SA16
Sixstring
Going to take a guess and say the sticking point for the Rangers isn't money but term. Wouldn't be at all surprised to hear that the Rangers and Islanders had very similar money on the table, perhaps the Rangers with even a slightly higher AAV, but the Rangers weren't willing to go more than 5 years.
I highly doubt any team ever involved with him was offering less than 7 years. That would be a complete deal breaker almost immediately.