Proposal: McDavid to NYR

[Moose and Squirrel]

he’s a top 3 asset in the NHL and most probably the #1-2 best defensemen in the NHL for the next ten years. if mcdavid were to go to colorado for makar colorado would probably only have to add newhook to it and the value would be fair.

McDavid, Drai, Hedman, Fox, Crosby, Kuch, Vas, Mac.. I don't see Makar better than these players, so I'd disagree that he's a top 3 asset in the league

 

[Zerotonine]

Nyr
ConnorMcDavid

Edm
Madison square garden, packed, and with an builders instruction manual, shipped free to edmonton.

Oilers value already worth over a Billion dollars I think they are doing just fine.....

 

[Zerotonine]

Oilers already traded away the best player in the game once upon a time, no way a franchise survives doing it twice......

 

[Calad]

I disagree depending on what the Oilers would want via the draft capital. Rangers have enough prospects they can afford to loose some.

Mcdavid> Zibby + Fox.
Loosing Fox would sting like hell but would be needed.

Laf for all we know could stay the same. If he doesnt improve its not a big loss when you get Mcdavid back

Unsure what prospects or draft capital Oilers would want.

Salary relief is just needed in the trade id imagine. Idk maybe not

Maybe, but the business side of this deal just doesn't work. You want to attract clients who say they want to play here and force their way to you? The best way to not do that is sign them to an 8 year extension and ship them off to Edmonton.

 

[TruePowerSlave]

The only team worth consider trading with is colorado

MacKinnon + Makar + 1st 2023 (the year)

for ConnorMcDavid

Colorado laughs at that offer. Zero reason to even think about it.

If McDavid asks for a trade he is going for less.

 

[Taluss]

Maybe, but the business side of this deal just doesn't work. You want to attract clients who say they want to play here and force their way to you? The best way to not do that is sign them to an 8 year extension and ship them off to Edmonton.

Yeah thats fair.

Honestly im not a fan of a player forcing their way anywhere so I wouldn't think twice about trading him for Mcdavid. Im sure other clients would understand as well. Like this is the best player in the leauge

 

[TFHockey]

You want a NYR/Oiler deal for McDavid?

Okay.



Shersterkin
Kakko
Nils Lundkvist
Braden Schneider
Chytil



Connor McDavid
Koskinen
Kassian

 

[Mandalorian]

Ok. Do you want McDavid or not???

MacKinnon + Makar.

Deal or no deal?

Add Draisatl and the value is more fair. Right now, the Colorado value bar is full while Edmonton bar is at 80%.

 

[bernmeister]

You want a NYR/Oiler deal for McDavid?

Okay.



Shersterkin
Kakko
Nils Lundkvist
Braden Schneider
Chytil



Connor McDavid
Koskinen
Kassian

It's a fair offer value wise, kudos there.
Consistent w/my positions about cap, depth etc etc. I'd pass esp since McD is only coupla yrs. Would not want him into late years as decrepit albatross, but contract into early 30s in his case, yes.

 

[bl02]

You want a NYR/Oiler deal for McDavid?

Okay.



Shersterkin
Kakko
Nils Lundkvist
Braden Schneider
Chytil



Connor McDavid
Koskinen
Kassian

It's a fair trade I just can't give up Shesterkin. Would you do all of the above players minus Shesterkin for Draisaitl or is having no goalie in the trade a deal breaker?

 

[Taluss]

You want a NYR/Oiler deal for McDavid?

Okay.



Shersterkin
Kakko
Nils Lundkvist
Braden Schneider
Chytil



Connor McDavid
Koskinen
Kassian

Done

 

[TFHockey]

It's a fair trade I just can't give up Shesterkin. Would you do all of the above players minus Shesterkin for Draisaitl or is having no goalie in the trade a deal breaker?

I think the Oilers have to have him. Adding him fixes a serious hole in their organization, adding Chytil fills in the center position that now should have drai, RNH, Chytil and McLeod, Kakko improves the right side after moving Kassian, and the two D should allow another move, such as trading Broberg, to add something else like Chychrun.

 

[Habs10025]

Connor McDavid


Alexis Lafreniere
Kaapo Kakko
Filip Chytil
Nils Lundkvist
Alexandar Georgiev

New York Rangers reject this trade.

 

[ViD]

Oilers already traded away the best player in the game once upon a time, no way a franchise survives doing it twice......

Yeah that Smyth trade was heart breaking

 

[SwedishFire]

Add Draisatl and the value is more fair. Right now, the Colorado value bar is full while Edmonton bar is at 80%.

Ok


MacKinnon + Makar + a pick

for

McDavid + Broberg

 

[SwedishFire]

It's a fair trade I just can't give up Shesterkin. Would you do all of the above players minus Shesterkin for Draisaitl or is having no goalie in the trade a deal breaker?

saysva Ny R fan?? OfC you think its fair.

Oilers has zero reason to do that trade.

Lafranierre and Kakko has low value. Pick them out.

There is a reason Ny Rangers fans is shipping out Kakko and Laf in every deal. Both is high draft picks, that has lower ceiling than thought, and lower floor than expected, and are dissapointments. Kakko has a small value, but its lower than for ex Puljujärvi. Their only value is high draftpedigree and expected talent


Add two others.

 

[Matty Sundin]

He’s not getting traded anytime soon even if he wants out. There just not a deal that works that doesn’t destroy a teams depth/farm system or a deal that doesn’t hose the oilers

 

[jellybeans]

The only team worth consider trading with is colorado

MacKinnon + Makar + 1st 2023 (the year)

for ConnorMcDavid

Colorado easily declines.

 

[Zerotonine]

Colorado easily declines.

Good because it's an over payment from the oilers

 

[TFHockey]

New York Rangers reject this trade.

Looks like Ranger fans disagree with you.

 

[BroadwayStorm]

Rangers don't have the young center, dman or goalie available to make it work.

Anaheim(McTavish/Drysdale/Dostal)
Florida(Lundell/Ekblad/Knight)
Buffalo(Cozens/Krebs/Power/Levi)
Detroit(Larkin/Seider/Cossa)
Avalanche(Newhook/Byram/Annunen)
Vancouver(Petterson/Hughes/Demko)
New Jersey (Hughes/Hughes/Blackwood)

Off the top of my head the teams that have the assets that would appease HFoil fans in a McDavid or Draisaitl trade.

you would take that from NJ for McDavid? lol

 

[The S5]

I disagree depending on what the Oilers would want via the draft capital. Rangers have enough prospects they can afford to loose some.

Mcdavid> Zibby + Fox.
Loosing Fox would sting like hell but would be needed.

Laf for all we know could stay the same. If he doesnt improve its not a big loss when you get Mcdavid back

Unsure what prospects or draft capital Oilers would want.

Salary relief is just needed in the trade id imagine. Idk maybe not

You're right, the Rangers won't instantly turn into the Oilers, THEY WOULD BE WORSE.

Sometimes I wonder if people on this board even watch hockey.

 

[thadd]

A comparable offer from LA would probably look like:

Byfield
Turcotte
Kupari
Bjornfot
Petersen

Which, in my opinion, isn't enough for McDavid.

That's a way better off than the OP imo.

 

[Taluss]

You're right, the Rangers won't instantly turn into the Oilers, THEY WOULD BE WORSE.

Sometimes I wonder if people on this board even watch hockey.

Explain

 

[Ninety7]

Start with fox