Did it? Because they added more vets, and then brought in a hard ass coach, by April 2012. The day before hiring Sutter, they were 11th in the West, and 20th overall. 30th in GF. A -9 differential. 11 RW to 14 RL. 23rd on the PP.
From the day Sutter was hired to the day before Carter got here, they were 10th in the West, and 15th overall. 29th in GF. 22nd on the PP. A +6 differential though.
Can you imagine if Carter didn't cry his way out of Columbus? Because there was not another Carter traded at that deadline.
We write these grand narratives. Prior to a certain time, and after a certain time. Of course the benefit on hindsight is always there. This or that move is the right one at the right time. DL's master plan getting Richards. Then they're 9th in the conference and 17th overall on Feb 22nd, with more regulation losses than regulation wins. I highly doubt that was the plan. Carter was not part of the plan. Sutter wasn't part of the plan. Both of those moves were made in total desperation, when the grand plan was falling apart. Had Gagne remained healthy, let alone had he and Penner been able to score, I doubt that trade gets made.
We have these ideas on how a rebuild should go. Who should play. When they should play. How much they should play. Who shouldn't play. Exactly when to call a guy up. Where they should slot where they'll maxmize their play and production.
They totally missed on Hickey, lucked out that Muzzin was as good as he was, lucked out that Carter was available for far less than what Columbus paid for him, and then lucked out that DL's good ole Canadian farm boy buddy was sitting on his ranch when he needed him. None of that is a plan. That's well I guess we'll try this and try that. Oh, that didn't work? Ok, then I guess we'll try this over here. Hey, maybe this other thing will work.