Proposal: McDavid to NYR

[Perennial]

Try Shesterkin and Fox +

The whole point of acquiring McDavid is to win the Cup, so it's likely any deal would involve picks + prospects going the other way rather than established young all-stars just entering their prime...

 

[Lindberg Cheese]

If you want McDavid, set up a honey pot operation for Daryl Katz to walk right into - one that preferably results in criminal charges. Create a straw man buyer for the franchise, the silent owners being the NYR, now you trade.

 

[Nylanderthal]

2020's 1st overall pick, 2019's 2nd overall pick, 2018 1st rd pick, 2017 1st rd pick & a goalie lol, there are way worse offers. That's a higher reward offer than most teams could put forward if you're looking for futures

The 19 & 20 picks look like busts, you haven’t sent any cap over. Ny would be in a bigger bind than Toronto is currently cap wise if they did this deal. Who out of the rags high ticket deals would accept a trade from new york to Edmonton cause they all have nmc’s.

 

[Osakahaus]

every player on Rangers untouchable as seen by the Eichel trade

 

[stevo61]

Doesnt even have Kravstov... Here I thought JT Miller was the biggest bozo around

 

[Mez]

Connor McDavid


Alexis Lafreniere
Kaapo Kakko
Filip Chytil
Nils Lundkvist
Alexandar Georgiev

Start with Fox and Zib and add from there.

 

[Suntouchable13]

Start with Fox and Zib and add from there.

Then there is no trade for them. It doesn't make the Rangers better. I don't understand what is the point of the trade for the NYR if they just become the Oilers after gutting the roster to acquire McDaddy. Just keep him and build properly around him.

 

[kilowatt]

I don't think the gap between MacKinnon and McDavid, at their respective contracts, is significant.

 

[Weltschmerz]

Connor McDavid


Alexis Lafreniere
Kaapo Kakko
Filip Chytil
Nils Lundkvist
Alexandar Georgiev

You forgot Kravtsov

 

[DanielBrassard]

Assuming Zibanejad would waive his NMC, and he probably won't, I would offer

Zibanejad
Lafreniere
Miller
Lundkvist/Schneider
Plus multiple 1sts and 2nds

 

[Synergy27]

Start with Fox and Zib and add from there.

We’re in fantasy land, so while we’re here, what about Zib + Panarin?

Or some huge package with Panarin as the centerpiece?

Panarin/Kakko/Schneider/Georgiev/pick(s)?

 

[ck26]

Nyr
ConnorMcDavid

Edm
Madison square garden, packed, and with an builders instruction manual, shipped free to edmonton.

Why would EDM want a second, crappier arena?

 

[ZiGOODejad]

They would easily demand Shesty. What people don’t realize is the should demand Benny Allaire he’s the f***ing goalie whisperer.

 

[BeersHockey]

Ok. Do you want McDavid or not???

MacKinnon + Makar.

Deal or no deal?

I would absolutely not do this deal from the Avs perspective.

 

[alasania94]

The only team worth consider trading with is colorado

MacKinnon + Makar + 1st 2023 (the year)

for ConnorMcDavid

absolutely awful for colorado lol

 

[alasania94]

not trying to slight him at all. he's a fantastic player, but his value isn't close to McDavid

he’s a top 3 asset in the NHL and most probably the #1-2 best defensemen in the NHL for the next ten years. if mcdavid were to go to colorado for makar colorado would probably only have to add newhook to it and the value would be fair.

 

[Nucklehead Supreme]

Ok. Do you want McDavid or not???

MacKinnon + Makar.

Deal or no deal?

 

[howboutahug]

he’s a top 3 asset in the NHL and most probably the #1-2 best defensemen in the NHL for the next ten years. if mcdavid were to go to colorado for makar colorado would probably only have to add newhook to it and the value would be fair.

I wouldn't add much of anything if anything at all. Their values are very close to one another.

 

[Mez]

Then there is no trade for them. It doesn't make the Rangers better. I don't understand what is the point of the trade for the NYR if they just become the Oilers after gutting the roster to acquire McDaddy. Just keep him and build properly around him.

Exactly...most trades for McDavid wont be worth it for the other team.

 

[SwedishFire]

View attachment 500728

no gretzkys or mcdavids for you...

 

[archangel2]

Connor McDavid


Alexis Lafreniere
Kaapo Kakko
Filip Chytil
Nils Lundkvist
Alexandar Georgiev

At least this deal has some good prospects heading towards the oilers. It would start the oilers on a full rebuild. I could see that being a problem for the oilers. Basically 4 first round picks and a guy who could be their starter

 

[archangel2]

Edmonton needs to retain 50%. NYR can't take on that cap.

Unless the Rangers are adding Fox--they are not retaining

 

[The S5]

Fox
Zibby
Laf
Oilers choice of prospect
Draft capital
Salary releif

And the Rangers instantly turn into the Oilers. No thanks.

 

[Taluss]

And the Rangers instantly turn into the Oilers. No thanks.

I disagree depending on what the Oilers would want via the draft capital. Rangers have enough prospects they can afford to loose some.

Mcdavid> Zibby + Fox.
Loosing Fox would sting like hell but would be needed.

Laf for all we know could stay the same. If he doesnt improve its not a big loss when you get Mcdavid back

Unsure what prospects or draft capital Oilers would want.

Salary relief is just needed in the trade id imagine. Idk maybe not

 

[Reddwit]

Any reasonable McDavid trade is going to gut the other teams depth, which is the very problem that would lead to McDavid being on the block in the first place.

Take the hypothetical acceptable offer from Detroit: Larkin/Seider/Cossa. Detroit’s current biggest need is another top 6 center. In trading for McDavid, they lose their current 1C, so they don’t make any headway in addressing their biggest need, but they also lose their current young 1D, and their potential future starting G, creating new problems. In short, upgrading from Larkin to McDavid actually sets back the team at large, creating a similar lack of depth in key positions to what Edmonton is dealing with now.