"Thinking processes. Brain stuff. Stuff that needs to happen so fast it's instinct."
yeah.....it comes NATURALLY.....a player either has it or doesn't
period
.....now YOU'VE learned sumpin'
That simply isn't true. Nail Yakupov was one of the most talented players his draft year and he stank when he got to the NHL. A big reason for that was development. Edmonton had no plan in place on how to bring Yakupov along. You can also make a case for Nolan Patrick here as well.
Development is more than just systems and playing the game. EVERYONE knows how to play the game. The problem is how coaches process the game.
Some coaches don't want defensemen to lead rushes or carry the puck out of the defensive zone. So, if you've got a defenseman that leads rushes and carries the puck out of the defensive zone regularly, coaching that aspect out of their game can have a significant effect on how they process what to do with the puck.
Normally the instinct for these type of defenders is to take off with the puck and skate it up ice. But, because you're told not to do that or your ice time gets cut, then there's just that slight delay to not race the puck up ice. That's just enough time for a forechecker to be on the defenseman and you've got a turnover.
Now, picture that this is your development path for years, then an interim coach comes in and says 'rely on your instinct and go with your gut.' Now, you've been developed a certain way, your instincts are no longer sharp and now you're being asked to rely on those again. So, there's another adjustment period. But wait, it gets better. After you've adjusted and things are looking good, you've now got a new head coach who says he's going to be hands off and he's going to leave things to his assistant and the assistant says "you can carry the puck, but you can't lead a rush. As well, once you get to the blueline, you have to dump the puck in and get back on defense, but if there's any opportunity to take a chance to create offense, do so, but don't create a turnover." Now you've got a real mess.
And finally, a new head coach comes in and says we're going to do things different and now you have to be aggressive, but defensively responsible.
And this is how a franchise muddies up the development aspect and wastes prospects.
Look at how Provorov has become a shell of himself. Rather than come up with a proper development path for Provorov, they just shoved him like a square peg into a round hole and now he can't even think the game anymore because his thinking is now just get rid of the puck and the skills that he used to be blessed with (carrying the puck out of the zone, puck handling and skating with the puck) are no longer prevalent in his game. That's pretty much been coached out of him.
You can also say the same for Sanheim. A guy who is blessed with terrific wheels and could handle the puck is now so uptight about making a mistake that he just gets rid of it as soon as he gets it. Once again, those God given skills and abilities he was born with are being coached right out of him because 'system' and 'playing the game the right way' cliche.
Here's another of looking at it. You have an offensive defenseman capable of scoring 60 to 70 points a year. Are you as a coach asking him to become a shutdown defensive defenseman? No, because you know that he brings a specific skill set to the offensive side of the game and to not use them in that role is a waste of an asset. It's the same thing with asking a shutdown defensive defenseman to all of a sudden quarterback the power play. It doesn't utilize their skill set and it's a waste of an asset. And that is Flyers development in a nutshell.