deadhead
Registered User
- Feb 26, 2014
- 49,812
- 21,836
I dunno. York walks right in and looks solid after a couple months in the AHL - raised the game of every defensive partner he played with. Torts is pushing him to be more aggressive on offense and not play it safe. Zamula was a much better player at the end of the season than the beginning, Ginning improved.Development and injuries has played a huge role in the defenseman stagnating. Sanheim, Provorov and Gostisbehere at one point so had exceptional puck handling skills and could lead rushes. Look at them now and fumble the puck like it's a grenade and they no longer lead rushes. They get the puck off their sticks as quick as possible. That's a coaching issue. Those skills have been coached right out of their games.
Hagg was also a decent puck handler back in Sweden and the first thing the Flyers coaches do is get him to abandon that and just play a physical game instead. Myers had ability, but as what the Predators said when they got him, all the fundamentals in his game was completely wrong. When Nashville and Tampa Bay give up on someone, you know that things are bad. Once again, rather than coach the fundamentals and let Myers natural ability shine, the Flyers coaches that out of him.
As for Morin, the injury big did him in. It's a shame, but such is the case sometimes.
It'll be interesting to see what the development plan will be going forward, but I'm certainly not convinced that Laperriere is the guy to do that. It's going to be more of the same "check, check, check" and "defense, defense, defense" mentality that seems to plague this club. Any sort of forward thinking in terms of development seems to be out the window.
Sanheim had three solid seasons, then signs a big contract and loses it, I think that was more the "Castellanos" effect, some players weird out after signing for big money, thinking they have to justify it and start pressing. Won't surprise me if he rebounds next season. But people overestimate him, great skater with the puck in transition, but mediocre once he gets to the O-zone, lacks the vision and agility to be an elite offensive defenseman.
Ghost was about the injuries, coming out of college he was exceptional, then the ACL sapped some of his explosiveness, then the groin, finally both knees being scoped suggests cartilage issues. He's never going to be the 2017-18 Ghost again, much less Mt Union Ghost. Still effective in a sheltered role.
Provorov is definitely a case of overestimation, he's a solid #2 paired with a #1 RHD. When he plays within himself he's a fine minutes eater, when he tries to do too much his limitations are exposed. He can skate with the puck, but not nearly as good as Sanheim, he can defend but is not elite there either, he has a good shot but nothing exceptional. Don't think that's about development, but the refusal to accept that he just wasn't as good as they thought he was.
Hagg isn't a good enough skater to be offense first in the NHL, problem was he never adjusted mentally to a defense first role, we're seeing the same issue with Risto, Shaw is working on his defense b/c if he can master the nuances of defense, he has enough skill not to be a cipher on offense.
A lot of defensemen put up good offensive numbers at lower levels, some due to the level of competition, some due to usage.
Attard was a productive rover in college, but that doesn't fly in the NHL, he's not fast enough to get away with that at the next level. But if he can learn to be a decent defensive defenseman, using his size and positioning, he can be a weapon on offense paired with a puck carrying partner.