Why, these guys are the experts and we are just fans!
Seriously though, this new approach of us, where we got a guy at the top of the crease that often only function as another option for the puck carrier is a pretty new set-up (new for me probably means 5 years old), and its working really well. After seeing it enough here to figure it out, it instantly becomes obvious that its how Philly have played for a several years. I always had hard time figuring out why Philly could have such good PP despite having too many lefty's on the ice.
I would say that most teams in the league plays the PP as we did the previous years. But we couldn't execute it because we didn't have good enough righties, and then Nash and Gabby wasn't good enough to handle the puck as one of the lefties next to BR. When a PK put pressure on us, we just couldn't throw the puck around on a string like you gotta be able to do if you are going to play keep away on the out side.
Now we are getting a player into that role mentioned above -- inside the box -- and that puts down the PK box and get us set-up.
Also, we are talking a lot about roster moves right now. We should also notice that Brad Richards and Derric Brassard both are essential to our top PP unit. We shouldn't underestimate Poo's play lately, its been good for sure, but he can be replaced easily. The production can vary, but the function of the PP won't be hurt if you stick anyone from Nash to Boyle into his role.
But the "midfield" of;
--------Poo--------------
Zucc-Brassard----------
-----------------
Richards
------McD---------------;
can't be overrated. I mean, what Brassard contributes really much with in that role is those top notch passes. Cross-zone crisp passes. One pass like that gets you set-up and the PK box passive. You cannot replace Brassard on that unit with you know Stepan or Callahan or someone like that.