Except, if we start 9-0 again next year, like we unexpectedly did this year?
Returning a lot of players from a good team cannot be under-estimated IMO
I don’t understand this concept of “unexpected.” Sure, we maybe didn’t expect the team to be at the top of the Conference without any additions but there were five teams that were all packed together as contenders. Ottawa was one of them.
We could see last year what the returning foundation was going to look Like. We knew we had defence and goaltending. We knew we had depth on the wings.
I figured we’d need to add a centre to augment Tolnai and Rohrer. See what we are at the deadline. Our competition was pretty weak so we managed to make a go of it with hard work and brilliant execution. Perfect.
Saginaw just sold Mintyukov while in 3rd place. They valued next year for a couple reasons. There is nothing wrong with good strategy.
We return a weak team again down the middle and no true anchor on defence.
We will be good next year but not great. Even if we were leading the division again, we’d still need to add significant pieces at the deadline. Probably a #1 D-Man and a quality centre. There goes whomever we pick in the first round in 2023 plus the remainder of our picks through 2027 in a deal for the D-Man. Remember, our 2023 1st will be the 21st pick. Not as high valued as Martone this year. Then we are looking at dealing someone like Marrelli to get the centre because we can’t package a weaker player plus picks because, well, we don’t have any.
Then the following season when Mews, Marrelli (traded), Kelly, Barlas, Pinelli, Foster, Gardiner, Dever, Ewles, and Horner are 18 and 19 years old, we have nothing to augment that team and we are forced to sell because we have nothing to use to buy. Remember, if we keep the core intact next year and only trade strategically (Rohrer, Sirman, Gerrior and Smyth) we recoup some picks and return Mackenzie, Mayich and Stonehouse as OAs to go with our current crop of 16 and 17 year olds.
Possible core for 24-25
Barlas-Gardiner-Kelly
Pinelli-Foster-Stonehouse(OA)
Dever
Marrelli-Mews
Mayich(OA)-Ewles
Horner
MacKenzie (OA)
We have two consecutive Import picks that add to that roster plus all the picks from the 2023 draft that will be 17 that season. That doesn’t include the picks from the 2024 draft that we’d start recouping next season.
We’d have our full compliment of picks in the 2027 and 2028 draft to arm ourselves with plus whatever else we trade for next season.
To me, that is a much smarter strategy. But, we could trade a bunch of stuff away next year, cripple the team above doing it and waste Mews as an 18 year old when he’s likely a stud.