Not sure how you can have two players from the same team be finalists for the Hart. There are a number of players that are more worthy of the Hart than Pasta this season.
Karlsson?? He's a -23. Sharks couldn't have been much worse if missed the whole season.
I could care less about his +/-, or anyone's +/- for that matter. The guy is 2nd in pts. this year at EV behind only McDavid (75 vs. 74) Think about that for a second when you consider how exceptional McDavid's season was.
First D to 100 pts. since the mid 1990s. Even Bourque never cracked 100.
What Karlsson did offensively for a D-man this year is truly exceptional. I can't give him a MVP vote because players from teams that DNQ shouldn't win Hart Trophies. But as far as individual performances go, Karlsson is Top 5 in the NHL this past season.
When you have a team that is near top of GF by such a significant margin, and also is leads in GA by a similar significant margin, you can have a forward and a goalie from the same team finalists for MVP. I think the exceptional-ness of the Bruins season needs to be taken into account.
It's a rare thing but it's happened before. In 1988 for example, Fuhr finished #2 behind Lemieux, Wayne was actually No. 3 that year behind his own goaltender.
Honestly I'm staring here at a list of the top scorers and who is more deserving than Pasta of MVP consideration other than McDavid? Sorry I don't see one. The guy just posted 18 goals in his past 21 games and accounted for 25% of all Bruins goals during that timeframe. Overall he's scored 20% of their goals this year, literally the exact same % as McDavid whose team is leads in GF.
If this was a team fighting for a playoff spot, he'd be getting praised for carrying a team into a playoff spot. So he's not an MVP candidate because he plays for a really good team?
Truth is, Pastrnak probably isn't getting enough praise for his performance this season. I'm not delusional, he's not winning the Hart (McDavid has it locked up). But he should be nominated, as should Ullmark.