BobMarleyNYR
Rangers future on D
See boys my source was right. Can I please get credit for this?
So through your boy's source you actually signed Stempniak to the Rangers... Maloney, is that you?
See boys my source was right. Can I please get credit for this?
See boys my source was right. Can I please get credit for this?
Boyle = Stralman (they both have very good qualities lets not start offense vs defense)
Stempniak > Pouliot though not by much IMO
Lombardi > Boyle just because of his speed alone.
Then there's tanner glass....
A nice replacement for richards would be icing on the cake.
In what world is Stempniak a 4th line winger...the guy averages over 40 points a year. He is closer to a 1st line winger than a 4th line winger. In reality he is more of a 2nd/3rd line tweener closer to the 2nd though.
Absolutely no one cares.
Miller is not centering our 2nd line. He is the 3rd line center (IF he makes the team)
MSL is not going to be on our 3rd line.
Brassard is not centering our 3rd line.
The top two lines will be centered by Stepan and Brassard, with Nash, Kreider, Zuccarello, and St. Louis on the wings. Those are our 6 best forwards, and thus they should be on the top two lines if the positions make sense (which they do, since both Nash and Zuccarello are effective at LW as well as RW).
The third line is Hagelin with Miller/Lindberg/Lombardi and Stempniak.
The lineup will look something like this:
Kreider Stepan St. Louis
Nash Brassard Zuccarello
Hagelin Miller Stempniak
Glass Moore Lombardi
Kreider has worked well with Stepan, and St. Louis has worked well with Stepan.
Nash takes Pouliot's spot. Similar body-type, better overall skill and better overall player.
Hagelin is the perfect 3rd line LW. J.T. Miller seems to be the front-runner to win the 3C spot, as of right now. Stempniak fills out that line.
Top-6 players in the Top-6.
Third line players on the third line.
Everyone where they should be.
Please stop posting lineups with Miller centering St. Louis as our 2nd line, or a third line with Brassard and Zuccarello.
Kreider - Stepan - St. Louis
Nash - Brassard - Zuccarello
Hagelin - [Miller/Lindberg] - [Stempniak/Kristo/Haggerty]
Glass - Moore - [Lombardi/Fast/Mueller]
McDonagh Girardi
Staal Boyle
Moore Klein
Allen
McIlrath
Kostka
Lundqvist
Talbot
or
Nash Stepan St. Louis
Kreider Brassard Zuccarello
or
Kreider Stepan Zuccarello
Nash Brassard St. Louis
either way, Miller is not in the top-6, and he's not centering MSL or Nash. Miller (if he makes the team at all) will be centering Carl Hagelin and Lee Stempniak / Ryan Haggerty / Danny Kristo on the third line. This isn't rocket science. The guy is an unproven commodity at the NHL level. You don't expect him to fill a second line center role and produce that level of production. Come ON.
Good signing. Not a player that's had much success on winning teams, but a good signing to strengthen the line up. Essentially signing him and Lombo forces kids to push their way into the line up, which is a good thing.
I think that Nash goes back to LW, and since Pouliot worked well with his skill set with Zucc and Brass, putting Nash on that line makes it a legit top 6 line even though Brass has never sustained a top 6 level of play outside of his hot streaks, especially with a guy that's a lock for 30-30 and a 40 assist winger who has a top tier sniper on the other side to feed pucks.
Think MSL works well as a better wheel house passer to guys driving the net with speed (Kreider) and a RH shot (Stepan).
The bottom six just got juiced up by servicable players in case the kids are not productive. If the kids are, and more than one of them can push for spots, then the Rangers can recoup picks by trading a guy like Stempniak at the deadline.
Kreider-Step-MSL
Nash-Brass-Zucc
Hags-Miller-Fast
Lombo-Moore-Stempniak
Glass/Mueller can push for spots on the 4th line if kids aren't ready, and have Stempniak and Lombo play up the line up. I'm liking the versality in the forward group, its not ideal in terms of the quality of players, but hopefully the roles can get filled accordingly.
could we even afford carcillo?
if we wanted someone who can just skate and fight, why didn't we just keep him over glass?.. so annoying.
FWIW I don't think Stempniak is necessarily better than Pouliot. More consistent, probably. Pouliotn has tremendous skill, and when it's on, like it was the second half of last season, he's very good. I know people say silly things about how it was his linemates, but that's not really true.
Pouliot off his game is like all of you swear Glass is ('cause we've all followed Tanner Glass throughout his career), only it's like 70% of the time. Where apparently Stempniak is very average 100% of the time. Tough call, for me, anyway. But I hope Stempniak plays well.
Absolutely no one cares.
is John Moore that important to keep? for instance. could we sign Carcillo if we were to use allen as the 6th D paired with Klein if we were to save like 300K? or do we see some potential in Moore? He can skate, but I haven't seen much else from him.
Does AV have a thing with college grads? Seems like all new signings have NCAA background. Maybe that's what it takes to figure out his system? (And why he's sceptical of JTM?)