I will be honest I think he is a goof but I don't get to hear him night after night.
Honest question to Bruins fans, is he really this bad or is it only the odd screw up that ends up on here?
DIsclaimer - I'm a Bruins fan who hates Edwards and his silly shtick. But I'll try to be impartial. He used to call a good PBP. He knew the names and background. His homerism is wayyyyy overblown, it really only shows up in scrums or fights. In reality, he's always complimenting the other team, and in the case of Crosby, or every Tampa player not named Maroon, he absolutely fawns over them.
Now the bad. He barely does PBP any more. Instead, he goes off on tangents about some slight to the hockey gods that nobody else cares about. He tells bizarre stories, like the aforementioned pinning down his sister, or the one about his teachers back in Jr. High that rambled on and went nowhere.
He's in love with obscure hockey terms nobody else uses - "penalty bench", "leg save". He uses far too many syllables trying to be erudite or cute; truculence, ten bell donnybrook, tumbling muffin. He uses redundant phrases; "tight radius turn", "protective netting". And he has a strange notion that hockey is played with kitchen utensils; "ladles it ahead", "spoons it forward", "can't put a fork in it".
He's also visibly slowing down, slurring his words, and finds it tough to string together sentences. And even with this hampering him, he still steps all over Brickley, and barely lets him talk. Oh and most of his shtick he writes beforehand and stores it in his app. It is obviously canned material. I guarantee he had that Maroon diatribe all planned out and was just looking for a place to shoehorn it in (if you can call 40 seconds of yammering nonsense "shoehorning").