Michael Farkas
Celebrate 68
The Hockey News - Mar 9 2004 said:If peers are the best judge of performance, there can be only two candidates for the mantle of top goalie in 2003-04. -
In a poll of 52 NHL netminders asked to name the best goalie in the league, New Jersey’s Martin Brodeur narrowly edged Florida’s Roberto Luongo by a count of 23 to 18. Goalies were not allowedto vote for themselves or any other masked man on their own team.
Ten goalies received votes in all. Toronto’s Ed Belfour, with three votes, and Dallas’s Marty Turco, with two, were the only others who had support from more than one source.
##
The Hockey News - Jan 28 1983 said:...
Brad Park: “I played with three goaltenders who could really handle the puck: Ed Giacomin, Gilles Villemure and Gerry Cheevers. Ed Giacomin had the best shot. Cheesy was the best stickhandler, Villemure was a combination of both.
“Peter Peeters can shoot it out with the best of them. And he’s learning to stickhandle. He’s really moving the puck well when the guys are coming at him. I don’t think they let him handle the puck that much in Philadelphia.”
Peeters, who came to Boston last summer from the Philadelphia Flyers in exchange for defenseman Brad McCrimmon, agrees that he was bound by too many restrictions during his five years in the Flyers’ organization.
“I think basically I’m getting back to my own style,” he said. “When I was in Philadelphia, they really had me programmed. Do this. Do that. They wouldn’t let me come out of the net. They wouldn’t let me wander and here Gerry’s letting me go.
“I think I’m a lot more aggressive. I’m attacking the puck when they fire it into the comer. I want to get on top of it. I want to handle it. Sometimes I make a few mistakes. I’m gonna get burned sometimes but you expect that.”
Differences in goalie coaches Bernie Parent (Philadelphia) and Gerry Cheevers (Boston), though Cheevers was the head coach (also?) at the time of this.
##
The Hockey News - Sep 9 1994 said:...
Goaltender equipment manufacturers and equipment managers, however, offer yet another factor. They claim some goalies were cheating, using pads and other equipment with blocking areas that are larger than printed NHL maximums.
They also claim not enough was done to check or ban the illegal gear.
First, the NHL equipment standards can be subject to broad interpretation. Second, the use of fatter pads and other items was so widespread that coaches didn’t complain. The bench bosses didn’t ask officials to check if opposing netminders had the oversized gear because, in many cases, their own goalies also were using it.
“Personally, I suspect that the lower GAA were a direct result of the leniency that the NHL had on enforcing size rules on goalie equipment, particularly the 12-inch wide pad,” said Brian Heaton, who oversees the Heaton and Koho goalie lines for Karhu.
“I’ve certainly heard of requests from some goalkeepers who, on a custom basic wanted wider equipment,” said Ned Goldsmith, a Vaughn Custom Sports’ design engineer. “If that’s want they want, manufacturers will build it for them. But we wouldn’t put anything like that on the shelf at a dealer that could get a goalie booted out of a game.”
Various goal equipment makers have different opinions about oversized gear. Some like, Goldsmith, say its use is still relatively infrequent. Others say it us becoming more commonplace and quietly accepted.
“A lot of the coaches know that the pads are illegal, but they don’t say anything to they officials,” said one equipment maker. They’re all 13-inches wide, so they’re all on equal playing ground.”
Regardless if pads are intentionally made wider, they can fatten somewhat through routine use. “Pads will widen on their own and change shape,” Heaton said.
...
If on-ice officials suspect a goalie is using illegal equipment once a game starts, they won’t stop the contest to measure. However, the referee is empowered to check the equipment between periods. If the gear is not within standards, the goaltender must change to regulation-sized gear before he can continue playing.
If it’s determined that a goaltender used illegal equipment in a game, a report is filed by a supervisor with the NHL’s officiating office in Toronto. In turn, the issue is referred to the commissioner’s office for review and possible discipline, such as a fine.
“Actually, catch gloves might be more of a problem,” said Harris, noting that trappers must not exceed eight inches at the cuff and 15 inches at their widest point. “A couple of years ago, one company I think it was Cooper, added some webbing on the outside. It was a monstrosity. We told them there was no use manufacturing that stuff because we wouldn’t allow it.”
##
I did not write this article, I promise.
The Hockey News - Mar 1 2002 said:There are lies, damn lies and goalie statistics.
...
“It’s always hard to analyze goaltender stats,” said Rand Simon, who specializes in research for the Newport Sports Management agency “Look at the Canadian Olympic team. The goalies are Curtis Joseph, Martin Brodeur and Ed Belfour. None of them are in the league leaders in goalie stats. There must be something else.”
Phoenix goalie Sean Burke seconded that.
“I always thought there was a better way,” Burke said. “When I did my own contract in Hartford, I came up with some categories of my own.”
The Hockey News surveyed nearly a dozen goalies and goalie watchers and found a consensus that NHL goalie stats do not tell the whole story.
...
“They already have the only stat they need - wins,” said Grant Fuhr
..
“Wins and losses are the most overrated stat there is for a goalie,” [Sean Burke] snapped. “Obviously, wins are the only stat that matters from a team standpoint. But it’s not an individual stat in hockey, like it is in golf or tennis. Everybody plays on a different team. Guys on good teams have good stats. Guys on bad teams have bad stats.”
Philadelphia’s Brian Boucher countered: “If you’re on a bad team you get more shots. You’ll have more chances to make saves and your save percentage will better…But it’s tough for a goalie when you face fewer shots. You give up a couple that you had no chance on and your save percentage stinks.”
...
So what do goalies see quantified in their statistical dreams?
“First and foremost, saves at big times of the hockey game,” Fuhr said.
“Quality shots,” said Burke, with St. Louis’s Fred Brathwaite and Boucher in agreement.
“Scoring chances,” said Calgary’s Roman Turek.
Yet scoring chances, which are followed closely by coaching staffs, are not on official goalie records because there’s no clearcut definition. If Detroit’s Brett Hull and Tomas Holmstrom take a slapshot from the same spot, is it the same scoring chance?
...
Edmonton goalie Tommy Salo says stats aren’t needed at all. “You know when a goalie’s good. You don’t have to see the stats.”
Boucher agreed: “People should just watch the game a little more closely.
“Judge a goaltender by that, and not by picking up the paper and reading the box score.”