When I look at the current roster, and then project that roster out into the future, I see next season (24-25) as a step back, but then the following year (25-26) could be pretty good again with our '06s being 19 years old, and some good OA candidates in Cloutier and Mignosa. Being competitive when our 07s are 18 years old should be the goal, IMO, because our 07s will be expected to take on huge roles on that contender, and there is no guarantee that Martin will be here at 19. If we want to look toward the future, then we should be working backward from that goal.
With regards to next season, I think we have to assume that next year we are trading Gibson regardless of what decision is made this year. We should also have more quality OAs next season than we can roster, and can hopefully turn a few of them into excess picks. With our current picks cupboard plus what we get for Gibson and a couple of 04s, we should be in a good spot with some surplus picks going into the Brady Martin years. That is without having to sell off this season. But that is also without loading up this season.
This could be a season where it makes sense to stand pat at the deadline. Give this group a chance to make some post season noise, get our young players some experience of at least 2 rounds of postseason play, and not have to take a huge step back next season as they continue to build for a possible 2 year window when Brady is 18/19.