thewave
Registered User
- Jun 17, 2011
- 42,303
- 12,752
Dubas ruined the best chance this franchise had had in eons for the shot at the cup.
Its a catch22 situation but "difficult decisions" unfortunately have to be made.
You can't trade Marner b/c he has full nmc/ntc
You can't trade Tavares b/c he has full nmc/ntc
You can't trade Matthews b/c he has full nmc/ntc (now and moving forward)
Your option is:
1) Trade Nylander and restructure cap a bit; when Tavares is off the cap then worry about that when the time comes. Meanwhile; don't mortgate future for playoff runs until Tavares is off the cap
OR
2) Re-sign Nylander for 9 to 10 AAV; deal with the cap crunch until Tavares if off; then after having paid Marner you have about 5M in savings that can be re-allocated. The bet you would be making is that after Tavares is off the cap the three guys (Matthews, Marner, Nylander) who would be making lion's share of the cap would drag this team forward in the playoffs.
Given last 7 years of how the so called "core-4" performs in the playoffs; whats the reasonable bet you are willing to make? In there lies my suggestion.
My suggestion is now that Marner cannot be traded (I wanted him traded to re-up Nylander at a lower AAV and then reallocate cap); and Matthews ahs re-signed for 13.25 AAV (highest AAV in the league until McJesus is probably up for renewal or Drai); and given the last 7 years of their performance in the post season; you unfortunately have to trade Nylander to restucture cap and roster. It sucks but thats the reality of the situation.
Unless one has firm conviction in option 2 (I don't); I am not sure what signing Nylander at a high AAV would accomplish when it comes to team results in the post season.
The only parade there will be is the pretty parade of names that the kids love. Dubas and Shanahan really did a number on us. Maybe Treliving can do something though, he seems good so far except for the Keefe thing. No hope or expectations sadly.