No player in the league has benefited from the PP this year more than Nuge and it’s not even close. He is the only player in the league to have more than half his points on the PP. You attempting to argue that he benefits more offensively by not playing on the PP with McDavid and being the PPQB is quite comical.
I am not sure if you did not read what I said or did not understand it. So I will review it for you.
1) I pointed out that
5 vs 5 Nuge was an example of a player who over the years has scored at a higher rate away from McDavid than with him. This counters your arguement that
McDavid boosts every player scoring more than any other player in the league.
Specifically about the pp here is what I said:
On the pp things are a little different. Nuge plays a key role here as he is the secondary puck handler on the Oilers pp. So while in the past he was the main ppqb he still gets a lot of high impact touches on the pp so in this case the extra goals the team scored over in previous years pretty much balanced out his modest decline in his role on the pp.
Note the use of the term "in previous years". The point being, until this year Nuge's scoring rate on the pp was similar in the past to what it was when he was the ppqb. You will note I said nothing about this year specifically.
As for this year...No one would argue that Nuge has not benefit immensely from McDavid on the pp. But what is true is that McDavid benefits from Nuge as well as he is a key component of the pp. Since I assume you watch all the Oilers games you must surely know this.
Bottom line is that you made a statement this is provably false and doubled down on it multiple times. If you find your own error amusing, then I am happy to have added some levity to your life.