July 1st - Free Agent Extravaganza Part III

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
Stepan and Brass 1-2 punch will suck in the regular season but in the playoffs they could be one of the best, both are very good playoff performers

They may have been very good in the playoffs because there was another line ahead of them, or between them, that preformed OK, but also took some attention away from defenses. Without that buffer, it's a different story. MSL needs a centerman. Without that, overall production during the season dips considerably and this team doesn't get to see how good the tandem of Stepan and Brass would be in the playoffs.
 
Maybe the Brad Richards of the Dallas Stars.

Certainly not the Richards of the last two years.

This is from 2013-14. Brassard a lot better defensively, but Richards made that up and more offensively. Both were below avg. point scorers 5v5 though.

RichardsvsBrassard5v52013-14_zpsc8f14d39.png
 
Good points. Stepan is the team's best center, but he is by no means an elite center. I dont understand how people get angry with him because he isn't.

Yes, look who he was matched against in the finals, Kopitar, most definitely an elite player. Kopitar incidentally only had 2 assists in 5 games in the series. Yet LA won because they had Carter, who was playing better than I have ever seen him. Stepan didn't have that luxury.
 
He centered for one of the top scorers in the league who couldn't put the puck in the ocean from the end of a pier. It's not like Stepan was/is a miracle worker but he played fine. Also he is an exceptional penalty killer.

I suppose it's no different then all the crap Boyle used to get before he was put in a position to succeed. If the Rangers got a true #1, people would be kissing Stepan's behind.

Down the middle is going to kill the Rangers, it's what killed them in the playoffs. For as deep a team as they were last year, they had no center depth and obviously were lacking a top tier C. That said there's nothing wrong with Stepan, he isn't elite and he's tasked with playing that part on this team.

Edit: I agree with you

Putting players, especially young players, in a position to succeed is key. Stepan had that with Richards in front of him. He no longer has that, but now has experience and can take that role, but he needs someone behind him, and if that's Brassard, then he needs someone behind him. As you say, down the middle may kill the Rangers this season.
 
Putting players, especially young players, in a position to succeed is key. Stepan had that with Richards in front of him. He no longer has that, but now has experience and can take that role, but he needs someone behind him, and if that's Brassard, then he needs someone behind him. As you say, down the middle may kill the Rangers this season.

Good point Fletch.

I see a lot of people wanting Miller, Lindberg, Fast, Kristo (whoever else) step up and take a roster spot, but I keep coming back to the "in a position to succeed argument." Does anyone really know what these players are at the NHL level?
 
Good point Fletch.

I see a lot of people wanting Miller, Lindberg, Fast, Kristo (whoever else) step up and take a roster spot, but I keep coming back to the "in a position to succeed argument." Does anyone really know what these players are at the NHL level?

that's the rub. You want a kid to compete, but if he's not NHL-ready, especially ready to be a second line centerman, can you rely on him to be in that role. If they're good, they'll get their shot. I don't think anyone of them has jumped out screaming ready for a 15 minute-a-night role in the NHL. Well, at least I haven't heard as much.
 
This season reminds me slightly of 2010-11 in that no one knew what to expect from that team and guys like the Pack Line, Staal, Girardi, and Stepan pretty much carried the team all year.

If that's the way they're gonna go fine but there will be growing pains. I'm fine with Miller/Fast/Lindberg.

They still need more size. Winnik is out there. He'd help.
 
that's the rub. You want a kid to compete, but if he's not NHL-ready, especially ready to be a second line centerman, can you rely on him to be in that role. If they're good, they'll get their shot. I don't think anyone of them has jumped out screaming ready for a 15 minute-a-night role in the NHL. Well, at least I haven't heard as much.

I'd say Miller is the closest, but AV had some awfully harsh words for him at the end of the season.

Fast didn't look completely out of place, but he was a passenger and didnt make much of a positive impact either.
 
He centered for one of the top scorers in the league who couldn't put the puck in the ocean from the end of a pier. It's not like Stepan was/is a miracle worker but he played fine. Also he is an exceptional penalty killer.

I suppose it's no different then all the crap Boyle used to get before he was put in a position to succeed. If the Rangers got a true #1, people would be kissing Stepan's behind.

Down the middle is going to kill the Rangers, it's what killed them in the playoffs. For as deep a team as they were last year, they had no center depth and obviously were lacking a top tier C. That said there's nothing wrong with Stepan, he isn't elite and he's tasked with playing that part on this team.

Edit: I agree with you

What killed the Rangers was their 2C (Richards) playing like trash, and the Kings' 2C (Carter) playing like a god.

Remember Kopitar had two points. Two. As did Stepan.
 
What killed the RANGERS against the KINGS was that Kreider couldn't score on three breakaways and Nash couldn't hit a open net. But yeah it's a lack of a #1 center :shakehead:
 
I'd say Miller is the closest, but AV had some awfully harsh words for him at the end of the season.

Fast didn't look completely out of place, but he was a passenger and didnt make much of a positive impact either.

which is why it's tough to leave open a "2C" slot for him (for those looking for a spot to be left open for a kid). I don't know how they fill that gap, or if they even fill it. The dynamic changes if Stepan is the #1 and Brassard is the #2. Their numbers may change also (more Brassard's than Stepan's, provided Nash plays a full season and Kreider improves on last season's play). And then...with whom does MSL play? What a dilly of a pickle!
 
We could see something like
Nash-Stepan-MSL
Kreider-Brass-Zucc
Hags-Miller-Fast/???
Glass-Moore-Carcillo/???

Your main PKers stay in bottom six, put hags and fast who both play sound defensively with Miller and make Kreider the replacement for Poo

Edit: We can also always tweak that fourth line
 
Yes, look who he was matched against in the finals, Kopitar, most definitely an elite player. Kopitar incidentally only had 2 assists in 5 games in the series. Yet LA won because they had Carter, who was playing better than I have ever seen him. Stepan didn't have that luxury.

If Kopitar is an elite center, the definition of elite must change by the minute.
 
If Kopitar is an elite center, the definition of elite must change by the minute.

Please tell me how Kopitar isn't elite. I'll wait.

When people on HF think Jason Spezza is better than Anze Kopitar and Patrice Bergeron (not you, specifically, but there are definitely people who do) then there's a problem.
 
Please tell me how Kopitar isn't elite. I'll wait.

When people on HF think Jason Spezza is better than Anze Kopitar and Patrice Bergeron (not you, specifically, but there are definitely people who do) then there's a problem.

I don't think any of those players are elite.

I think there are like 10-15 elite players in the league.

Case in point, the definition of elite changes every day.
 
Stralman needs to remember what got him the $22.5M

It's funny to hear Anton Stralman say he wants to rediscover his offensive game. He earned a 5-yr deal b/c of how well he drives possession.

https://twitter.com/drosennhl/status/486581065851887616

Stralman hopes to re-discover his offensive game in the Lightning’s system, which has more freedom, without sacrificing what got him his big payday.

http://www.tampabay.com/blogs/lightning/stralman-says-lightning-close-to-complete/2187611

Stralman had the freedom with the Rangers.
 
I've stayed away from here for the past few days, mostly since there's only nonsense being spewed around here.

Joe Thornton? GTFO of here. We'll be the 2012-2013 team all over again. We'll end up gutting our depth for a good top 6, but not much else after that. The Rangers have been successful the past few years because they have depth. We're not a Joe Thornton away from a Cup, especially if it comes at the expense of what's being proposed around here. Balance is what wins championships.

Mike Ribiero? Puke. If Phoenix, a team desperate for offense, bought him out, you know there's HUGE issues there. Run, not walk away.

Dany Heatley? Pass. Legs are shot.

The most viable plan for this season is to sign a guy like Setoguchi that can add a right handed shot to our 2nd PP unit and let the kids fight it out for the 3rd line center spot, and pray. It wouldn't be totally inconceivable to see Lindberg on this team next year. Underrated offense, great on faceoffs.

Hagelin-Stepan-Nash
Kreider-Brassard-MSL
Zuccarello-Miller/Lindberg-Setoguchi
Fast-Moore-Glass
Carcillo

McDonagh-Girardi
Staal-Boyle
Moore-Klein

Lundqvist
Talbot

Go to war. Trade Staal at the deadline if he Callahan's himself and wants too much money and term.
 
Setoguchi is bad.

If he were left handed, no one would want him.

Winnipeg was a mess last season. Guy scored 20 goals or over or was on pace for it every season he's been in this league except for last. He's a good guy to take a flyer on a la Pouliot last year. Worst case is that Fast, Kristo, and Haggerty all beat him out for a spot.
 
Winnipeg was a mess last season. Guy scored 20 goals or over or was on pace for it every season he's been in this league except for last. He's a good guy to take a flyer on a la Pouliot last year. Worst case is that Fast, Kristo, and Haggerty all beat him out for a spot.

They were a mediocre team with horrific goaltending. If they had competent goaltending, they would have been fine. They're far from a "mess", they're not the Oilers. Setoguchi will score around 15-20 goals, but he'll be garbage in every other facet of the game he could possibly be bad in.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad