Confirmed with Link: Kyle Dubas named President of Hockey Operations

  • Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
It's what Toronto does. They could have the best management team in the history of the world and still fail remarkably.

But that's a discussion for the Toronto board, not here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BusinessGoose
Quoted for truth.

Good article.
Playoffs are a crapshoot. Nobody wants to admit that but it's true. We won b2b cups and then lost in the 2nd round and 4 straight in the first round.

Washington finally won a cup with far from the best team they ever fielded in the Ovechkin era.

65 win Bruins just lost in the first round.

etc etc.

The playoffs matter obviously but there's a huge amount of variance there. The best thing you can do as a GM is continue to put great teams into the playoffs and hope for the best. And Dubas did that in Toronto.
 
I’m not entirely sure I’ve seen one take from any Canadian media that isn’t slamming Dubas or the Pens. Just so salty up north.

Tbf I haven’t seen one Pens media member that has been remotely critical of Dubas or his past work.
Joe Starkey had an article for the Post-Gazette entitled, “It’s alright to be underwhelmed by the Dubas hire” lol
 
I’m not entirely sure I’ve seen one take from any Canadian media that isn’t slamming Dubas or the Pens. Just so salty up north.

Tbf I haven’t seen one Pens media member that has been remotely critical of Dubas or his past work.
Their arguments against him coming here suck. Toronto's problems don't apply here. They never mention his draft and development ability and that is massive for us.

The most ridiculous thing to me is that Leafs fans and media were very happy with Dubas' moves up until the playoffs started, and that is well after Dubas' lost any control of outcomes. That's well after the deadline. They're also happy with the contributions of the core until then.

So they acknowledge the roster is solid and that he prepared them well, and then they pull a 180 when the players fail.
They don't see the flaw in this reasoning.
It's basically just crying over losing and needing a target for their rage.

Joe Starkey had an article for the Post-Gazette entitled, “It’s alright to be underwhelmed by the Dubas hire” lol
Yeah, like they were gonna get someone that gives them a bigger chance to make the playoffs and can do draft and development better than him.

Stfu Starkey
 
I know I'm the cynic here, but I'm honestly hopeful that Dubas can ram through some changes. I'm not worried about him seeing the problems, per se, I'm worried about him being able to get the changes made through this weird power-sharing agreement we're working with.

But like always, I hope I'm wrong, and I'll give him time to prove himself.
My only cause for optimism in regards to the bolded is Dubas seemed to be sought after by multiple teams. So I can't see him choosing the Pens over the other options unless he was guaranteed some level of autonomy to run things how he wants to.

If he was going to remain a puppet GM and do whatever the people above him told him to do, he could have just stuck around Toronto and continue doing Shanahan's bidding.
 
I know I'm the cynic here, but I'm honestly hopeful that Dubas can ram through some changes. I'm not worried about him seeing the problems, per se, I'm worried about him being able to get the changes made through this weird power-sharing agreement we're working with.

But like always, I hope I'm wrong, and I'll give him time to prove himself.

I don't think it's a power sharing agreement at all. I think its Dubas' power* and we'll see how much he chooses to delegate. That might cause other problems but right now, those are all Dubas' problems to avoid or create.


*The only exception is the four names the org has made sacrosanct, and that is presumably something he is fine with.
 
All writers, pundits, bloggers, podcasters, team employees, etc, are clowns, blowhards, jokes...

The biggest blowhards around post here for free.

People need to get a grip.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlankFrank416
Playoffs are a crapshoot. Nobody wants to admit that but it's true. We won b2b cups and then lost in the 2nd round and 4 straight in the first round.

Washington finally won a cup with far from the best team they ever fielded in the Ovechkin era.

65 win Bruins just lost in the first round.

etc etc.

The playoffs matter obviously but there's a huge amount of variance there. The best thing you can do as a GM is continue to put great teams into the playoffs and hope for the best. And Dubas did that in Toronto.
I guess the question Dubas has to answer for himself first, with this team with their core in their upper 30's, with Jake with only a year left on his contract and likely gone after, is whether this team has a good chance in that crap shoot or not.

There is an expiration date on this team and if not now, it is close.

Knowing when to cut bait and when to fish is a big part of what a good GM does, especially in the case of a team like the Pens.

If the window has closed the choice made would be much different.

So Dubas needs to choose.

I don't see where trying to do 'both at once' is really possible.

Either you trade off real assets to make a real run or you cut bait. To do virtually nothing is a choice but the worst of the three choices.
 

In Pittsburgh, the team essentially has no top young prospects. The Penguins haven’t had a top-20 pick in a decade. When they had the No. 8 and No. 22 picks in 2013, the Penguins screwed up both, taking Derrick Pouliot and Olli Maatta, passing on the likes of Jacob Trouba, Filip Forsberg, Tom Wilson and Andrei Vasilevskiy.

Pittsburgh’s cupboard is bare. The Penguins have the No. 14 pick next month in the draft, and no second-rounder. That pick was dealt to Nashville for veteran Mikael Granlund, one of the last of the pointless moves made by the Brian Burke/Ron Hextall regime.


The good news is that Crosby, Malkin and Letang are all still very good players, if no longer what they once were. Crosby was 16th in league scoring this season, while Malkin was 26th. Jake Guentzel, meanwhile, had 36 goals, Rickard Rakell had 27 and Jason Zucker scored 26. Still, the team missed the Stanley Cup playoffs in the final week because it couldn’t beat awful Chicago or horrible Columbus.

As Burke and Hextall could tell Dubas, the new owners of the Penguins aren’t interested in a teardown or a rebuild. They want whoever is running the team to take another run at a Cup, as unrealistic as that might be to everyone outside of Pittsburgh. That probably means more moves like the Granlund deal, and no possibility of moving one of the stars for some badly needed futures.

Dubas has no experience with this type of situation. With the Leafs, he had to take a young group, augment it with other players, and try to get the team to a level of success it hadn’t experienced in 20 years. Outside of the regular season, he failed.

Obviously the Penguins saw in that failure glimpses of brilliance that convinced them Dubas was the best choice to take over their hockey department. His age, expertise in analytics and preference for a puck-possession style of hockey may have been what made the Penguins believe he is their future.


He has already won over the local media, which went gaga over his hiring on Thursday, calling him “one of hockey’s most famous people” and a “genius.” Perhaps those qualities were obscured somewhat in Toronto while his teams were losing in the first round six years in a row.

It’s interesting that the common element between Toronto and Pittsburgh is that, in both places, Dubas didn’t get to pick his own coach but instead inherited an experienced head coach with a record of championships. In Toronto, that was Mike Babcock. In Pittsburgh, it’s Mike Sullivan.

We know Babcock and Dubas weren’t on the same page, and Dubas won that MLSE political battle. Sullivan, however, is a more formidable personality on the Pittsburgh scene, and he is extremely well-connected inside the organization and throughout the sport.


Maybe he and Dubas will see eye to eye, although this perception that they embrace exactly the same style of hockey may require further analysis. If the team stumbles next season, Sullivan shouldn’t count on more support than Babcock got. At least Sheldon Keefe isn’t waiting in the wings. Not yet, anyway.

Most people would agree Dubas did good work in Toronto. But the job ahead in Pittsburgh looks to be much more complex and difficult, even if the glare of the spotlight is less. As well, Dubas no longer has a buffer between himself and ownership like he did in Toronto with Brendan Shanahan.

Dubas must meet the expectations of immediate success set down by the Fenway Group and simultaneously start restocking the team’s depth chart with talented young players. Plus, he may have to find a goalie, never his strong suit in Toronto.

Maybe he is a genius. In Pittsburgh, he’s going to have to be.

Lmao I love Toronto media.

Also Oli Maata was hardly a bad pick and doing that woulda coulda about him is weird

He was a reliable D man on both cup runs.


Pouliot was bad enough alone that the revisionism on Maata was unnecessary
 

Sullivan on same page as Dubas to have Penguins contend for Stanley Cup​

Coach agrees with new boss that it's best to 'surround' Crosby, Malkin, Letang with more talent​



Speed is what's most needed, Sullivan said.

Oh I'm going to vomit
🤮
Why? Do you watch other teams? Penguins are playing in mud
 
  • Like
Reactions: LOGiK
I honestly think that this is a hire for the rebuild rather than some all in for the old guys one more time.

Dubas is a young guy and is not going to want to hamstring the next decade for a pursuit of a fantasy.
from where I'm at, I can't see a way to go for the "one more time." every time i start up a path i run into a wall. the trade all our junk for the other team's gold (as some posters here want to do) just doesn't fly. not enough jr's in the world. even doing the rebuild will take more time because of all the walls the prior administration has left us. even getting free agents will be hard because they will be blocked by unmovable rocks.
 
I guess the question Dubas has to answer for himself first, with this team with their core in their upper 30's, with Jake with only a year left on his contract and likely gone after, is whether this team has a good chance in that crap shoot or not.

There is an expiration date on this team and if not now, it is close.

Knowing when to cut bait and when to fish is a big part of what a good GM does, especially in the case of a team like the Pens.

If the window has closed the choice made would be much different.

So Dubas needs to choose.

I don't see where trying to do 'both at once' is really possible.

Either you trade off real assets to make a real run or you cut bait. To do virtually nothing is a choice but the worst of the three choices.
We'll know the direction when we see what Dubas does with our 1st rounder this year. It's got a heck of a lot of value. If they trade it, and throw in Pickering or deal him separately to get an actual high impact player, then we'll know we're all in, and planning to bottom out in a couple years.

The problem now is that these picks are actually guys who will need to lead the rebuild in 3-5 years. The question then becomes is Pickering and our pick this year going to yield the type of talent to lead a rebuild. Probably not.

If I'm Dubas I go all in this year, trade everything but the kitchen sink, then go about building the prospect pipeline back up over time with smart later round picks, undrafted FA signings, international signings, etc, and see what the core can do. Between our 1st, Pickering, and our cap space he can reshape the roster dramatically in an offseason, especially if they are willing to trade or buy out Granlund, Rust, Petry, etc.
 
from where I'm at, I can't see a way to go for the "one more time." every time i start up a path i run into a wall. the trade all our junk for the other team's gold (as some posters here want to do) just doesn't fly. not enough jr's in the world. even doing the rebuild will take more time because of all the walls the prior administration has left us. even getting free agents will be hard because they will be blocked by unmovable rocks.
You did not even go into how all the core are yet another year older. That Malkin and Crosby both were healthy for the entire year for the first time in their careers. Letang for the most part too. All the core was there for the playoffs.

How much of that is likely to occur again?

Then you get into dead weight contracts, making perfect signings and trades, and on and on.

Way too much has to go right for them to actually compete.

And then it is just for one year. No way that they can sign Jake and keep anything like a competitive team.

I just don't think that most have accepted the reality of this team. I am sure that Dubas gets it. I just hope that he is not pressured into a stupid quixotic quest for one more ride into the sunset with the good guys that leads over the cliff.

Could it work? Sure.

Could I win a million dollars in the lottery? Also, sure.

Am I better putting my money into an index fund rather than lottery tickets? Dubas hopefully knows the answer to that question.

The fans may hate it but it is the right move.

It is going to be rad to see this team trade the 1st plus something stupid for Hellebuyck and then resign Dumo and put Carter as 3C
I want to give your post a like but I can't because I hate how true it is.
 
  • Love
Reactions: The Old Master
Lmao I love Toronto media.

Also Oli Maata was hardly a bad pick and doing that woulda coulda about him is weird

He was a reliable D man on both cup runs.


Pouliot was bad enough alone that the revisionism on Maata was unnecessary
Maatta was very good til his injury. And he wasn't as bad as people made him out to be after his injuries.
 
Playoffs are a crapshoot. Nobody wants to admit that but it's true. We won b2b cups and then lost in the 2nd round and 4 straight in the first round.

Washington finally won a cup with far from the best team they ever fielded in the Ovechkin era.

65 win Bruins just lost in the first round.

etc etc.

The playoffs matter obviously but there's a huge amount of variance there. The best thing you can do as a GM is continue to put great teams into the playoffs and hope for the best. And Dubas did that in Toronto.
Winning the Cup may be a crapshoot, but putting together a real playoff contender means you will typically make at least a couple of deep runs over a half decade when your core is in their primes.

Dubas wasn’t able to do that in Toronto. The guy is young, maybe he will have learned from past mistakes and have better luck here. One can only hope.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scandale du Jour
It is going to be rad to see this team trade the 1st plus something stupid for Hellebuyck and then resign Dumo and put Carter as 3C
If it makes you feel better, they're probably gonna trade the 1st for Garland and use him as Zucker's replacement, because this team just has to stay stocked to the gills with smaller, 40-45pt middle-6 forwards making $5 million a year.

And they'll also re-sign Dumo and put Carter at 3C. :laugh:
 
  • Like
Reactions: farscape1
It is going to be rad to see this team trade the 1st plus something stupid for Hellebuyck and then resign Dumo and put Carter as 3C
It's not going to be rad because they will not trade that first round pick unless they get a ridiculously great offer. They will keep that first round pick as they should! Remember, the Mandate is to look forward to the future just as much as now. Giving up your first round pick wouldn't make much sense now would it? They keep the mother f****** pick! Or maybe move up!
 
Lmao I love Toronto media.

Also Oli Maata was hardly a bad pick and doing that woulda coulda about him is weird

He was a reliable D man on both cup runs.


Pouliot was bad enough alone that the revisionism on Maata was unnecessary
The Toronto media and some of their fans a pissed that the Leafs haven't won a championship since the NHL expanded; while the pens have won five championships.
 
If it makes you feel better, they're probably gonna trade the 1st for Garland and use him as Zucker's replacement, because this team just has to stay stocked to the gills with smaller, 40-45pt middle-6 forwards making $5 million a year.

And they'll also re-sign Dumo and put Carter at 3C. :laugh:
I sincerely hope Dubas helps curb all of this Stockholm Syndrome moves like resigning Dumo....

I for one am intrigued by him and whoever he gets as GM. I think we are trending up. Makes it hilarious how 95% of Leafs fans are so upset. Pretty pathetic to read some takes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Friggin Dummy

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad