Player Discussion Rasmus Dahlin Part 4 - D (1st Overall, 2018, Frölunda HC, SHL)
- Thread starter Orange Fanta
- Start date
TheMistyStranger
ミスト
- May 21, 2005
- 31,558
- 7,398
GOALOFSSON
Game Changer
Jim Bob
RIP RJ
Left - Rasmus Dahlin Alpha LX Pro 75 Flex Stick
ProStockHockey.com is your online source for the best ice hockey equipment. Click here to shop the world’s largest selection of pro stock hockey gear.
www.prostockhockey.com
I would ask for this for my birthday if it were a P28 curve and not a P92/P29/W03/E3/W90. Although, it does seem like a custom curve.
tsujimoto74
Moderator
- May 28, 2012
- 30,599
- 23,356
Probably should've been a Norris finalist. Feels like the voters are punishing him for some combination of being on team that missed the playoffs and having not won the award before this season.
Last edited:
Old Navy Goat
Registered User
zenthusiast
cybersabre his prophet
- Oct 20, 2009
- 19,127
- 6,651
Makar got the gas off of last season. Among the best in the league but not the McDavid at D he was made to be
BowieSabresFan
Registered User
- Nov 18, 2010
- 4,405
- 1,730
NHL awards are often reputation based. This is just the latest.
Jim Bob
RIP RJ
WhereAreTheCookies
Registered User
The only reason I can see would be voters didn't want 2 of the top 3 not being in the playoffs. Even then someone like Heiskanen or Hamilton were more deserving than Makar.
debaser66
Registered User
- Mar 10, 2012
- 5,106
- 2,826
game management, award management
not even the ice is transparent
not even the ice is transparent
Bendium
Registered User
- Oct 18, 2019
- 1,907
- 1,489
The James Norris Memorial Trophy is an annual award given "to the defense player who demonstrates throughout the season the greatest all-round ability in the position." The winner is selected in a poll of the Professional Hockey Writers Association at the end of the regular season.
I don't like how the Norris has evolved into a points competition. Having the most points doesn't make you the best all-round defenseman. Karlsson ran away with points, but was a -26 and doesn't play on the penalty kill! How can a defenseman be the Norris and NOT be on the top PK unit?
Makar and Fox are both PK1 leaders and have solid positive +/- numbers. Dahlin has improved, but is behind those guys defensively still. He's not even on the top PK unit.
Honestly, to me Fox is the better definition of the Norris than Karlsson or Makar.
I don't like how the Norris has evolved into a points competition. Having the most points doesn't make you the best all-round defenseman. Karlsson ran away with points, but was a -26 and doesn't play on the penalty kill! How can a defenseman be the Norris and NOT be on the top PK unit?
Makar and Fox are both PK1 leaders and have solid positive +/- numbers. Dahlin has improved, but is behind those guys defensively still. He's not even on the top PK unit.
Honestly, to me Fox is the better definition of the Norris than Karlsson or Makar.
Fjordy
Registered User
- Jun 20, 2018
- 17,008
- 9,344
It's very debatable, Dahlin had a good season and he definitely improved in defense, these are the facts.
Using Hockey Viz’s Model Fox and Karlsson were better at driving offense
Dahlin was better than Makar on offense.
Dahlin had better defensive metrics than all of them.
Same with Evolving Hockey.
debaser66
Registered User
- Mar 10, 2012
- 5,106
- 2,826
where is the statistical proof for your statement, beyond +/-, even there dahlin is just plus 12 while Makar is 16; also Makar has played 12 games less.
A nomination of Makar over Dahlin makes no sense, other than past reputation.
Butt Ox
Registered User
The brilliant start to the season - establishing a new record - was long forgotten unfortunately. Can you imagine what could have been if Ras wasn't fed minutes until he was dead down the stretch.
Bendium
Registered User
- Oct 18, 2019
- 1,907
- 1,489
You made my post about Dahlin...not me. I made it about the Norris itself. I made my case why I do not think Karlsson should be such a shoo-in because he is not relied on by his team defensively. That case does also diminish Dahlin's claim in that Dahlin is not on the top PK unit.
No, I do not think Dahlin was in the top three all-around defenseman in hockey. He has some growth still to do on the defensive side of his game before he gets there. I think there are likely a few other better "all-around" defenseman out there who could argue they were snubbed as well.
Fjordy
Registered User
- Jun 20, 2018
- 17,008
- 9,344
Dude what are you talking about? If Dahlin had better defensive metrics than EK 65, Makar and Fox.
MOGlLNY
Registered User
- Jan 5, 2008
- 12,324
- 12,595
“You made my post about Dahlin, not me!” He yells in the Rasmus Dahlin thread
Bendium
Registered User
- Oct 18, 2019
- 1,907
- 1,489
You guys are always looking to pick fights and put other posters down. Makes it pretty hard to have legit conversations. I used to enjoy some of the discussions on this board, but its gotten to where if you say anything even remotely negative about any of the fanboy favorites, you just get ganked.
Yes it is a Dahlin thread. The discussion was about him not being top 3 in voting. I made a comment about how I didn't like the way Norris had become a points total race instead of best all around defenseman race. Thats a legit segway off that conversation.
Yes it is a Dahlin thread. The discussion was about him not being top 3 in voting. I made a comment about how I didn't like the way Norris had become a points total race instead of best all around defenseman race. Thats a legit segway off that conversation.
