Sentinel
Registered User
Yes we do. Professional hockey is professional hockey.No we don’t
Yes we do. Professional hockey is professional hockey.No we don’t
Meh, it's called NHL goals for a reason. Now there can be a separate stat for professional goals.Yes we do. Professional hockey is professional hockey.
And there should be. Taking out 7 years of Howe's goalscoring removes the context.Meh, it's called NHL goals for a reason. Now there can be a separate stat for professional goals.
And there should be. Taking out 7 years of Howe's goalscoring removes the context.
Wow! Looks like we are finally going to see the day when you admit that Ovechkin will pass Gretzky in goals. And even toying with the idea that Ovechkin might play a full season of hockey after breaking the record. I tried telling you back in 2013 that this would happen, but you didn't listen! You didn't listen!So at this point, what sort of pace do you think he is on? Are we looking at late in the 2025 season here? Or what is likely to be his final NHL season in 2025-'26? If he doesn't get injured, and his play doesn't drop significantly I could see late 2025 season. These are "ifs" at the moment of course. He's off his normal pace with 5 goals in 11 games. That's a pace of about 37 goals or so. Not great for him. Also, Ovie is back to that weird plus/minus stat again this year, being at -8 already.
Meh, he's been on the ice for several ENGs against. Lavi is pretty aggressive pulling the goalie early, and the Caps haven't been successful in that scenario this year, so that's been a big drag on Ovie's +/-.Also, Ovie is back to that weird plus/minus stat again this year, being at -8 already.
WHA and KHL were not some minor leagues. In WHA Howe and Gretzky played against Bobby Hull and in KHL Ovechkin played against Jagr. Just because NHL refuses to acknowledge competition, the hockey would should do the same.Points – AHL Hall of Fame
ahlhalloffame.com
Where do these players rank all time?
Your last comment was "professional hockey is professional hockey"WHA and KHL were not some minor leagues. In WHA Howe and Gretzky played against Bobby Hull and in KHL Ovechkin played against Jagr. Just because NHL refuses to acknowledge competition, the hockey would should do the same.
There is a reason Gretzky did not retire until beating Howe's total number of goals (NHL + WHA) by just one goal.
Peak Datsyuk, Federov and Bure being way overrated here. They all have less than a handful of peak seasons on par with 2007-10 OV, yet people speak of them like they played long careers at that level. Especially Datsyuk and Bure. Agree with Malkin though.For prime or better peak performance/talent for one game or a short period of time I would take maybe 4 Russians alone from the last 20/30 years over Ovechkin. Clearly I take peak Fedorov over peak Ovi. I would also take peak Malkin over peak Ovi. Maybe even peak Datsyuk and peak Bure (but both debatable in my eyes). IMO Ovi is not close to the most talented players ever. But he clearly has one of the absolute top individual careers ever. In my eyes with his goal scoring dominance as I said a light Big 4 and the deserved fifth place in the all time ranking.
Bure lead NHL in goals 3 times (and once in playoffs) and has 5 50+ goals season and he missed a lot with injuries.Peak Datsyuk, Federov and Bure being way overrated here. They all have less than a handful of peak seasons on par with 2007-10 OV, yet people speak of them like they played long careers at that level. Especially Datsyuk and Bure. Agree with Malkin though.
OV scored 1 goal in his next game and pace is 41 goals now, early in a season pace projections are meaningless (see McDavid). Agree that OV is slightly off, overall Caps have lots of issues as a team, top 6 is decimated and Kuzy yet to score a goal.He's off his normal pace with 5 goals in 11 games. That's a pace of about 37 goals or so. Not great for him.
Ovie being 'off' well scoring at a 0.5 goals per game pace at age 37 is something...OV scored 1 goal in his next game and pace is 41 goals now, early in a season pace projections are meaningless (see McDavid). Agree that OV is slightly off, overall Caps have lots of issues as a team, top 6 is decimated and Kuzy yet to score a goal.
The amusing thing is when people try to use the Ovy arc to project how younger players will likely score. Forgetting all the while that Ovy is an outlier and no where near the norm.Ovie being 'off' well scoring at a 0.5 goals per game pace at age 37 is something...
Professional hockey is professional hockey. The goalpost is right where I left it.Your last comment was "professional hockey is professional hockey"
My god you move the goalpost quickly.
That pales in comparison to OV, and rating Bure over OV is rating him too high IMO.Bure lead NHL in goals 3 times (and once in playoffs) and has 5 50+ goals season and he missed a lot with injuries.
He is rated fine IMO.
Wow! Looks like we are finally going to see the day when you admit that Ovechkin will pass Gretzky in goals. And even toying with the idea that Ovechkin might play a full season of hockey after breaking the record. I tried telling you back in 2013 that this would happen, but you didn't listen! You didn't listen!
Meh, he's been on the ice for several ENGs against. Lavi is pretty aggressive pulling the goalie early, and the Caps haven't been successful in that scenario this year, so that's been a big drag on Ovie's +/-.
His defensive play hasn't changed this year, and the Caps have been excellent defensively at even strength over the past several games, with or without Ovie on the ice.
Did you see Ovechkin tie Gordie Howe for most goals scored with the same team in detroit last night?! In Detroit of all places! It's like even the hockey gods wants Ovechkin to succeed at this point! You can't make this stuff up. 20 years from now you'll be making threads about it on the history boards!No one knows if it will happen yet. We are about three years away from it potentially happening. Plenty that can happen in between.
I agree, I was just saying Bure is not "overrated" on these boardsThat pales in comparison to OV, and rating Bure over OV is rating him too high IMO.
The suspensions in the 2009-10 season forced him to change his playing style and to tone down the aggressiveness.
I think he was still capable of murdering guys in open ice (see hit on Nosek or Drouin), but he can’t overdo it without getting unwanted attention from the DOPS
You can argue 5 ross > 9 rockets and that's fine. But 5 rosses has been done by 4 other players, soon to be 5 after McDavid. No one else has 9 Rockets or even 8. But at least OV has a ross, Jagr has 0 rockets. Also 3 harts > 1 hart, 1 Smythe > 0 Smythe, 1 Calder > 0. Too many zeros for Jagr.
International lol. Yeah, random 5 game tournaments in the middle or after the NHL season prove more than what actually happens over a full season. Peak OV tore peak Malkin apart in pts, PPG, goals, GPG, hart votes, lindsay votes. But yeah you can hold on to international play.
Fedorov had 1 season that might rival OV's 3rd or 4th best season. But he never played at that level again so it was just a fluke. Most overrated player in history. Bure was a poor mans OV. Adjusted for era he was worse offensively and didn't have OV's physicality either. Datsyuk was never close to the best player in the world, voted by media and players. I'll trust them over you. Malkin's 11/12 was great but OV's 07/08 was better. OV's 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th best seasons were all better than Malkin's.
Points – AHL Hall of Fame
ahlhalloffame.com
Where do these players rank all time?