuanced issues with how the Panthers played last night which was caused by line mismatches with only 10 forwards and 5 regular D men