Confirmed with Link: Rangers Sign Brendan Smith (4 years x $4.35M)

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Even without Shattenkirk, Smith is not a lock for 2nd pair minutes. I'm not into paying third pair defenders upwards of 4 million per and giving out NTCs like candy.
 
I wasn't for signing him, and I don't believe in signing players to whatever amount it takes to sign them. That's how we got stuck with Staal and Girardi and Redden.

All of whom received contracts that were longer and more expensive/year than what Smith got. To put this deal alongside those is silly.
 
Even without Shattenkirk, Smith is not a lock for 2nd pair minutes. I'm not into paying third pair defenders upwards of 4 million per and giving out NTCs like candy.

What? Who's going to play over him? Holden and DeAngelo? Not likely
 
All of whom received contracts that were longer and more expensive/year than what Smith got. To put this deal alongside those is silly.

So unless a contract is for a certain $ amount or a certain term, it can't possibly be excessive? THATS silly.
 
Even without Shattenkirk, Smith is not a lock for 2nd pair minutes. I'm not into paying third pair defenders upwards of 4 million per and giving out NTCs like candy.

Smith is certainly a lock to play top 4 minutes. Who would play above him?
 
What? Who's going to play over him? Holden and DeAngelo? Not likely

If Holden is still in the lineup (which means one of Bereglazov/DeAngelo are in the press box or another league), I could see AV giving Staal-Holden 2nd pairing minutes again.
 
Yup. People get upset over everything.

Yup.

Lias Andersson!? This is the end of the world - worse than McIlrath!

Chytil instead of whatever pet prospect I had? This is every worse than Lias! We'll never compete again!

Ruff as an assistant coach!? Just disband the franchise already!

It's so tiring. Every little thing is the worst move in the world to half this board.
 
My only issue now is investing all this money in Smith while still employing a coach who loses him on the bench
 
Would have liked him at 4 mill but more important was the years to me. Im willing to pay the extra 300k as long as its not a 5 year deal.
 
Yup.

Lias Andersson!? This is the end of the world - worse than McIlrath!

Chytil instead of whatever pet prospect I had? This is every worse than Lias! We'll never compete again!

Ruff as an assistant coach!? Just disband the franchise already!

It's so tiring. Every little thing is the worst move in the world to half this board.
It does get brutal in here sometimes.
 
solid deal and welcome back brendan smith.

4 yrs is perfect. kids got alot of hockey left in him and he gives us something we need. loved him in the playoffs, love his attitude and like that he plays with a little anger and edge. fair deal all around.

so now we can do this

27/42
76/bereglazov
18/77

no more girardi
no more holden
no more kk

god that sounds good.

me thinks the kevin shattenkirk thing just got a little less likely but who knows. he would still look nice here
 
Yup.

Lias Andersson!? This is the end of the world - worse than McIlrath!

Chytil instead of whatever pet prospect I had? This is every worse than Lias! We'll never compete again!

Ruff as an assistant coach!? Just disband the franchise already!

It's so tiring. Every little thing is the worst move in the world to half this board.

We have a very large userbase, which is a great thing. Every move is going to have a small subset of users become a large vocal majority.

Filter out the noise, respond in kind to people who deserve responses, or don't respond. Basically the only way to navigate this place.
 
Even without Shattenkirk, Smith is not a lock for 2nd pair minutes. I'm not into paying third pair defenders upwards of 4 million per and giving out NTCs like candy.
Do you think the management would offered him this contract and view him as bottom 6? If they don't, why do you? They obviously liked what the saw with the Skjei-Smith pairing which was a solid top 4 combo.
 
Holden played more than Smith in 6 of 12 playoff games.

Yes and even if Holden is played with McDonagh, that still leaves Smith getting 2nd pairing minutes.

Unless we think DeAngelo is going to get those minutes instead'

You all do remember that Girardi is gone, right?
 
Even without Shattenkirk, Smith is not a lock for 2nd pair minutes. I'm not into paying third pair defenders upwards of 4 million per and giving out NTCs like candy.

thats only cause AV is an idiot...Skjei-Smith should be locked in as the 2nd pair
 
Yes and even if Holden is played with McDonagh, that still leaves Smith getting 2nd pairing minutes.

Unless we think DeAngelo is going to get those minutes instead
Sorry, I don't know what the word and means apparently.
 
We have a very large userbase, which is a great thing. Every move is going to have a small subset of users become a large vocal majority.

Filter out the noise, respond in kind to people who deserve responses, or don't respond. Basically the only way to navigate this place.

True. I'm hesitant to filter anybody out all together because even the people who grind my gears the most sometimes have points that I'm happy I read and thought about.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad