It was alluded to at the time that the Flyers had Gauthier 3rd. And that some teams did not have Cooley as the highest ranked NTDP player. With how giddy the Flyers were about telegraphing this pick, it’s not exactly a conspiracy theory.
Also, this is as ridiculous a comment as, “They signed Hayes over doing nothing.” I’m glad you chose 2 random slightly disappointing picks — that none of us wanted — and paint them as the only alternative. It’s already a dishonest argument. As far as I’m aware, any player is available. We were screaming for a trade down. I could throw it back at you that they could’ve taken Ostlund + Hutson — right move still? I already know your response: maybe they couldn’t trade down. They weren’t going to, so who knows? You don’t and don’t say you do.
As I said elsewhere, Gauthier is having the best year possible to make me believe he is on track for what I believed him to be. That’s not a bad thing at all. But please do parse that statement out.