I know we've already voted him in but I still think it's relevant.
I'm reading through Diary of a Dynasty and it goes game by game in the playoffs. Terry Sawchuk gets the highest of praise in the 1960 and 1961 playoffs. Makes it sound like outside him and Howe, the Red Wings were getting thoroughly outplayed in each series against the Leafs. It's years after his prime but he's talked about as frequently the best player on the ice.